Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to question whether my child should go to her dad

29 replies

Nodramalama36 · 17/01/2021 15:10

Really in need of advice from ppl in a similar experience

Have a ten year old DD. It’s just me at home with her.

For as long as I can remember she never wants to see her dad, for no other reason than she misses me and that they are a bit stricter than me. It causes stress sometimes I’m drained as I’m trying to manage him who obviously wants to see his dd as much as possible and then her who struggles being away from me. Iv always thought it’s just cos she is used to a different way here ie if she is upset she can get in my bed, I’m more cuddly etc there’s more rules there but nothing too bad. She has come home and said the odd thing iv raised my eye brows about but and if I’m honest she struggles to say no to them
Or assert herself.

She came out upset today her younger sister called her fattie is explained it’s not great but siblings do this and she should either tell her dad, tell her sister not to or laugh it off depending how she feels about it. We got talking and she told me that her dad sometimes can use physical force with the children not actual hitting but a smack on the bum. Agin we don’t have this at home I’m dead against it but I explained it’s not out the norm but she is too old for that he has never and would never with her. She agreed but then told me that when she was 4 she had an accident in the night and got scared so tried to clea. It herself (poo) and then it got everywhere and she was crying so they came in. She said his wife was so angry and told her off she was repeating it as though it was yesterday. I feel like crying for her and it’s made me feel so sad. There way is a lot different to mine and I’m trying to be mindful and open but my daughter has got chronic constipiatiin from with holding iv had to have words with him about ensuring he is not shaming her etc as that’s not the way to manage it. She actually only really overcome it last lock down when she didn’t see him. I’m now wondering is this why? I remember at the time she was upset she had an accident and that his wife was upset. She was very pregnant at the time and I could tell that she was more short tempered, but I feel like this is something g traumatic for my daughter.

I want to encourage her to see her dad and family hut she is constantly saying she doesn’t want to go and says things like she doesn’t feel comfortable going down in the morning. She said she feel scared even though her dad hasn’t shouted at her or anything. She is a sensitive child and I do feel like he does try a lot with her but I’m just worried what will come out years down the line now.
I want her to be happy in life. He has got annoyed at times when I have collected her rather than her staying overnight because she was upset, he wants her there and had used things it’s upsetting for her sibling when she doesn’t. But I also need to do the right thing for her and right now I don’t know what that is!
Any ideas experienced?
I was also thinking maybe I should send her for some kind of therapy or something. I don’t want her memories as a child to be unhappy. Prior to lockdown she used to wake up in tears before she went and one day she told me ‘I dread every weekend being away from you’ whilst sobbing.

OP posts:
Rtmhwales · 17/01/2021 21:13

Honestly it sounds like anxiety. What is she like away from you in other situations? I'm thinking school or overnight camps or at the grandparents'.

If you say her father is generally a loving, caring parent (albeit more strict) I'm not sure it's worth cutting down his time with her. I just can't imagine if my DC decided they felt like this at my house that I'd be happy to let them go live at XH's full time. I'd want to explore other possibilities first. It's too bad he won't consider skipping the overnights for a while but I can kind of see his point .. if it's just about staying overnight that sounds more like anxiety about sleeping somewhere else/away from mum than a general unhappiness about visiting dad's house.

Aspiringmatriarch · 17/01/2021 21:50

Rtmhwales I think exploring other options first is missing the point that the daughter is specifically very anxious and unhappy staying overnight. How many other options are there? She can see him but not stay overnight, or be forced to stay. Surely the latter would be potentially detrimental to her relationship with both parents, not to mention the distress it could cause. Better to let her build back to that at her own pace and with good communication all round, than tear her away from where she feels safe and expect it to just be ok? You say you wouldn't be happy if it was the other way round and your DC wanted to live with your ex full time, and I'm sure none of us would. But I'm guessing you're not in that situation, and if you were there would be many factors which would need to be dealt with, while putting your DCs' needs and emotional welfare first.

Aspiringmatriarch · 17/01/2021 21:54

It must be horrible for her to see her sibling being smacked as well. I wouldn't feel happy in that situation now, let alone as a ten year old. Horrible.

TaraR2020 · 17/01/2021 22:08

If it helps with discussions with her dad, I don't think nighttime anxiety is unusual while a child. When I think about it, however used to staying over ay grandparents or my dads I was the being in bed in a different house could be a little unnerving at times. It was never so bad for me as to upset me, but I think these things do effect you more as a child and there isn't always rhyme or reason to it, it just isn't home. Children also go through clingy periods growing up and maybe the two are coinciding.

Like it many things with children, I suspect the more it is made into a big deal the bigger a deal it will be.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread