Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - Sister undiagnosed mental health condition

5 replies

Zaratamara · 22/08/2020 14:56

Hi guys,

It's a long story and believe it or not this is the shortest version I could writeGrin. I had my younger Sister come stay for a night and she brought my Niece who is 2. I see my niece very frequently and shes very close to me.

Both myself and DH smoke (I know, very bad but I have cut myself down recently from 10 a day to 2 and I'm working on quitting). I know some people will judge but it's our home . We dont have kids and would normally smoke in the living room but because my sister was staying we decided as a once off to smoke in our bedroom, I didn't want my niece being in a smoke filled room. The following morning I asked my sister if she would like to have one with me as I was planning to air the room out for the day and had lit wax melts to minimize the smell. She told me she was fine and didnt need one. Later she decided she wanted one and came into my room with a cigarette and I told her to go out to the back garden because I was airing the room out. She argued that I had smoked in there about 6 hours ago and what was the difference now. This really pissed me off because 1. It's my home so my rules and 2. I only decided to smoke in my bedroom so her daughter would have clean air. She just told me to go F* myself and walked out of the room.

So I decided to allow us to both cool down and half an hour later I approached her to talk but she called me a C and said I was just saying no for the sake of it and said that I was a control freak. When I tried to explain that I didnt want my bedroom stinking later she said that if it was her house she would allow me to smoke anywhere and just told me to get the f out of her face and that I was trying to control her. I walked into my bedroom because she was calling me every name under the sun but she barged in my door and said the reason I have hardly any friends is because I need to control everything Confused. All the while , I'm telling her to stop shouting at me because her daughter is in the next room and to get out of my room.

My sister has always been erratic but has never followed up on appointments despite family interventions, has been on various antidepressants but wont stick to the medication and has abused various drugs including prescription medications. She can explode out of nowhere but seems to be able to put on a charm in front of extended family so they never get to see the real side that her closest friends and family see. It's been very hard over the years because although I love her and want to be close to my niece very badly , my own mental health has taken a toll just having to listen to her and her problems with everyone else around her. Our family GP has long suggested Bipolar disorder or a personality disorder which is why he referred her to a specialist but she just wont attend and will go MIA days before the appointment.

At what point does somebody question whether it's the persons mental illness that had them behaving this way or if they are just being an absolute tosser?

Was I being unreasonable for not just allowing her to have the cigarette in the room?

Advice would be appreciated guys xx

OP posts:
Goldenhedgehogs · 22/08/2020 15:12

Just look at actions. Your sister wanted to smoke in your bedroom so she kicked off when you said no. Ignoring the fact her daughter could hear all this and be worried and frightened. I would say her anger is being used to get what she wants over your and her daughter's feelings. This is the behaviour of a domestic abuser, using moods and temper to get what they want. So regardless of if this is caused by mental health I would stop worrying about her mental health and start reacting to the behaviour. My reaction would be you don't take abuse anywhere but especially in your own home and ask her to leave. I would also raise your concerns with social care for the child's welfare.

OwlBeThere · 22/08/2020 15:19

Well, from what you’ve said, in isolation, you weren’t unreasonable. However, knowing families there is probably a ton of back story and her version of it and yours might be wildly different.
I’m not saying you were wrong, just that family history can be complicated. She feels you are controlling. Do you feel there’s any truth to that if you look at it rationally?
Her MH issues might well be the reason she over reacts to small issues. If it is a personality disorder, people can take any kind of push back against what the want as a sign of rejection and then they explode.
I feel very differently to the PP who said separate illness from action. I dint think that’s possible really.

Zaratamara · 22/08/2020 15:30

@Goldenhedgehogs Thanks for the reply, I agree with 100% and in previous circumstances I have asked her to leave when shes behaved like this in my home, but I feel so bad to even suggest it now because I feel like I'm also kicking my Niece out who has done nothing wrong. Plus we live a few hours apart so I thought it would be best to leave it because she would have been leaving soon anyway.

She is struggling and I know she has "ideals" on how she wants her daughter to grow up and has often said she doesnt want the daughter to turn out like her, so I'm guessing she is already aware she has a problem. The child hears so much arguing and tension between her parents and I feel awful at times because I only want happiness for her, shes a blessing and very sweet and could really thrive in the right environment. I have never witnessed my sister behaving like this with the child which again makes me think that shes manipulative and can switch her mood on and off like a button, depending on who the person is.

OP posts:
Zaratamara · 22/08/2020 15:40

@OwlbeThere, thanks for the reply. I'm sure she will have her own version of the story aswel, like the saying goes, there 3 sides to a story Grin. One thing I do know is that she would not allow me to actually explain why I didnt want her to do it in there and flat out just told me I was being a wanker , excuse the language. She continuously spoke over me and wasnt willing to reason even after I suggested looking after her daughter so she could go outside to have it. She smokes everywhere in her own home whereas I dont because I dont want the whole house stinking. My sister has called me controlling once before and made me question myself, this was because she promised to give me back money I had borrowed to her and needed it by a certain time to pay my rent. She ignored my calls all day until late night and then said I was controlling and a freak for having called her 10 times in a row over "money". My rent was late because of this. See she has no respect for other peoples time , and I doubt she would even understand the value people place on their free time.

OP posts:
Oldraver · 22/08/2020 16:18

Her throwing the control comment sounds like her way of getting you to back off

New posts on this thread. Refresh page