Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to ask parents to respect our boundaries?

42 replies

PaisleyCrib · 14/11/2020 16:20

Have also posted in relationships.

This might seem silly but I want to make sure I raise something sensitively with my parents, to avoid any bad feeling, and I need some help with how to do it! A bit of background info will be necessary so apologies for the long post.

We recently purchased a house for my parents to live in, which is about half an hour away from us (they currently live 3 hours away). We are financially very comfortable and it felt good to be able to help them in this way (they will sell their own house and invest the proceeds to generate an income for their retirement, while living in the new house rent free). We are over the moon to have them closer and have always been close. In turn, they help us with our 3 kids and multiple pets. They love the area and love the new house.

This is the hard bit: we want to make sure that certain boundaries are put in place, for the sake of everyone’s happiness. They are the sort of people who think nothing of walking into our house without knocking, at any time of the day or evening, to just say hello!! I’m fine with this as they’re my parents but I realise I wouldn’t want my in laws doing this, and DH wants to make sure that the new arrangement works without us feeling that we’ve sacrificed our privacy. How can I raise this with them without potentially sounding rude?? It’s pretty foreign to the way that they think. I definitely don’t want them to think we’re having second thoughts after they’ve been through the upheaval of leaving their lifelong home and town and all their friends. They are fully independent and physically fit so that’s not the problem, but they just don’t seem to realise that DH needs evenings alone sometimes... they generally don’t have a strong sense of privacy/ personal space and so I just want to avoid problems in future.
IABU - don’t raise this with parents as it could upset them
IANBU - you should talk to them (suggestions on how to raise it very welcome!)

OP posts:
rorosemary · 14/11/2020 17:45

I’m fine with this as they’re my parents but I realise I wouldn’t want my in laws doing this, and DH wants to make sure that the new arrangement works without us feeling that we’ve sacrificed our privacy.

I think that this is a pretty good explanation tbh. Just tell them.

Incrediblytired · 14/11/2020 17:52

We had this with my in laws and one day they popped in when we were on our way out for dinner and we had to reject them at the door - so next time I saw them I just said “I’m sooo sorry about the other day, I felt awful turning you away, please can you ring in future just to check with are in?” Then they felt guilty and now they ring but don’t pop in!

Nostrings457 · 14/11/2020 17:54

I would speak to them and say DH has asked me to ask you not call over unannounced..Grin

PaisleyCrib · 14/11/2020 17:59

I’ve just realised I made it sound like half an hour drive... it’s actually half an hour walk!! Hence the worries over dropping in. In the car, it’s a very short journey!

OP posts:
LightDrizzle · 14/11/2020 18:06

I'd wait until the first time they drop-in without warning, then raise it.
I wouldn't have liked this with my own parents, never mind in-laws. It is good that you are thinking of your husband's different threshold in this.

Just say that evenings together are precious as you both work, please could they ring if they are thinking of coming.

lazylump72 · 14/11/2020 18:09

OP you have done a lovely thing for your parents..my advice..do nothing atleast not for now. Let them find their feet and make new friends and a new life in a new home and see how the land lies then.Explain to your hubby he has to be slightly more understanding and tolerant just for the short term as its new to all of you. I genuinely feel once they are settled it will not be such an issue for you. Give it time....Your parents must be very proud of you I think,I would be!

PaisleyCrib · 14/11/2020 21:37

@lazylump72 thank you, that means a lot

OP posts:
Oliversmumsarmy · 16/11/2020 12:09

I too am a little off with the dynamics of this.

Presumably like a lot of parents, at some stage the family home gets too big and too expensive to run. It doesn’t mean they actually need to have their children move them away from their friends to look after their gc and animals

They could maybe have bought a small flat and stayed where they were surrounded by their friends

romeolovedjulliet · 16/11/2020 12:36

i wouldn't dream of turning up unannounced at my dcs homes we are all agreed it is arranged prior whether i see them or they come to us.

PaisleyCrib · 17/11/2020 09:45

@Oliversmumsarmy They could have done this but it would have made them pretty sad... They like having their friends and grandchildren to stay and having a large garden to look after (gardening is their passion!). They are only in their mid 60s and are also very active people. Downsizing to a flat was a possibility but one that they didn’t want to have to do. We could simply have helped them to stay in the existing house, but as explained previously they have concerns about the future of the area (greenbelt changes) and they genuinely love our area. My sisters and I all feel that it’s better to have them closer for future.

OP posts:
LEELULUMPKIN · 17/11/2020 09:49

My Dsis has just moved next door to me.

We had the conversation BEFORE she bought the house.

It's working brilliantly and I finally have a neighbour I can be absolutely honest, direct and truthful with.

Comefromaway · 17/11/2020 09:54

My in laws have always been a bit like this. They have keys because they help with our dog and when the kids were little with them too but they do just have a tendency to just walk in. Ds is blended learning at college at the moment and he was finding it difficult when they just turned up on his days at home.

So when we are in the house I leave our key in the lock on the inside of the door. This means they can not unlock the door from outside when we are in and have to knock/ring.

PaisleyCrib · 17/11/2020 09:58

@Comefromaway simple but effective!! Thank you. I think I will start locking the door (generally a good idea as others have pointed out!) but also have a conversation with them about the difference between popping round during the day (when it’s just me at home) and doing the same during DH’s downtime from work.

OP posts:
Comefromaway · 17/11/2020 10:03

Of course the current lockdown situation means they can't just turn up. Even before lockdown we had to ask them to give notice of when they were coming so that we did not break the rule of six (for example if we as a family of 4 were home plus ds had his girlfriend round for dinner them just turning up made 7 people.

pam290358 · 17/11/2020 10:09

Just curious - how does this impact on the situation should one or both of your parents need full time care in a nursing home or similar. Presumably the new house is solely in your names, as otherwise it could be subject to sale to cover care costs ?

Stillfunny · 17/11/2020 10:24

I moved near my parents and we had the same attitude about just calling in. I too loved to see them at any time. But they also had a great deal of respect for my DH needing his space after work.You may not need to say anything yet. But if so , gently tell them that DH likes to come home , have dinner and just be alone with you and kids. The fact that he was so generous about the house will let them know that he does like and care about them, so they really shouldn't be offended. I am sure they are so very grateful and it is a wonderful thing you were able to do for them . They will probably be perfectly OK to accommodate this.

PaisleyCrib · 18/11/2020 09:13

@Stillfunny thank you and that makes me feel a lot better.
@pam290358 this shouldn’t be an issue as we’d be able to afford care costs for them (hopefully way into the future!)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page