Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sulking mil and boundaries!

33 replies

Groundhogday21 · 15/02/2021 17:32

Might be a long one! My mil lives with me. It’s the done thing in my husband’s culture, was warned it would happen on about our 3rd date and although it happened about 10 years before I thought it would, I made my peace with it and she’s been here coming up for 2 years. All in all, I’m glad she’s not stuck in her home country completely alone during these funny times we’re living in and she does spend a fair chunk of time with DH’s sibling occasionally (I consider it to be like a custody arrangement of a child!) We set ground rules right from the off (after I had to say it wasn’t normal to stroll in and out of my bedroom!) saying that as DH and I have the loft room she doesn’t come up unless invited.

We’ve been generally getting along but with 2 primary aged children homeschooling and a new baby that she likes to give her opinion on every 2 minutes I’ve been biting my tongue more than usual. Today I left baby playing in his chair in the kids bedroom with my other 2 whilst I popped upstairs for a quick shower. She was in another room and DH is also a working from home in the guest room next to them so only a shout away. I had my 2 minute shower in the loft en-suite with the door going from the bathroom to my bedroom ajar to stop the steam but so I could still hear the kids and the door going to the downstairs wide open. I got out of the shower and thought the baby sounded close and figured my eldest had carried him up and laid him on my bed, so towel in hand and naked I pull the bathroom door fully open to see mil standing in my bedroom holding the baby! Now I have no issue with my husband or my kids seeing my jiggly post baby body but mil is a step too far! I quickly swung the door shut and heard her say something about clothes, I wrapped myself in my towel, opened the door again, grabbed my clean clothes off my bed and slammed the bathroom door and got dressed in there. DH appeared 2 minutes later with the baby who needed a change of clothes, which is what mil had been trying to find in my room. I changed baby then cuddled him in for a nap on my bed and calmed myself down.

When I went downstairs an hour or so later she apologised profusely and said she was just trying to help, I said forget it. She then started crying and said she’d made things worse, she hadn’t had lunch due to worrying about me and I ended up comforting her saying it doesn’t matter. But it does matter! She had called up to me but I didn’t answer, maybe she thought I was hiding or playing, who knows? For clarification baby has a changing mat and stuff downstairs in the living room too so he wasn’t going to suffer if she’d stayed out of my space! After a bit of a frosty lunch I went back upstairs in a bid to stop myself getting more irate at her sad face, feeling sorry for herself and she went to bed, which is where she’s stayed ever since, ignoring her normal 4pm cup of tea. She’s worse than the kids for sulking. I have a feeling in her retelling of this story I’ll be the bad guy for leaving the pooey baby, not being grateful for her assistance and then keeping my distance from her all afternoon and there will be no mention of her overstepping boundaries yet again.

So AIBU here? Surely I shouldn’t need to remind her about personal space over and over? I read stories of people upset with mils that they see twice a year and sometimes I’m jealous! 😂

OP posts:
NailsNeedDoing · 15/02/2021 17:41

Yanbu to be a bit upset about it, but you do need to let it go. If she shouted for you and you ignored her, you’ve lost on the moral high ground. She was trying to help your baby, she’s said sorry, and she clearly feels bad about it. Be nice to her.

MaLarkinn · 15/02/2021 17:43

I can top that.... after the difficult birth of my first child and and 10 stitches later my ex mil walked into my bedroom when my bits were being checked by my midwife to tell her to check my stitches as I'd been moaning about the pain. My midwife went to town on her.
By my 3rd child, I just told her to fuck off.

Your mil didn't expect you to walk out and you didn't expect her to be there but it's time for a chat regardless.

I think you were probably more upset she'd seen you naked.

Mellonsprite · 15/02/2021 17:47

I understand why you are annoyed, but she was doing this from a good place and you hadn’t heard her shout up. Unfortunately you will look like the bad guy, as annoying as it is if you remind her again. Best just to let this one go now.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 15/02/2021 17:51

She's dramatic, for sure,but you sound the same.

I'm confused as to why you would leave a small baby alone with your other children when there are two other adults in the house who could have had him while you showered - the bonus to this being that MIL would then have known what you had disappeared for.

Why wait an hour before going back downstairs to speak to her?

OldEvilOwl · 15/02/2021 17:52

Yanbu to be upset that she saw you naked. However she didn't try and walk in on you. She's obviously upset too, take her a cup of tea and both forget about it?

Jobsharenightmare · 15/02/2021 17:58

Her heart was in the right place and she didn't deliberately walk in on you so I'd let it go and expect her to as well. I wouldn't have left the baby to be watched by its siblings when your MIL could have watched it. Taking her at her word your decision led to this in the first place as she did shout you. I don't think it does matter really as she won't be doing it again!

olivesnutsandcheeseplease · 15/02/2021 18:01

Crazy idea but could you ask MIL to watch the baby for you whilst you take a shower? Surely you should get some benefit of her living with you?

suspiria777 · 15/02/2021 18:02

i would probably be a bit shocked in the moment too, OP, but YABU.
You don't really like her being there, and it clouds every interaction you have with her. Imagine if she had left your child crying and dirty for the whole hour+ you were upstairs? You might say now that you wouldn't have minded at all, but I'd wager you'd be annoyed. So in the scenario there's no way for her to win -- either she comes into your room or she neglects your child.

Let it go.

SharonasCorona · 15/02/2021 18:06

I’d hate living my MIL, although she’s lovely. (I’m Asian).

However, it sounds like perhaps the baby cried and MIL was worried or that your DH asked her to get baby clothes?

The fact that she apologised profusely suggests she respects your rules and was worried about baby.

The sulking is not good. Why does she have to live with her son? Maybe she feels like a burden?

Whitecup4 · 15/02/2021 18:11

No!! I’d be furious if MIL saw me naked because she came into my room!! Especially if she has been told before to stay out!

No mans worth having to live with another adult on top. Not just a mother in law but any other adult- I couldn’t do it- your a stronger women than me, or more foolish?

Bluetrews25 · 15/02/2021 18:13

1 - why could she not have changed him herself?
2 - is she deaf? Could she not hear the shower running as she got close?
3 - why did she have to do the forbidden (enter your space) and then do the drama llama victim playing?
4 - do you need a patio? Wink

Groundhogday21 · 15/02/2021 18:19

She’s reappeared now full of compliments for dinner and being overly nice. I didn’t give her the baby as she was praying downstairs and I didn’t want to disturb her so left him within earshot of DH in the next bedroom instead. If she called it was incredibly quiet as I could hear the kids playing in their room but not the call. I wasn’t showering for an hour, I was only a few minutes, didn’t even wash my hair! We often spend the afternoon apart; she calls her family in her bedroom and I study whilst baby naps next to me. I think I’ve just found this week difficult as she’s been at sil (my support bubble purely for moving mil around freely) and I’ve got to get used to her being here again. The only reason that we had the talk about boundaries is because when she moved in I kept waking up in the morning with her sat on the end of my bed, but I thought we’d moved past that. I know she really does mean well but that doesn’t stop her being suffocating at times, I suppose a few other smaller things lead to me being annoyed about this, and I haven’t seen my own mum or family since last summer which must cloud my judgment too, so I’ll accept I’m BU.

OP posts:
katy1213 · 15/02/2021 18:20

Well, I'd hate it - but it's what you signed up for! I shouldn't think any man is worth it - but he did warn you.

TillyTopper · 15/02/2021 18:21

If she can carry a baby upstairs why can't see change the baby herself? I'd be really fed up with that tbh. Perhaps it's time to go to the other sibling for a bit?!

Snaketime · 15/02/2021 18:24

I totally understand the whole boundaries thing and I can understand why you would be upset about your MIL seeing you naked, but I do think on the whole in this situation YABU. Why couldnt you just go to you MIL in the first place and say baby is playing happily in his chair and the older 2 are doing their school work, I am going to pop up for a shower, I wont be long but can you please keep an ear out, you know where the changing stuff is, don't come in my room for anything else as I will be walking about naked.
That way she would know where you were and why you were there. In situations like this communication is key.
That said your MIL IBU sulking like a child.

Stovetopespresso · 15/02/2021 18:25

i'm sure it will blow over op, although yanbu. sounds like a challenging situation. try not to let it take root. we are all living in close quarters with others and there is a danger of beginning to take on each others characterisitcs and standards, that's natural, but remember to be youself, and move on

Groundhogday21 · 15/02/2021 18:28

For the record DH is firmly on my side in most instances, I don’t make unreasonable demands and he knows there aren’t many who would take in their mil full time. Lockdown has been a blessing in disguise for me for him to see how stressful she can be to live with as he hasn’t spent so much time with her since he was a child! She’s always just trying to help, it’s just sometimes it is a bit much Smile

OP posts:
CrazyOldBagLady · 15/02/2021 18:33

How did she know the baby needed changing if you were 2 minutes showering and the house was quiet all that time? Did she respond to the baby crying or the other children calling for assistance?

It sounds to me like she picked the lesser of two evils, getting the baby sorted over upsetting you by being in your room. It's just unfortunate you appeared stark bollock naked at the same time. I'd try and laugh this one off and put it down to bad luck.

MaLarkinn · 15/02/2021 18:33

I get it kp, my ex mil used to come for months at a time with no return date in sight.

It drove me crazy, especially when she'd butter her toast, lick her fingers and then pick up my marmalade jar.

It's the little things Grin

Do you ever get time to yourself?

Butterymuffin · 15/02/2021 18:33

I think your DH is getting off a bit lightly here. Why couldn't he have actually had the baby for 5 minutes while you showered? And why didn't your MIL, when you didn't answer, go to your DH as the other parent? He seems to get tiptoed around at your expense.

Hankunamatata · 15/02/2021 18:36

I'm sorry but the waking up with her at the end of the bed - made me spit my tea out laughing. Awful but kinda funny if your not in the situation.

Groundhogday21 · 15/02/2021 18:38

MaLarkinn Not at the moment no, but I can’t be the only one! Baby wasn’t crying, just making cooing baby noises, she just picked him up and brought him straight to my room, rather than going downstairs, at the exact moment I stepped out of the bathroom. I think she thinks DH is above a nappy change... he is a man after all!

OP posts:
yvanka · 15/02/2021 18:39

I kept waking up in the morning with her sat on the end of my bed

Yikes!

Get DH to firmly explain that she is not allowed in your bedroom unless there is an emergency. You are being more than accommodating and are entitled to a safe space in your home.

ThePoetsWife · 15/02/2021 18:42

Baby was next to DH. Why didn't he change him then????

MessagesKeepGettingClearer · 15/02/2021 18:45

YABU.

She usually respects your space. Today, she thought to help as you and the dad were busy. She cocked up and happened to see you naked.

I actually don't think leaving the baby alone with two primary age children is appropriate. You should have brought baby in with you in the bathroom.

Your MIL is clearly upset and worried you'll be deeply offended. Just forgive her and move on. You both sound a bit dramatic tbh.

Swipe left for the next trending thread