Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Will the Doctor do anything about this? (ExH related)

39 replies

Ismychilddrinkingenough · 18/03/2021 16:18

NC for this in case ExH/Ex-PILs are on here.

DD is 6, year 2. Has some additional needs but is at a mainstream school.

Chatting last week to her teacher and ExH was also there (zoom parents evening – its odd for him though usually he ignores school stuff). I mentioned I’d noticed DD bringing her water bottle home still 3/4s full and asked what DDs drinking at school.

Teacher says she’s never seen DD drink from the water bottle but she doesn’t appear dehydrated. Teacher said knowing DD as she does she’s probably a child who drinks in a routine i.e. she drinks when doing specific things rather than when she’s thirsty. Which makes sense to me, they offer milk or water with the school dinner (which DD loves) and she often says she’s had milk but can’t remember when, also DD is very routine focused, she thrives on a structure – she very rarely at home asks for a drink but that might be because everytime I have one I offer plus she gets one with meals etc without me even really thinking about it. Teacher has said she will remind all the children that they can have a drink when they want one but she can’t do more than that as there’s no specific concern about DD drinking.

ExH has decided that school are preventing her from drinking water and that he’s going to the GP to prove how harmful this is. He wants me to remind DD every morning to finish all her water and wants me to make her drink it at the end of the day if she’s not finished. He says if I don’t support him he will use it as evidence that DD is “unsafe” with me.

DD likes water, milk and of course squash and juice, no-ones ever mentioned it being a problem when I take her to appointments. She’s a healthy weight, below average height but that’s one of her conditions causing that. I asked her teacher about it to see if she’d noticed it but I am reassured that it’s just DD (I am also certain that had the teacher noticed it was an issue she’d have raised it with me before now!). She appears to drink more in the summer when it’s warmer but at a guess with milk at lunchtime, milk on her cereal and water with breakfast, tea and in her water bottle at school she drinks about the right amount.

She doesn’t appear to be thirsty or dehydrated but I only have DD so don’t really have any other children to compare to her.

To add context ExH only sees her for 1 night EOW usually but due to his own –excuses—circumstances he only has her EO Saturday for a few hours at the moment.

So what will the GP do? And will they be bothered about a child appearing to not drink much at school?

OP posts:
Wishitsnows · 19/03/2021 07:42

Your ex sounds like a twat. If he's so bothered let him arrange an appointment and embarrass himself at the Drs

ThePricklySheep · 19/03/2021 07:43

How will your ex know if you are ‘reminding her to drink’ etc? Maybe just agree and then remind her in a half hearted way in case he asks her. You could say ‘drink your drink’ about her school water bottle, but not mind if she doesn’t drink it all.

AlternativePerspective · 19/03/2021 07:45

It’s not 6/8 glasses of water it’s fluid intake equivalent to approx 2 liters.

If she’s having milk on her serial as well as a glass of milk this counts.
If she has sauces and soups those count.

I have a serious heart condition and have a fluid restriction of 1500ml a day as well as having to take diuretics. But fluid is just that. Fluid.

i don’t eat serial now because the milk takes away from what I can drink.

If I have soup then I have to factor that in.

If a child appears dehydrated then it stands to reason that she needs to drink more, but if she’s taking in fluid in different ways then she’s still being hydrated.

People are far too hung up on the 8 glasses a day message that has been put out by ... who? The makers of bottled water perhaps?

woollysheeps · 19/03/2021 07:48

@Purplewithred

The GP will add this to the staffroom competition for "who saw the biggest time wasting idiot this week"
😂😂😂 Brilliant Tell him to up his interactions and learn what real problems are in parenting.
NoSquirrels · 19/03/2021 07:50

I’d love to listen in as he tries to get a GP appointment about this. What a prat.

Practically, how will he know you’re making her drink her water anyway? Just agree she’s got much better at drinking it and don’t mention it again.

If she’s routine driven then can you get her a water bottle with notches marked on it, and remind her to drink down to a notch at each breaktime?

Some kids need less to drink than others - I’ve one kid who’s a camel but then so am I compared to my DH whose fluid consumption is practically an obsession. I wouldn’t worry.

5zeds · 19/03/2021 07:57

Her liquid intake sounds fine. Just ignore the whole thing and reassure him that she’s fine and the teacher agrees if it comes up again. He’s just being annoying.

RainingBatsAndFrogs · 19/03/2021 08:16

His insistence that a child be forced to drink the rest of the bottle at the end of the day is quite chilling.

At least now you know never again to bring up any such subject in his hearing.

ThePricklySheep · 19/03/2021 16:23

@AlternativePerspective

It’s not 6/8 glasses of water it’s fluid intake equivalent to approx 2 liters.

If she’s having milk on her serial as well as a glass of milk this counts.
If she has sauces and soups those count.

I have a serious heart condition and have a fluid restriction of 1500ml a day as well as having to take diuretics. But fluid is just that. Fluid.

i don’t eat serial now because the milk takes away from what I can drink.

If I have soup then I have to factor that in.

If a child appears dehydrated then it stands to reason that she needs to drink more, but if she’s taking in fluid in different ways then she’s still being hydrated.

People are far too hung up on the 8 glasses a day message that has been put out by ... who? The makers of bottled water perhaps?

Less than 2l for a six year old.
RainingBatsAndFrogs · 19/03/2021 16:30

Most food is mostly water.
Fruit, yogurt - loads of fluid.

Even meat is about 75% water.

AlternativePerspective · 19/03/2021 19:50

@ThePricklySheep that was in response to PP who said she should be having 6/8 250ml glasses a day.

ThePricklySheep · 19/03/2021 19:55

[quote AlternativePerspective]**@ThePricklySheep that was in response to PP who said she should be having 6/8 250ml glasses a day.[/quote]
Oh I see.

EugenesAxe · 19/03/2021 19:58

My first thought was 'Well he can jog on then.'

A lot of our water intake is through food anyway. It's only the health gurus that obsess about a certain amount of liquid each day, although I agree it does help with food cravings.

purplepufferfish · 19/03/2021 20:03

What a waste of a GP appointment.

I’m so sorry you’re going through this. What does he think the GP going to do? What a horrible thing to hang over your head.

I really would not worry about this at all. The GP will have a good laugh once your ex hangs up the phone.

BusyLizzie61 · 19/03/2021 20:53

@EugenesAxe

My first thought was 'Well he can jog on then.'

A lot of our water intake is through food anyway. It's only the health gurus that obsess about a certain amount of liquid each day, although I agree it does help with food cravings.

No, the nhs disregards the food intake. Look up. Children’s fluid management. Though this one suggests 1.2l for the op's child age. Which the child is still way off from.

I wouldn't wish to be contributing to a potential longterm kidney or bladder issue myself, if simply encouraging the child to drink could prevent.
Forget about the father's threats. But don't lose sight that it should be the child at the heart of this.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread