Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask bf to visit sibling and abusive partner?

27 replies

susanstohelit123 · 30/05/2020 13:56

For background, my brother is in an abusive and controlling relationship with a history of mental abuse and suspected physical. I won't go into details but he's admitted the extent of it to me previously and it's appalling.

He has two little boys with his partner but is rarely allowed to bring them to visit his side of the family. He has three siblings, including me, and unless we visit him we don't get to see him or our nephews.

When we do try to visit, nine out of ten times there's an excuse at the last minute and they'll cancel on us. When the rare visits do happen, we are welcomed in and his partner makes a big show of being chatty so the actual time spent at their house isn't awful, especially as our children get to mix and get to know their cousins.

The problem I'd like outside perspectives on is that my partner, for understandable reasons, absolutely hates my brother's partner and cannot understand why my brother allows her to treat him and the rest of his family as terribly as is the case (and without going into too much outing detail, it has been absolutely terrible).

So,when the rare occasion arises that we're invited round, I encounter resistance from him - he refuses to come and doesn't want our young children exposed to the toxicity of their household. He's making a stand and I do understand and largely agree with his reasons why.

But to maintain a relationship with my brother and nephews and to allow our children to know their cousins, I think it's important we make the effort to stay in touch and take up the rare invites. I fear if we don't, my brother and his children will be cut off and feel more isolated in the middle of an abusive situation.

In an ideal world, he'd flee the situation and seek help but he's not at that stage yet and I don't feel that we should turn our backs and wait until he gets there.

But my partner doesn't want to be around her at all and it's getting to the stage where I'm always having to make excuses for him not coming and it's getting very obvious to everyone that he simply doesn't like being there and won't come any more. It's awkward, uncomfortable and sad for me - the whole situation is really upsetting.

We've been invited round for a socially distanced garden visit on Wednesday and in order to bring the kids to see their cousins, I actually need him to come with me now as we have a newborn and a young toddler that I'll struggle to wrangle alone. If the world was normal, I'd just go with another relative to help but I can only rely on him at the moment.

He's refusing to come and is angry with me for trying to persuade him to be around people he can't stand but I'd really like his support and it only happens every few months for a couple of hours - am I being unreasonable or should he put his righteous hostility to the side in order to be there for me (and by extension, my brother) in this situation?

Any advice on the overall situation (including how to get your sibling away from such a toxic environment!) would be welcomed and sorry if I've rambled a bit here but wanted to try and be clear.

OP posts:
ohtheholidays · 31/05/2020 21:03

As a victim of horrendous abuse I'd say please don't stop visiting him,him being cut off from everyone that cares about him will only enable his abuser even more.

When your in the thick of a relationship like that you can be consumed by what the abuser wants and you can spend years walking around in a fog,someone on the outside that loves you trying to show you that the things that you are going through are from normal and that the view can be alot clearer is sometimes the one thing that keeps you going.

lyralalala · 31/05/2020 21:10

Please don't stop visiting. He'll just be isolated further. For the sake of your nephews keep the relationship going as much as you can. My Grandparents bit their tongue, offered support for over 10 years when my siblings and I were young and our parents were in a violently destructive relationship. It was that link that got us kids away when it really deteriorated when I was 7. I'll be forever grateful they didn't walk away.

Use Covid and just take the baby. The toddler will be a nightmare social distancing anyway.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread