I'm going to respond to everyone's questions in one message as it's taking too long to reply quote them all - sorry. I'll try and @ correctly.
@SynchroSwimmer This particular hole does not show on the title deeds for my property. They do show and reference other things (see my previous post to this one) and that's since 1906 when the house was built. So maybe the hole came after?
Re: insurance, agreed. I wasn't going to contact the insurers until I had all the pertinent information. And even then, I'll only mention it if I feel I need to take out an indemnity against it.
I figured I'd have to fill the hole at least partially because I'm hoping to lay a patio over it. Not sure how I'm going to do that yet. The neighbour has most of the hole opening on his side and there's a concrete path over the top of his bit.
@AwwDontGo Thank you, yes. I did think about this. I'll call them as a last resort and if I feel an indemnity is required.
@NotMeNoNo Yes, I thought about contacting my surveyor. It was about 3 years ago I bought the property but he was really knowledgeable about older buildings especially. I'll dig out his email and send him a message. Happy to pay for his time of course.
@cabbageking A sewer was my initial thoughts but there is a drain already marked within my property boundary so I'm not sure it is. There is a manhole cover a bit further up from the hole which takes mine and my neighbours waste away though.
@occa Maybe we are the Hades and sanity is on the other side.
@Haggisfish :D
@EthelMayFergus Thank you. There are a few posters now mentioning it looks like a well. The hole is definitely spherical in shape under the ground. If it is an old well, can I fill it in? If it's not a well, can I still fill it in?!
@Doggodogington It looks too spherical to be erosion.
@recycledteenager24 Our neighbours on the other side mentioned a rat problem a few months back. Eek! I always worried they were making a home for themselves underneath my decking. I can't wait to get rid of it. I hate decking (sorry for anyone that chose to have it.)
@Bertucci Thank you. I googled a dumb well and from what I can understand, it was to drain water from the surface, rather than a well which is used to collect water from an underground source? If it is a well, what do you think that cable is? Could it be an electricity cable for next door? I probably shouldn't fill in the hole, but could I at least cover over the entrance to the hole on my side so I can lay patio?
@WhoWouldHaveThoughtThat Can I charge the Hobbits rent?
@tara66 It looks a little shallow to be an air raid shelter. I know you can't really tell the depth from the photos, but it's about a metre deep (there are lots of old bricks and what not on top though so it might be a bit deeper?
@Thighdentitycrisis This is certainly a possibility. I'd like to be able to see what's underneath on my side but the fence gets in the way of me getting my head down there and taking a look. I may have to rig up my camera and take a few photos within the hole.
@Elouera Eek. Definitely not a mine shaft. There used to be an old elastic factory over the road though.
@Timesdone Thank you. I'll post over there too.
@mumwon Thanks. I love looking at old archive photos and paperwork. I'll see what I can find when life returns to normality.