Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who IBU here? Bridesmaid-related

30 replies

Indirectly · 02/07/2020 14:30

NC because I don't want this linked with previous posts.

I have 2 friends, A and B. The three of us have been good friends since we met in school over 15 years ago. A is a lovely person but can be quite needy - I understand why, she's had a difficult life but at times I've had to space out contact a little bit because it's been a bit much. B is on the other end of the spectrum, very busy with her career and is very family-oriented so often doesn't initiate contact. I've often gotten the sense that she spaces out contact with A for similar reasons to me under the guise of her busyness, but we've never spoken about it directly. A and B have had a couple of issues over the years, mainly to do with A feeling she does all the initiating with B, but they've managed to work through it.

B got married last year and because I was working abroad I wasn't able to attend. B didn't have a formal set of bridesmaids but she had A walk in as part of the extended family party and A was involved in many of B's wedding events (B's culture involves several events associated with marriage).

A got engaged last year and is now planning her wedding for late February 2021. She asked B to be a bridesmaid and B initially accepted. However, B got pregnant unexpectedly with her first child and is due at the beginning of January. B reached out to A and said that she's not really sure if she'll be able to fulfil her responsibilities as a bridesmaid and said she'll leave it with A to make the call, saying she wanted to give A as much notice as possible so that she could potentially ask someone else. B said she'll obviously still attend the wedding but also said if it was anyone else she wouldn't - A interpreted this as B seeming to believe she was doing A a favour by even attending.

A is now really upset with B, saying that she wasn't asking B for anything except to be with her on the day and take a few photos. A was also upset by B asking A to consider doing her hens several months before the wedding so that A could attend, and it's opened up old wounds now about A feeling like she isn't valued by B. She thought B could have at least seen how she felt closer to the day and A would have been as accommodating as she could be.

So I'm essentially stuck in the middle of the two friends here, and thought I'd put it to a MN jury. I see A's point and understand why she's hurt, as she felt she was there for B when B had her wedding, but I also know that B is very nervous as a first-time mum and keeps thinking worst case scenario e.g. some unexpected difficulty with the baby. None of us have children so it's entirely new. A is now saying she will still be friends with B but she no longer wants to make any effort. B doesn't think she's done anything wrong.

YABU: A is being unreasonable
YANBU: A is right to be upset

OP posts:
Comefromaway · 03/07/2020 10:41

I take it that A does not have a young baby s doesn;t know what it's like.

SHe needs to stop being so sensitive

ConkerGame · 03/07/2020 10:53

B is my pet peeve type of person! The women who get married earlier in the friendship group expect everyone to drop everything for their wedding - there’s the hen; the bridal shower; the bridesmaids duties, the whole shebang.

Then when those in the friendship group who get married later on ask for similar in return, the earlier brides are all “Gosh, I’m PREGNANT now don’t you know, so I can’t possibly do anything for the 4 months before or after the birth. weddings aren’t really important; they’re just a party!”

Drives me nuts! (Can you tell I’m in the later group to get married?! Blush)

B is being unreasonable. She expected a lot from A so now it’s time to repay the favour! No need to have wild nights out at 8 months pregnant but there’s plenty she can still do!

ThePlantsitter · 03/07/2020 11:04

I think B is covering her bases because she doesn't know what having a baby is going to be like. And she's quite right, she doesn't.

I too would interpret the 'I wouldn't do this for anyone else' as a way of saying A is special to her. Same with the hen - she's indicating she really wants to come. But the good thing about people who are busy with their family etc a lot means you can generally say things like 'I don't want my hen early' and they will just think 'ok'.

It is difficult when people each life stages at different times but I think A needs to chill out and concentrate on her husband to be and her own wedding. It's all very well stewing about whether B is being unreasonable or not but unless there's something specific she wants her to do differently - that is doable - and unless she's prepared to directly ask B to do it, there's not much point going on about it.

Sceptre86 · 03/07/2020 11:22

I would interpret B's comments as that because she cares for A she is making an effort to attend. Could it be that B wanted to give A as much notice as possible with regards to choosing a bridesmaid because she doesn't understand what A would need her to do. For instance some women on mumsnet expect bridesmaids to help with planning, decorating, seating etc and she may not be able to do all of that with a baby in tow. Also some women want numerous meetings with their bridesmaids before the wedding and as she is pregnant might not be able to commit to them? B shouldn't have asked them to move the hen earlier Acan do it whenever suits however she should be aware that B might not want to attend in later pregnancy. If I was B I would reiterate how much I cared for A and get her to explain my bridesmaid duties fully. If I felt that as a result of my pregnancy I wouldn't be able to fulfil those duties I would explain that.

Igotthemheavyboobs · 03/07/2020 12:28

@ConkerGame

B is my pet peeve type of person! The women who get married earlier in the friendship group expect everyone to drop everything for their wedding - there’s the hen; the bridal shower; the bridesmaids duties, the whole shebang.

Then when those in the friendship group who get married later on ask for similar in return, the earlier brides are all “Gosh, I’m PREGNANT now don’t you know, so I can’t possibly do anything for the 4 months before or after the birth. weddings aren’t really important; they’re just a party!”

Drives me nuts! (Can you tell I’m in the later group to get married?! Blush)

B is being unreasonable. She expected a lot from A so now it’s time to repay the favour! No need to have wild nights out at 8 months pregnant but there’s plenty she can still do!

This ^^
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread