Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister offended that we want to socially distance

8 replies

MOGMOGMOG85 · 28/11/2020 10:09

Since the start of the pandemic my sister has been personally offended by me and others sticking to government rules and socially distancing. I'm not assuming this, she has admitted she gets personally offended and feels hurt and annoyed about it and has said she would prefer not to see anyone at all than to have to socially distance i.e. go for a walk keeping a distance and not hugging hello/goodbye etc. I have seen her with the same regularity as I usually would during the pandemic as before (once every couple of months - we are a couple of hours drive away from each other), either I go to hers for a walk or she comes to mine - more usually I go to hers because I'm a confident driver and she's not, although she is happy to get the train to mine. Until recently I've been pregnant throughout the whole pandemic and so I've always asked that I can use her toilet if I'm visiting her, but apart from that I avoid her house and we walk which we both enjoy. Her husband was very anxious about the pandemic at the start and its possible me using the toilet was awkward for them but they would always sterilise and bleach everything after I went. I would always insist that she can use our bathroom if she came to visit us but she would always refuse. Every time we meet she always mentions how much she hates socially distancing, how isolated and alienated it makes her feels and that she actually feels worse seeing me socially distanced than not seeing me at all. Once I gave her a big hug goodbye because I could see how upset she was, so I guess I've been inconsistent about following the rules myself and perhaps that is even more annoying to her?

I'm not pregnant any more and our first child was born a few weeks ago. My sister came to visit yesterday and she was the first family member to see our son. On the phone she insisted she didn't want to come inside our flat and we would go for a walk. In theory this sounded nice but on the day my son was stuck on my breast constantly and in a fussy mood and after 10m of trying to prepare to leave the house and failing I just said she should come inside. I was happy to have her inside with all the windows open and the heating switched up to compensate, and realistically my son was not going to be able to leave the house happily. She came in but was really awkward about it and refused to sit down until we insisted (we have a huge living room with 2 huge open windows and seating more than 2 meters apart. Then she mentioned that she was going to spend Christmas with our mum which was news to me - we are in a support bubble with Mum and I had thought we were going to spend Christmas with her. Throughout the pandemic she has been careful not to spend too much time indoors with Mum because she is a secondary school teacher and there are always outbreaks of the virus at her school and Mum has heart failure and has a high fatality likelihood if she contracts the virus. She always asks me what I think/seeks my approval if she is going to go visit Mum, but I'm not sure why she does this as they are 2 adults and I'm obviously never going to say I think its a great idea given her job and Mums health. Throughout the pandemic she has admitted that because she hates socially distancing she doesn't do it with anyone else who doesn't want to, and that her and her colleagues at school basically ignore social distancing and mix with the kids and each other. I'm fine with that, it's her choice, but she genuinely seems annoyed that I have wanted to be more strict (although not totally as I've mentioned), despite the fact I have been in a vulnerable category as a pregnant woman for the whole thing.

The meeting yesterday was brief and awkward, she acted wounded and quickly left, and didnt' seem that interested in our son, although I think that was because she was hurt and upset that she couldn't interact with us and him in the usual way, that the windows were open and we were socially distancing etc.

I feel hurt that she acts like this because its not like its my preference that we socially distance - I would never not want people to cuddly my son, or not want people at Christmas if it wasn't for this pandemic - she is acting as though its my choice to be distant and reduce social contact but I'm unhappy about it too - I don't like feeling distant from people and I can't wait for this to be over but in the mean time I am taking some precautions roughly in line with government guidance, sometimes more stringent than government rules (I didnt ever do eat out to help out etc) and sometimes breaking rules like hugging her that one time because I felt it was important as she seemed really sad. But none of this is my choice, its not what I want.

Anyone else having difficulty in the run up to Christmas with family, and how best to deal with someone who takes the whole pandemic situation personally? Am I a hypocrite for breaking the rules sometimes? It honestly makes me feel like I'm a bad person or like I'm deliberately being cold or distant with her when I'm not, it is just the pandemic situation, although after so long of this being taken personally I do genuinely feel weird around her now and she acts weird with me - worried it is genuinely damaging our relationship, but still don't want to break all the rules all of the time for this one person.

OP posts:
Namerchanger42 · 28/11/2020 10:22

I’m a bit confused about your sisters stance... is it that she dislikes social distancing, wants to be more ‘normal’ and freely mixes at school but then if so why the anxiety about using the loo? Why was she annoyed to come into your house, if she’s happy to mix at school?
You are not unreasonable for sticking to the rules though, it’s her choice if she wants to break them.
I understand the bubble thing might be annoying for you though, we’ve got a similar arrangement but another part of the bubble have also deciding that they are a seeing another family too, on a different day which in total means they’ve broken the 3 family aspect. I fear that it’s going to cause a lot of family disputes of who’s in and out of bubbles.

MOGMOGMOG85 · 28/11/2020 10:43

@Namerchanger42 this Christmas is DEF going to exacerbate a lot of family tensions you're so right - it can already be challenging for people and now we have covid and different people feeling differently about it, its going to be a nightmare!

I think she's trying to be considerate of other peoples anxieties about the virus (i.e. trying to be considerate that I'm taking social distancing more seriously) by making a big deal about not using the toilet but actually I am happy for her to use the toilet and have said so and I invited her into my flat - wouldn't do that if I didn't want to/wasn't consenting. Its all very mixed up she is clearly upset about the whole thing.

OP posts:
Nottherealslimshady · 28/11/2020 10:51

YANBU to follow the rules. But some people really need a lot of human contact and I really feel for those people at the moment. It must be really hard to not have the contact you need with people. I do not like a lot of human contact, but if I'm away from my husband then I miss him and his touch so I imagine that it's like that for people who really do need those hugs and closeness. But you can't put your health at risk to facilitate that.

Hayeahnobut · 28/11/2020 10:53

Social distancing is very difficult for some people, it's human nature to want to physically interact with each other. Isolation/ non contact can be very damaging to a person's mental health.

You need to find some common ground. You do sound extremely (over) anxious about it, which you mention you might have picked up from your husband. Equally she could be more careful with her contacts before Christmas Day. On the school issue, it's impossible to SD in most schools, and again, very damaging to a child's mental health.

Hayeahnobut · 28/11/2020 10:55

But you can't put your health at risk to facilitate that.

Mental health is just as important as physical health. Ask any member of the mental health profession, and they'll tell you the damage these measures are having on people. Mental health kills too.

Skysblue · 28/11/2020 10:57

Hey OP my sister is so similar! She has said she doesn’t want to see me again until I’ve stopped social distancing. I’m hurt and puzzled as I don’t see what’s so hard about staying a metre or two apart while out for a walk. (She thinks the virus threat has been exaggerated, doesn’t do any kind of distancing, and finds it irritating than I do.)

I think some people are just a bit weaker than others and can’t manage the situation to be honest. 🤷‍♀️

With your sister I imagine she found it painful not being able to interact normally with the baby and is giving up / looking for a row as a release for the tension.

Be gentle with each ofher for now. Hopefully over soon once vaccines are out.

Namerchanger42 · 28/11/2020 11:13

Ultimately we all have to take our decisions based on how we feel and can manage best ourselves. What’s right for one is not right for another and we shouldn’t try to influence or pressurise people.
I upset my mum last night by being too blunt and direct about the bubbles situation at Christmas (see my post above), and I feel really bad about it now, as It’s so unlike me. What was sustainable for a short period, or tolerable in the good weather isn’t in the long term. She can’t dictate to you how to behave.... we just have to try and get through it now. Best wishes Flowers

SimplyRadishing · 28/11/2020 12:53

It's a weird time

People are struggling with their mental health I would try to keep things calm and not get too excited about anything.

Fwiw while id generally say spend it together being a teacher complicates it

What does your mum think???

New posts on this thread. Refresh page