Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Christmas hosting - another one

32 replies

Changingforthisnow · 02/01/2020 23:08

Following on from another thread I just wanted to see what the thought on this scenario is. My MIL hosted Christmas for us, DH’s siblings, her siblings and families (DH’s aunts, cousins and their partners/kids as appropriate), her MIL and other odds and sods (not being rude but not family) and has done for years. The only people who travel are us and one of DH’s siblings and partners (think over 6 hours a piece) and everyone else goes home after Christmas Day (except maybe DH’s other siblings who don’t travel).

We alternate and MIL is saying she is getting tired of it. Not surprising tho others do bring a few things and it is the one day. We are - realistically - the only ones who could do it (and the hints are there that we should) but it would be everyone for longer than a day. I do get on with them but they wouldn’t bring stuff with them at that distance and they would basically take over for the Christmas duration as they wouldn’t want to go to hotels - too much money - so would be there all the time. A proper holiday.

We were thinking of on our next alternate year of saying MIL, her MIL, DH’s siblings and families as appropriate and that’s it. However, the other thread made me think that would make me CF? I think it’s the fact that it would not just be a day, it would be all in, all season.. Thoughts?

OP posts:
ThatLibraryMiss · 03/01/2020 13:04

If you do decide to go down the group booking route, OP, and you end up being the one responsible, DON'T BOOK until you have ALL the deposits. You don't want to end up out of pocket because Not-Quite-Cousin Sidney decides he can't afford it after you've plonked your credit card down to secure the booking.

BlueLadybird · 03/01/2020 13:20

Seems entirely reasonably to limit it. Would all the other extended family and friends want to travel 6 hours to your house? I’m sure it’s lovely but perhaps they are going to MIL’s for convenience.

How many can you comfortably accommodate? If only a few say MIL, GMIL, DH sibling with young kids etc can stay, others need to book a hotel (give recommendations). I’d also ensure you limit the number of days and be clear on your expectations for whilst they are there. It will be hard work otherwise.

Also - if you alternate (so your family next Christmas) presumably you’re talking about 2 years time? That’s so far away that I really wouldn’t offer now but wait and see in 18 months. Things can, and do, change.

fedup21 · 03/01/2020 13:26

It’s the aunts/uncles and cousins that are the problem here, as far as I can see.

It’s very unusual surely, that once people have their own children and grandchildren, they would expect to keep being hosted yearly by the same one sister? Even more unusual that that once that sister gets older and hosting becomes too much, she expects her son and DIL to take over and host all her brothers, sisters and family?!

Wouldn’t the uncles and aunts go instead to their own kids?

northernknickers · 03/01/2020 14:02

Surely you can see this is bonkers!

a) it’s 2 years away, and
b) it’s totally unnecessary to keep doing this, just because one person (your MIL) decided many years ago that she would!

It was ‘her’ thing, which doesn’t make it ‘your’ thing by default when she decides to stop!

You are setting yourself up for YEARS of this if you start now (well...in 2 years 😳)

Changingforthisnow · 03/01/2020 14:31

As I say I wouldn’t have thought of posting now but I saw the other thread and went ‘oh hang on!’. The good news is I wouldn’t be unreasonable to keep it to what I said as we can comfortably accommodate them. Tbh it’s more than I would like but I think it’s reasonable in the circumstances and it would mean I could be at home which would be nice for our DC.

It is odd of aunts and stuff but it’s typical. They don’t really understand why DH benefits from stuff on my side and it’s not extended to the rest of their family - but then even DH’s siblings and DM goes in for that - so it’s quite an intrinsic family trait truth be told.

OP posts:
Changingforthisnow · 04/01/2020 20:57

I should add the adults did a secret Santa this year - and I got a cheap spirit I never ever drink so thanks for that Santa!

OP posts:
Notthetoothfairy · 04/01/2020 21:47

Maybe try to break the cycle so your family next year and go away for Christmas the year after.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page