Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder whether you can separate but live together?

27 replies

BeanCalledPickle · 15/08/2020 21:12

Back story; married nine years. Two DDs aged 5 and 7. Live in decent sized house and have a joint income that allows us to live well but not indulgently, so one holiday a year, a meal out every month, haircuts, days out etc. One DD has some additional needs and we spend money on specialist tutor etc.

Marriage pretty much dead. Have discussed in amicable manner and agreed we want to split up. We get on but we don’t want to be together. We do want to be as civilised about it as possible. Both of us have slipped up and gone over the line with colleagues and we have been honest about it with each other. Emotional affairs really. No hard feelings either way, we know these are symptoms not the problem but it makes it clear that we do need to move on.

We have been looking at living apart but it would be very tricky. I’d need to put 200k on the mortgage to buy him out and he would need to take on 100k of mortgage on top of the 200k I’d give him to stand a chance of getting even a half decent two bed flat. Expensive area. We don’t want to rent and it would cost more than mortgage in any event. HVing done the maths it’s doable but with no spare cash for anything nice. I’m prepared to make cuts but I don’t want to end up with no treats for the kids because of my choices. And beyond the money I do worry that our selfish desire to move on will impact on them massively. I do think that separated happy parents are better than together miserable parents though.

He has now come to me suggesting we draw up an agreement whereby we separate but live together. A clear rota of who is in charge of the kids with the other free to do whatever. One weekend on one off. We have separate bedrooms and bathrooms already. Similarly share the kids and week nights as well. Haven’t discussed the detail but would work out a way of separating finances so less shared as well, along with things like shopping and laundry.

I was initially quite dismissive but I can see some possibility this could work. Does anyone have any experiences to share? I can see it might be difficult if there were new people on the scene and it would have to be that this can’t happen if the other is under the same roof. I’m hopeful this could be some sort of solution?

OP posts:
BeanCalledPickle · 16/08/2020 10:23

Good to hear it can work. I fully expect it to be weird and take some getting used to. But the alternatives are all pretty drastic for a first step. Renting is minimum six months, and even a studio could here is 1k a month plus bills etc. Seems an awful lot to spend just to explore the alternatives.

OP posts:
EveryDayIsADuvetDay · 16/08/2020 10:47

No harm in giving it a try - as long as it doesn't make things worse between the two of you.
If it's not working - or starts OK but then falls apart, the same alternative options will be available to you.
Maybe try it, but set a date to formally review how its working for you all?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread