Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU Conversation stoppers

12 replies

Bella43 · 13/12/2020 14:31

For a while now I've realised that my family have little interest in me. They don't ask me questions about my job or life and when I try to engage them on either they look bored or block any hope of expanding on what I'm saying with a conversation stopper like, 'Did you? That reminds me, remember so and so who used to work in Tesco...' and that's the end of that.

I've recently had a change of career (a massive step for a quiet person like myself) which requires a lot of study and lots to talk about! I love it and would love to tell my family how I'm doing but every time I try their interest is very limited. They might allow one or two sentences from me before I get another conversation stopper. They love talking about their own interests, work, gossip. All of which I engage in and ask loads of questions (except the gossip as that's a little nasty). I often wonder how they respond when they're out and about and people ask about me. I doubt they could tell them much as they never listen. They don't even know what my degree is in.

My sister, however, is treated differently. She lives an hour away, visits twice a year and my family thrive on those visits. They ask about her job, life, boyfriend, make tea and bake beforehand. When I visit I'm told to put the kettle on. Make your own tea. Oh you haven't washed up your cup have you? That sort of thing. I visit once a fortnight for an hour and even then I'm made to feel I've outstayed my welcome. My mother will often yawn as I'm talking! I feel I'm being conditioned or trained not to talk about myself as it goes nowhere and I come home feeling upset that they have no interest in me. It's been this way for years. My mother has even criticised my clothes and appearance (I wear smart/casual and mostly tie my hair back) and have been compared to my sister who wears power suits and has beautifully straightened hair. I get on well with my sister but can't help feeling sad that we're treated differently. They'd never speak to her the way they speak to me. They change completely when she visits. She's treated like a guest. Even their voices and mannerisms take on a formal air. They never visit her. She doesn't allow that. I always leave fairly early into her visits so they can have their time with her uninterrupted. They will talk about this visit for months afterwards saying how well she looks, how happy and successful she is etc.

My sister went years without speaking to them. We always kept in touch though. Although we've never discussed it, I think my sister realises as I do that our family is not like others. Now she's been back in touch with them for the past few years and it's all on her own terms. She visits. They don't. It's like she's trained THEM.

I was watching Strictly last night. It was lovely to hear Maisie call her mum her best friend. I've never had this. I've tried but my mother isn't affectionate at all. She never rings me either. I probably need counselling but hate the thought of actually telling someone about this as it'll make it all real. I've buried this hurt for years. I do have wonderful friends who love asking me about my life. I just feel sad that my family seem so distanced from me. AIBU to want more from them or should I just accept that this is all I'll ever get?

OP posts:
FangsForTheMemory · 13/12/2020 14:39

They are taking you for granted. I would stop visiting every couple of weeks. Once a month for half an hour is enough. They know where you are if they want to speak to you. Don't be so available. Fill your life with other people and things. You can't control how your family behave. You CAN control how you feel about it. You have a bit opportunity to make new friends and change your life - grab it with both hands. All the best.

Nottherealslimshady · 13/12/2020 14:42

I dont think you should compare to your sister. It's a very different situation. Personally I'd hate to be a guest at a parents house.
I get that it's annoying that they dont ask lots of questions and do her but if you see them more regular then theres less new stuff. Just tell them stuff though, they dont need to ask.

I do understand how you feel, but I think you'd benefit from looking at it differently, you're closer to them really than she is by the sounds of it. They dont sound comfortable with her like they are with you.

OrigamiOwl · 13/12/2020 15:21

They take you for granted. Take a leaf out of your sister's book... Don't visit them as often, don't be so available to them.
Someone has got to go away for you to miss them...

HollowTalk · 13/12/2020 15:24

I wouldn't be visiting every fortnight if they treat you like that. It must take you those two weeks to get over the previous visit.

Do you and your sister ever get together on your own?

nosswith · 13/12/2020 15:31

I agree with visiting less often. You could use a Covid related excuse to miss the next visit, as a starter.

picklemewalnuts · 13/12/2020 16:53

Ditch them. Stay in touch with your sister. Wait until your parents invite you to visit.

dexterslockedintheshedagain · 13/12/2020 16:59

Why did your sister cut them off for so long? I agree with PP, don't make yourself so available for them. Easier said than done I know, but if it changes the dynamic-great. If it doesn't-well, you've lost nothing. Stop trying to please people who can't be arsed to please you.

Aquamarine1029 · 13/12/2020 17:04

I think therapy could be very empowering for you, and I also strongly believe you should back WAY off from them. Visiting them only makes you feel terrible. Why do that to yourself?

Persephoned · 13/12/2020 17:10

Maybe you could visit your sister OP? If you get on well do you have an independent relationship with her? If not it might be nice to try and develop one, suggest a few catch ups on the phone, an hour away is close enough to go and meet her just for lunch or something too.

Evans800 · 13/12/2020 17:20

Do you visit your sister? Have you ever talked about the reasons why she went NC with them for a couple of years?

I would definitely be cutting back on visits and lowering my expectations of them to match what they have shown they are willing to give/are capable of.

I would start my halving it all - so once a month for 30 mins and not offering as much information about your life to them.

HeckyPeck · 13/12/2020 17:26

I agree with PP re visiting less, particularly as you're coming back from visits feeling upset.

I wouldn't make a big deal about it to them - just say your busy with work/study etc.

Spend the time and energy on friends and other family who appreciate you.

Also congratulations on the new job!

Bella43 · 14/12/2020 09:11

Thabkbyou for your messages. You're right. I'm making myself too available and giving them the opportunity to make me feel like this. I've backed off these past few days and will only visit once a month going forwards. I've also decided not to talk about myself unless they ask me a question. Perhaps that way they'll have some interest in finding out what I'm doing. It's sad really as all my friends want to do when we meet up is ask questions! They're all excited to find out about my new job. Like you've all said, I need to surround myself with their company and make more friends rather than expecting something more from my family.

My sister's distance from them is a long story. My mother left my father (he then left the family home). My mother instantly got together with my now stepfather (they must've been having an affair). She moved him into the family home within weeks. Both my sister and I moved out of the family home a few years before all of this but my sister took it all really bad as my stepfather has a daughter (around my age) and my mother immersed herself into the new role of stepmother. This included shopping trips with my now stepsister, Facebook pics together on hers and ss's acccounts. In these pics my mother was hugging her and this was hard for my sister to take I guess (she never directly said) as my mother was never affectionate towards us. This affection/closeness towards ss extends to this very day! She'll put lengthy messages on Christmas/Birthday cards, they'll go for meals, my mother knows everything that's going on in her life. It's bizarre. For the record I like ss and there's never been any animosity between us. Life's too short and all that. My sister's not so forgiving. She has never spoken to ss. When my sister visits, ss knows to stay away that day.

I don't have an independent relationship with my sister. She works very long hours. I work and have children. She doesn't have children. I think she tried but it never happened. She never goes into any great detail about her personal life. I've thought of maybe writing to her to see if we can build a closer relationship.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page