Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

being nice is right,right?

21 replies

gaiusmoham · 13/05/2020 10:46

A good few years back, me and my girlfriend of the time went through a rough patch. No cheating or abuse, just we were snappy, both had family drama etc. She (I found later) had her head turned but what I suppose is a bad boy type. Things got to a point where we had to decide what to do about us. I went all in, invited her to move in with me, told her I was fully committed to making it work. She decided instead to go off with the other bloke. Sad trombone.

Years pass, then at the start of lockdown I get an email from her to my old email address, prob only contact details she has left. I didn't see it for a couple of weeks but once I noticed it I responded, we exchanged pleasantries. She asked for my new number but I kept it to myself.

After a few civil back and forths she sends me a long email about how the last few years of her life were terrible, she made a massive mistake and she has been left high and dry by the bad boy with a kid!

I'm no fool, I can see where this is going. She had already established in our back and forth I had bought a nice two bed house and had done well in my career, so had progressed from when she knew me renting a little studio place. She has no job and lives back home. I am 30, she is a couple of years younger.

Now, although I am single and did feel for her, I am no fool and will not be wading into this shitshow. I have no desire to be saddled bringing up some wasters kid as well as living with the nagging feeling of being second best. I dont want to be nasty though, for all her mistakes she is a nice person so I want to let her down as gently as possible? What do I say? I need a reason to rebuff that doesn't just sound like me saying her life sounds unappealing to me. Should I keep it on email or text her? Do I offer ongoing support, if so how do I do that whilst still ensuring she knows there is no hope of us getting together.

OP posts:
JKScot4 · 13/05/2020 10:48

Be pleasant and withdraw, you’re not obliged to get back with her. Don’t give her your number.

Spied · 13/05/2020 10:57

I'd keep it light. When she emails you I'd wait a while before replying and keep things light.
Don't divulge too much of your life and don't ask questions. A kind of 'hope you are well' type chat.
Don't give your number and if she asks say you are changing contract etc and don't have a reliable number to be contacted on etc.
She should read between the lines that you're not interested. If not then ghost. Or tell her you have a partnerGrin ( although probably a bit cruel) I'd also keep your social media settings private.

Apirateslifeforme · 13/05/2020 11:10

Sorry, but I dont understand why you're trying to save her feelings here. She walked away from you when someone more exciting came along.

You dont owe her the stress of even figuring out an explanation for

Fckingfuming · 13/05/2020 11:12

Don't text, then she'll have your number! I'd mention it in a further email (only if she keeps contacting you dropping out hints about past regrets, etc) that you think it's a shame her life didn't work out how she planned it to, and wish her and her child well for the future.

Personally if it was me though I wouldn't have responded in the first place, and would have been glad to see the back of her. HTH

RandomMess · 13/05/2020 11:14

I would just say "that's a shame for you, I've been enjoying dating other people and am now far more confident in the type of person I like being with"

If more hints are dropped

"I've moved on and am not going back"

UnabashedlyNeurodifferent · 13/05/2020 11:15

bringing up some wasters kid
This doesn't make you sound nice. Hmm

But you're right to not want to fall for it. You could just reply "So sorry things have not been going well for you, I hope they improve soon for you and your son/daughter. All the best" or something of that nature.

It's dismissive but polite. Then don't reply anymore messages, if you want to break contact.

Biker47 · 13/05/2020 11:16

Making up that you have a partner is a good tactic, an ex of mine contacted me out of the blue, we chatted for a bit, when I mentioned I had a partner, pffff; gone.

She's found out the grass isn't greener the hard way and is coming back to 'ol reliable as a consolation prize, don't get sucked back in.

justtb · 13/05/2020 11:16

Being the queen of fucking up a perfectly good relationship, I can understand why she might reach out to you. Don't immediately assume she wants to get back with you. I used to talk to a ex quite a lot and apologised for everything that had happened between us and got so much closure. We've both moved on with our lives, although admittedly I don't think either of us are happy..
Sometimes it's just good to talk to someone you used to be with. Reminisce about the old times and share inside jokes etc..

UnabashedlyNeurodifferent · 13/05/2020 11:18

Also, if you want to say something definitive, you could add something like "Sorry but I've moved on". That's it. No explanations for why or how.

Picklypickles · 13/05/2020 11:21

Well if it were me in this situation I would just ignore, but if you feel you must give an explanation you just say that you moved on a long time ago and any feelings you used to have simply aren't there any more, wish her all the best and then drop contact with her.

Sn0tnose · 13/05/2020 11:25

She thinks so little of you that she’s assuming you’ve been sat around waiting for her to come back to you because the life she chose didn’t work out for her? Does she think that you can’t see what she’s doing? Are you supposed to feel grateful because she’s giving you the chance to financially support her and her child until someone else comes along to turn her head? Fuck that for a laugh.

The only person you owe niceness to in this situation is yourself. If you want to stay polite, then I’d reply ‘Well I’m really sorry to hear that things haven’t worked out for you, hopefully everything will turn out alright in the end. Take care and all the very best, Gaius’. And then shut that email address down quickly so that anything else just bounces back to her as undeliverable.

MouthBreathingRage · 13/05/2020 11:27

Really Hmm.

SeriouslySoDoneIn · 13/05/2020 11:29

Aye sure this is real. Single man without kids on a site for parents. Can you get any more obvious?

CalmdownJanet · 13/05/2020 11:32

Just keep it straight "Jane I'm going to leave it here with the emails, it's always good to catch up with people from your past to see how they are getting on but the past is the past and I am happy to leave it there for our friendship. I wish you well though and hope you have a happy life" - I think that's fairly straight to the point but nice

Aquamarine1029 · 13/05/2020 11:32

You need to stop communicating with her completely. You may think it won't happen, but you may find yourself getting dragged back in to her "shitshow", which I agree that it is. She sees you as a perfect opportunity to improve her lot in life.

Tell her you wish her luck, but you have moved on and aren't interested in being "friends." Then block her and get on with life.

Eschallonia · 13/05/2020 11:36

I don't think you sound particularly nice --describing the child of a woman you purport to have loved as 'some waster's kid' is particularly unpleasant.

And your reading of her getting back in touch is mercenary -- for all you know she's simply realised she made a mistake in leaving you and wanted to tell you. A job and a house doesn't actually make you all that much of a catch, you know.

You're also assuming you wants you back -- has she actually said this? You seem to be replying to a message she hasn't actually sent. It's pretty arrogant to assume that the only reason an old girlfriend would get in touch is because she wants you back.

dontdisturbmenow · 13/05/2020 11:36

That's a lot of assumptions about her you seem to be making. Maybe she isn't after you lovely house and income. Maybe you're not second best but genuinely realised she made a mistake.

Why not give her the benefit of the doubt if she's a nice girl? If you were to start dating as long as you insist on condoms, get rid of them yourself, and don't make any promises of the future, maybe you could see whether you could indeed pick up where you left. That is of course assuming you still have some feelings for her.

MiaowMix · 13/05/2020 11:42

30 yrs old, really? Hmm

dannydyerismydad · 13/05/2020 11:42

A lot of people are using lockdown as a way to reconnect with people who have been important to them in life.

I'm using the time to check in on people I care about. Some of while I one had relationships with. I have no interest in restarting a relationship with any of them. I just want to make sure people I know and love or have loved are ok and coping.

She may be manipulative. She may be genuinely interested in friendship and no more. You're right to be cautious, but you seem to be suspecting the worst and are not coming off as very pleasant. I think she's best off without you.

dannydyerismydad · 13/05/2020 11:43

Some of whom I I had relationships with...

Autocorrect.

OnABeachSomewhere · 13/05/2020 11:49
Hmm
New posts on this thread. Refresh page