Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS can't/won't do work in school

29 replies

scrappydappydoooooo · 14/12/2019 12:38

DS aged 8 is struggling a lot in school. He was doing fine last year but at the start of this school year he was very ill, spent some time in hospital and a lot of time off at home and even since returning to school has missed a number of days here and there as his immune system is very, very low and he is getting sick far more often than he ever has. He's missed roughly 1/3 of the school year and at times I can see that he's extremely worn out after a school day.

When he was out of school I used to go an pick up the work he was missing from his teacher. A lot of the time he was genuinely far too sick to do it but on his better days he worked his way through all of his missing work with no issue. He flew through his maths work, had little bother with his writing worksheets, occasionally mixed up his reading because he sometimes rushes his reading but when I'd get him to use his finger under what he was reading he could do it pretty well. His main problem was with learning spellings. At times he'd also make his own 'comics' and he has trouble sounding out a word to spell it.

He's always been more of a 'sight-reader' but I started to realise that he had very little comprehension of phonics at all. So once he was well enough I went through phonics with him. It took a bit of work to convince him because when I'd go over phonics with him he'd argue back with non-phonetic examples. (He wasn't being arsey, just genuinely baffled.) But with a lot of effort we finally had a breakthrough with it and he now gets phonics and can sound out phonetic spellings with little difficulty.

Yet at school he is struggling hugely. When he first went back, he couldn't do anything at all. Maths worksheets that he'd been doing quickly at home were coming home with him because after 20 minutes of sitting in front of them at school he hadn't been able to get through them. Then he'd sit up at the table at home and do them without bother. His English work was even worse. He could barely do any grammer worksheets. He gets all of his spellings wrong. His teacher tells me he cries at school that he just can't do it. Then at home he does them just fine.

After about a month of this he's back to getting through most of his maths at school but he still does better at home. His English work is 50/50 at school, somedays it's fine, some days it's dire. But any work at home is done quickly and correctly. He'd started to get a better at school but in the last few weeks his school work is getting worse again.

On the one hand, I accept that he is recovering from an illness that his doctors have told me will take at least 6 months for him to fully recover from even if he doesn't relapse. And that he missed so much of the start of the school year and is still occasionally missing days, that he's struggling to actually get into the swing of things. On the other hand, I really don't want him to form poor habits. He needs to be able to do the work he is capable of in school. So I'm worried about the backslide.

The last issue I have is that I've realised in the last few weeks that his class has become very competitive academically. DS has told me that he is the dumb one out of all of his class. And when I talked to the teacher about it, I've discovered that they do tests at the end of every week and that they are told their results in order of how they did, so DS and all of the class know how badly he is doing. That there is a constant threat of being moved down a class hanging over them if they don't do better. And I know my DS, if he feels like he is constantly failing he tells himself he doesn't care and he stops trying. Except he really does care and it's eating him up. I had him crying in my arms a few weeks ago about how he didn't realise he was so stupid and all because of work that he couldn't do at school but once I calmed him down and sat down to help him with, he did easily without any help at all.

I'm really, really worried about how to help him now. He can do the work but can't/won't do it at school.

OP posts:
scrappydappydoooooo · 17/01/2020 15:03

So, as an update on this things really have gone to hell at school. I've pulled DS out and am applying to other schools for next year. I feel a mixture of shit and relieved. But mostly relieved right now.

OP posts:
scrappydappydoooooo · 30/01/2020 13:52

Update 2 and more advice needed, please.

Right so, DS has been out of school for almost 3 weeks now and is like a new child. I realised that his school environment was honestly quite toxic for him and even reading back over some of my OP I'm pretty angry with myself for not seeing how bad his school experience was for him, as there were a few things he was telling me at the time that I was dismissing as him being overly sensitive. Since being out of school he has changed rapidly and drastically, right down to his ability to hold a conversation and express himself having improved dramatically. He's also started to read for pleasure and it's just amazing to watch him pick up a book and just get stuck in.

So here's where I could do with some advice. I feel like I now have a number of choices. I can homeschool him. I have no worries about homeschooling from an academic perspective, I think it would suit his learning style and I can work around him being home. However socially I'm not convinced I can provide him with enough interaction and I would have to work from home for 3-4 hours a day from late morning to early afternoon. I'd be free enough during that time to help him with schooling things but I wouldn't be able to take him to homeschool meet-ups.

That means sending him to school and I have two options. A small (religious) school in a nearby village which could potentially take him next month. Or a bigger, modern school which could take him in September. Either way, I'm thinking that this year of school would be a bit of a write off and letting him go back a class. His reading and maths ability is good for his age but his writing skills and stamina are weaker. He has genuinely had his confidence shattered at school and I think I'd rather him go back a year and build up his confidence than put him back into a situation where he is likely to struggle. He is also socially a bit young for his age in my opinion and he'd very possibly get on better with slightly younger children.

I don't know if it would be better to start him straight into school now, letting him go over stuff he did last year and gain confidence. Or give him some time off now and then let him start over next year. Would it be too hard for him to have nearly 8 months off and then dive into schooling at a level which he struggled with this year, partially down to illness and partially down to a fucking awful teacher. A huge part of me just wants to keep him home with me but that's partly because I sent him to what I truly believed was a super nurturing individualised learning environment (yes it was an independent school) and it turned out to be a shitty, honestly damaging environment. (He's not the only child to have left.) So I have a worry of once more sending him somewhere else that seems good and turns out to be awful. Especially as it took me far, far too long to recognise what was happening this time.

OP posts:
HomeMadeMadness · 30/01/2020 14:14

Poor thing OP. You're definitely making the right choice removing him from that school, it sounds dire. Could you try him in the small village school for now? How is his health? If he's still tired and has a weakened immune system you can try home schooling until at least Easter to let him recover.

I think home schooling can be great but not as a reaction to one bad school experience, depending on where you live it can be difficult to be accepted into the home school community. It may well be that the pressured environment of the school was the issue for DS not school in general.

scrappydappydoooooo · 30/01/2020 14:47

We really don't have much of a homeschool community where I live at all. I know that there are only a handful of families and they are all over the place geographically. Meet-ups tend to mean driving for the best part of an hour, in any direction, so you can't ever really guarantee the same people being at them. If DS was older and more able to manage his own friendships or if we lived in a neighbourhood where he could go out and play with other kids in the afternoons, I think I would just give homeschooling a go.

But I think I really do need to send him to a school. I think I'm leaning towards the smaller school. We are not religious and they have said he can take time to read/do art during religious instruction. I'm a little uncomfortable with that in some ways but I guess it could actually be a positive thing for him to have a little break during the day. I just have an absolute dread of making the wrong choice for him again.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread