Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to pay to repair ds's laptop?

35 replies

theduchessstill · 24/08/2019 21:37

About 6 months ago ex’s df bought ds2 a laptop. Ds has since complained that it is too ‘laggy’ to use for Roblox, which is all he wants to use it for really, and has told me that ex has said I need to pay to have it ‘cleaned’/fixed, which they (ds2 and ex) have apparently found out will cost about £80. Ds2 has told me ex has said that I need to pay for it as he (ex) can’t afford to.

I really don’t want to pay this because:

  1. I didn’t buy it. I’ve looked on the reviews for it and I think it was a cheap option and that it wasn’t the best choice for ds’s requirements. Why should I end up paying for someone else’s poor choice and will the work done actually have the desired effect?

  2. Ds uses my laptop when he’s with me – although he brings this laptop to mine he uses mine as usual because it’s better. I limit his time on it, as I would do even if he was using his own because that’s what parents do. He also has an xbox at mine (also time limited) so he doesn’t actually need this laptop when he’s at mine at all.

  3. I believe ex’s df bought the laptop because ex works from home on his laptop and allows the dc pretty much unlimited screen time. Ds2 doesn’t have a phone yet, or any other device, so I think this laptop was bought as a way of making ex’s life easier as ds2 would be able to go on it all the time at his house, allowing ex to work and generally have a quiet life. So I would therefore be paying for ex to have an easier life. It caused tension when it was bought between ds2 and his db – nothing similar was bought for ds1 and it wasn’t ds2’s birthday but it was just bought to get ds2 off ex’s laptop imo - and of course it was me who had to smooth that over…

  4. Ex pays no maintenance (CMS have taken him to court but that got me the grand total of £16 and he continues not to pay) and he buys the dc nothing. That does have a bearing in my reluctance to pay. He doesn’t work in full-time employment but is going away on holiday in a couple of weeks, smokes, drinks, and prioritises his ‘band’ over paid employment.

A slightly complicating factor is that ds2 recently broke ex’s laptop by spilling a glass of water over it. Ex has told him he can’t afford to replace it and he uses ds2’s laptop to work on whenever ds2 is there for a period of time, but since ds only spends 1 night a week there I’m not sure exactly what this ‘work’ that ex does is. Ds2 shouldn’t have spilt the water but it was an accident and if ex didn’t allow him to sit on screen the whole entire time it may not have happened – and surely I’m not responsible for ds2’s accidents when he’s with ex?

I can afford to pay it but I don’t spend £80 without some serious thought and I really don’t want to spend it on this. It seems ex will be a major beneficiary. I also feel like some research needs to be done to find out if it’s even worth it, and I don’t want to do that either – if I choose to buy the dc something major like that I look into it, but now I feel lumbered with picking up the pieces of someone else’s poor choice (not that I think ex df should have paid more – I wish he hadn’t bloody bought it). Ds2 has said he will spend his pocket money on it. He has about £300 saved that he has easy access to (more substantial savings are not accessible until he’s 18, luckily) but, again, I don’t want him to spend a sizeable chunk of his money on this, for mainly the same reasons that I don’t want to spend my money on it.

Any thoughts would be so much appreciated – this has been rumbling on for a while but seems to be coming to a head so I need to make a decision but I really don’t know whether or not I’m being UR to refuse to pay it and email ex telling him so and not to mention my paying it to ds again. DS is 10 if that’s relevant.

OP posts:
SweetPetrichor · 25/08/2019 13:56

I don't think it would be worth spending money trying to improve the laptop. It sounds like it's just not up to the spec required and no amount of tidying will solve that.

SweetPetrichor · 25/08/2019 13:57

He sounds like a sensible wee lad. It's not his fault that it's not up to snuff!

msmith501 · 25/08/2019 14:17

The only real upgrade option would be memory and it's negligible if it's underpowered. If it has 4gb ram then upgrade to 8gb ram if you can and windows 10 will run a lot better. Games need better graphics sadly and not worth or possible to retro fit a graphics card to most laptops. If you PM me I may be able to help.

user1471590586 · 25/08/2019 14:26

Sounds like it's a cheap laptop. Unless it has a decent amount of ram, a good graphics card and fast hard drive it will be slow.

user1471590586 · 25/08/2019 14:32

Do you know anyone who is good with computers who could look at it for you for free? That way your ex can't moan about it.

scaryteacher · 25/08/2019 19:48

@msmith501 The OP states that the ds spilled water into the laptop of the ex, thus accidental damage certainly does apply. I pay an awful lot in insurance premiums and have claimed twice in 25 years, precisely so I can claim if an accident does happen. I was not suggesting that the OP deliberately damages her son's laptop, and I hope you were not suggesting that I misclaimed either. Ds, who was 23 when this happened, was handed his arse on a plate for carelessness.

msmith501 · 26/08/2019 04:35

@scaryteacher

Hi, wasn't suggesting anything but I couldn't see an easy link between the ex's laptop which was damaged and could be sorted via insurance and the OP's DC's laptop which as far as I can tell is just slow rather than damaged. My fault so sorry. TBH I didn't originally read the part about the ex's laptop being broken as I was focusing on the slow spec laptop and it's something I know a bit about.

tttigress · 26/08/2019 06:57

Sounds like the problem does not have the right spec, nothing to do with "cleaning"

Angeldust747 · 26/08/2019 08:06

Sounds like it needs more RAM, which isn't hugely expensive in itself, but you can't always add more to laptops and you would need to get someone to open it up to find out. Agree with the other comments about freeing up disk space and defragmenting, all of that is free if you can follow some YouTube videos to show you x

msmith501 · 26/08/2019 18:34

Sorry to re-intervene. More ram will help windows 10 run a little bit faster. BUT the graphics capability required by many games (eg rain effects, lighting, textures, depth of field etc) can only be solved by a dedicated and expensive graphics card. RAM (memory) will help but the CPU will still have to put time aside (literally) to move the coloured pixels around on the screen and as a result the laptop will still be slow. Apologies if I sound like a know it all teat but it's what I do and have done since 1987.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread