Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Holiday with MIL AIBU to say NO

36 replies

ProblemShared · 12/02/2020 21:18

Name changed for this as DH knows my usual name.

DH and I have been together 13 years, married 11. 3DC.

so not to drip feed...

The other night he mentioned we were invited to a family wedding (people I have never met) in september. I replied oh that's nice. Then got accused of being under excited... reiterate to him I have never met them and indeed not seen photos, so really would pass them in the street.

Conversation moves on to how I didnt get excited about his suggestion of going on holiday with his mother. He mentioned it once 2 years ago and I said no. I told him I would rather be honest and not lie.

For background NEVER has he in his adult life expressed any interest of holidays with his family eg) used holiday allowance etc to spend time with them. This was before we met and after. it was an over night Sat -Sun trip to see them a few times a year. and Christmad he would just travel back from london and spend minimal time and work between Xmas and new year. I on the other hand have used holidays to spend with my family, gone away with them as a large group etc before he was in my life and yes after. I only write this to emphasise that this was really out of the blue for me and given private conversations between us a bit of a U Turn. YES people can change their mind.

so this is about him thinking IABU not to want to go on holiday with his mother (ONLY) . Because and i quote "because i think it would be nice for her"

I said to him that my stance hadnt changed and i want comfortable with that. As he stood there muttering and shaking his head i said we should continue the conversation at another time as it was bath time for the DCs and wasnt going to address that right at that moment. As as far as i was aware all he could hear was me being a horrid person so i wasnt going to try and defend myself to a shaking head muttering, huffing and puffing man. I did say he was welcome to go on holiday with her - take her to paris or somethng nice for a long weekend. Ended without much further discussion but in my head i just felt a bit shit. because i felt all my reasons sounded a bit rubbish / selfish / childish.

I like his mum. she comes to stay and we do things, have fun and is welcome. Never and issue EVER about her coming to see us.

BUT i do have MIL / family IL issues.....

DH does change in her (and in his family's company in general) and it is sometimes just exhausting and uncomfortable to watch. he is not the person i live with, i love and am married to. it is like a split personaity. He is not like this around my family.

His mother also treats him like a proxy husband sometimes. eg) his DB lives 40 mins away from her and she asks DH to travel 4+hrs instead. so yes he is the preferred son. cards with "i dont know what i would do without you... love you loads" " how could i manage without you..." she is 68 and in good health.

anyway i can easily live with this for 3 nights in my own house with 3 dc to take to parties, cook, take to activities, my own life etc. What i cant see being fun is spending a week like this during the holiday that i work hard for. always trying to please his mother. who def turns to no.1 priority to please but also to show off too.

It doesn't sit right with me, like an invasion of my space or something similar i cant quite put my finger on.

BUT It makes me feel like i am being horrid and silly when I say it out loud.

SO AIBU just to say no and leave it at that.

AIBU to ask mumsnet if there are words I can use try and explain how I feel.

again to be clear. any family holidays with my family have been a very large group of say 14+ DH has enjoyed day trips cycling with my DBIL etc people do their own thing. I def wont be going on holiday with DBIL and family as they have only met DC3 once despite frequently coming within about 20 mins of our house! they live about 3-3.5 hours away. DH doesnt want to do that either.

Thanks all - apologies for the long wittering story. Just feel this could be one of those festering things that in 10 years gets pulled out if not addressed.

OP posts:
Mummyoflittledragon · 13/02/2020 14:56

I would go for a short break with her. I get what you’re talking about, totally. I would do something she is most likely to enjoy. Eg a haven / Center Parcs if she likes to swim and go for walks in the countryside or somewhere near the beach if she likes to sunbathe etc. With young kids, you need this to be child focused but also ensure your mil doesn’t become a moaning Minnie.

Lsquiggles · 13/02/2020 14:59

You could not pay me enough to go on holiday with my in laws Grin

Hanab · 13/02/2020 15:14

OP you mentioned that you would not want to spend the money in that way .. are you the higher earner or bread winner by any chance .. maybe this could a factor as well as the others you mentioned?
As in he expects you to foot the bill?

i have a similar issue OP .. I just make sure H entertains his mum and I enjoy by myself or with my kids .. they are free to join H and mil but they also pick up the difference in personality in H when he is with his family or his friends.

Cheeseandwin5 · 13/02/2020 15:19

Sorry , but you are being totally unreasonable and I can understand why your DH is peeved off with you.
The reason he enjoys himself with your family is that he makes the effort to do so, and with many members and on multi trips. The least you can do is act the same.
He changes around his family but you don't? Just because he doesn't mention it doesn't mean its not true.
If you dont want to holiday with his MIL, than fine dont do it but be fair and say you that no holidays with your relatives as well.
You sound so controlling and manipulative.

billy1966 · 13/02/2020 15:28

I think he wants someone to blame for the fact that he's not pushed and hasn't been.

He's using you as his punching bag in this matter.

Don't allow him to.

Tell him to own that he feels guilty and tell him to take his mother away for a break.
She would probably enjoy it more if it was just the two of them.

You are not interested and she hasn't any interest in the children so nothing to be gained there.

Don't allow him to try and blame his lack of interest on you.

He sounds childish.

MaryShelley1818 · 13/02/2020 17:26

I just can't imagine being in a relationship where you don't just do something you don't necessarily want to do to make the person you love happy (obviously within reason). Is he the same as you? Or does he compromise?
It all sounds just so very selfish.

ProblemShared · 13/02/2020 20:14

Thank you for all the input.

I wont be going on holiday. I would consider a short break. But that would be dependent on something that is a fit for all and all does not directly include me having specific things. It means my children dh and mil will be satisfied so inturn i am not stressed..and so content.

To those saying compromise I agree it is important in relationships. To say I am utterly selfish for not compromising well this is one situation in my life. Maybe I am selfish but not utterly as we compromise just fine.

To those saying my DH makes an effort to enjoy time with my family. Not sure he has to put much effort in enjoying cycling up mountains with my DBIL for a couple of days child free..... he enjoys it because I go places I know he will have fun etc.

To again be clear it not a regular occurrence a holiday with my family that we go on and in effect rub his mother nose in it. Not at all. I would not go on holiday with my only my parents dh and children....

He sees my siblings and their spouses as friend so not too much effort and my parents do their own thing.

It would be very different if MIL came. I know this.

Thanks again for comments. Will consider the suggestions

OP posts:
Ubercornsdiscoball · 13/02/2020 20:20

YABU. It’s his mum. It’s one holiday. I think you’re being selfish to be honest. I’m not surprised he is upset with you

Aquamarine1029 · 13/02/2020 20:21

I would cut my own head off before I ever went on holiday with my in-laws, so I am of no help here. My only advise is don't be pressured into doing something you know will make you miserable.

ProblemShared · 13/02/2020 20:26

@ubercornsdiscoball he is not that upset.

And i am unsure of why he is thinking about this as in my post he said "nice for her"

I will he asking him when I see him why. I suspect he feels it's a duty which is a bit pants all round.

And for those wondering.... when I see him to.orrownnight ... not seen properly since Sunday as I compromise! And i work ft and commute to central ldn and have 3 children. So I am not a blazing bitch telling him what he can and cant do!

I suggested in my.last post I would.consider a short break / long weekend

OP posts:
ProblemShared · 13/02/2020 20:29

@aquamarine1029

Agree thats what I felt and really why I posted. but when its mil related! Suddenly you throw that into doubt!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread