Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you give up maintenance in this situation?

31 replies

MaintenanceOrNoMaintenance · 04/02/2021 14:20

DD is 6. I earn £30k per year, plus DD has some disabilities so I get LRC for her, plus child benefit and maintenance so my total income is around £32k per year.

The area I live in isn’t expensive. We are in council housing as DD needs certain things due to her disabilities (she’s on the cusp of qualifying for MRC and LRM) so my total rent plus council tax is under £600pm.

I am using a mixture of furlough for childcare reasons and annual leave at the moment (DD goes to a mainstream school as her issues are mainly related to her muscles and not due to social or learning issues) so my bills have increased slightly but I can more than meet it. My car is paid for by work and I only have to cover fuel and insurance for personal use which works out at about £100 a month (DDs conditions mean I try and walk everywhere as it’s really good for her). I have savings as I am planning to buy a house when DD is 18 either so she can live with me permanently or so she has some stability should something happen to me but I can dip into my savings if I need to. I am also saving some money as the therapies and activities that DD does to help her conditions are not currently allowed to open (swimming and gymnastics she does these in a mainstream class with some of her school friends so not open atm).

ExH pays £100 a month maintenance. On paper he earns around £10k a year but most of his assets are paid for by his parents through their business so he has maybe around double that, still a lot less than me.

I’ve recently been feeling guilty about taking maintenance off ExH. He has DD EOW overnight but due to his situation has only seen her once a month since August for a few hours. So at the moment I am her parent 100% of the time (as I can’t really do much in those 2 hours).

I know ExH is struggling financially, his parents only run his assets like that as he’s had problems with keeping a roof over his head so it’s more for DDs benefit than to hide assets from CM. He also has addiction problems although I’m sure he’s clean at the moment and has been for a long time.

For context ExH and I split due to his violence and control in 2017 but we get on mostly ok. We didn’t work as a couple but as friends and parents to DD we do get on ok although I’d never trust myself to be 100% alone with him. He was never violent in front of DD and has never raised his hands to her, if anything he’s the opposite and a bit of a Disney dad.

ExH has not asked to reduce the maintenance, I’m thinking about it. DD will not go without if I accept less, the bills will still get paid, there will still be food in the cupboards, our pets will still get fed and housed.

WWYD? Accept less maintenance or none?

YABU - Continue to take the maintenance
YANBU - don't take the maintenance

OP posts:
Excited85 · 04/02/2021 15:19

Going against the grain here I’m in a similar situation in that my financial circumstances are better than my exes and as a result I’ve never asked him for a penny. He struggles with his mental health and just about gets by ok financially but his outgoings are high and I won’t be the person responsible for worsening his quality of life by asking for money off him that I don’t need for my daughter, as I can and do provide her all she needs. I figure it’s far better for DD that she has stability with him and her dad is able to treat her to the odd thing and generally be happy when she’s in his presence, than to sacrifice those things just for me to take a chunk of his hard earned money and shove it in savings for her. She won’t thank me for the money if it has led to him struggling financially and hence impacted his mental health and her childhood with him.

However..... much of this is set around the time they spend together which is EOW and a few hours a couple of times a week. Considering your ex isn’t taking on much on an active role at the minute this would probably lead me to suggest sticking with things as they are for now and keeping the contribution at the moment.

picklemewalnuts · 04/02/2021 15:21

Let him have some self respect from knowing he has contributed towards his daughter. He bears none of the costs apart from this.

MaintenanceOrNoMaintenance · 04/02/2021 16:14

@Excited85

Going against the grain here I’m in a similar situation in that my financial circumstances are better than my exes and as a result I’ve never asked him for a penny. He struggles with his mental health and just about gets by ok financially but his outgoings are high and I won’t be the person responsible for worsening his quality of life by asking for money off him that I don’t need for my daughter, as I can and do provide her all she needs. I figure it’s far better for DD that she has stability with him and her dad is able to treat her to the odd thing and generally be happy when she’s in his presence, than to sacrifice those things just for me to take a chunk of his hard earned money and shove it in savings for her. She won’t thank me for the money if it has led to him struggling financially and hence impacted his mental health and her childhood with him.

However..... much of this is set around the time they spend together which is EOW and a few hours a couple of times a week. Considering your ex isn’t taking on much on an active role at the minute this would probably lead me to suggest sticking with things as they are for now and keeping the contribution at the moment.

That's how I feel, when there wasn't a lockdown/restrictions he was consistent in seeing her EOW overnight she liked going and that was what was important. It's only now due to the restrictions he can't have her overnight, but we're hoping when they lift he'll be able to again.
OP posts:
KarmaNoMore · 04/02/2021 19:56

As people have said, paying maintenance is the only thing he is doing for his child. Making it optional makes your child, in his mind, something that he can take or drop as he needs.

Keep the constant, it is good for your ex and child. Or save it for rainy days, if he has the problem he has, what reassurances you get that by declining maintenance you are providing the extra money he needs to go back into his addiction or other destructive behaviours?

SarahBellam · 04/02/2021 20:08

Good Lord no. He’s a grown man. He does not need your pity. If he’s not making enough it’s his responsibility to find a way to make some more. Do not make his problem your problem. It’s important both for your daughter and for his self esteem and engagement. £100 is less that he should be paying. You are shouldering the responsibility for most of the costs. What would happen if you lost your job or got sick? You need to think longer term. The other reason is that it would likely be really difficult to get him to return to the original arrangement once he started earning well again.

MaintenanceOrNoMaintenance · 04/02/2021 20:40

@ItsNotAlrightButItsOkay

I'm sorry I don't have any advice for what you're asking. I was just wondering if your daughter has what my daughter has (JIA) and if so, Can I pick your brains? Sorry if I've got confused. X
Sorry not JIA I hope you get the help you need though x
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread