And I am sorry, but children starting in a school nursery or reception still in nappies is not acceptable.
I eagerly await the publication of your parenting book.
I remember my nan telling me "the sooner you start, the longer it takes".
I found the opposite was true actually
I always took the saying to refer to signs of readiness rather than age so if you start before they're ready or at very outside edge of being ready it will take longer than it would it you waited until they were actually ready.
What signs do you look for that indicate they're ready? Or do you just roll with it
For us the signs of readiness were:
- a nappy being dry for ages before being used, a sign that they can hold on before going
- knowing that they're going, my DC would pause what they were doing while peeing which showed they were aware
- awareness of when their nappy is used, when they started trying to take off the nappy/bringing me a fresh nappy/asking for a fresh nappy straight after they'd used it that was a good sign
- hiding to poop or pooping at roughly the same time each day
And you do sort of have to roll with it too, some kids will take to it straight away and others will be more resistant, some like rewards and some aren't bothered, some prefer a potty and others prefer the toilet.
A general rule of thumb is that they should make progress so day one they might have a lot of accidents but they should have less and less as the days go on. If after 3-4 days they're making no progress at all then go back in nappies and try again a few weeks later because life is too short to be scrubbing piss out of the carpet ten times a day.