Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to feel very ambivalent about this relative?

11 replies

Nextphonewontbesamsung · 14/06/2019 20:55

Just checking whether I'm being unreasonable or not because complex family relationships can make you feel very unsure. I've namechanged for this thread because I've posted about this relationship before and it's all extremely identifying, but I've been a regular on here since 2006. It's going to be long, sorry.

It's about my step-mother and her children, although she's not really my step-mother - she's my dad's second wife, my mother is still alive and has always been on the scene.

My dad left my mum and they divorced when I was 11 and my older brother was 16. A few years later (ie. not the cause of the split) he met and married sm. She was 17 years younger than him and they had 3 children. The first was born when I was 16 then they had another two when I was at University. Once he had this second family I barely saw my father - he was busy with them and I was busy with my life as a young adult and didn't live in the same city, although geographically we've never been more than a bit more over an hour's drive apart.

They had an extremely happy marriage and he was much better suited to being with her than my mother, all fine although I had to deal with the fall out of my mum being devastated by the divorce, the depression, the alcoholism, the damaged mental health and to some extent am still dealing with it now MORE THAN 40 YEARS LATER but anyway. They were suited to each other and very happy.

In 2010 my dad had a heart attack. He survived. But during the recovery period my SM phoned me up and told me that they had decided to exclude me and my older brother from his will. The reasoning was that we would inherit from our mother, and their three children had not been as lucky as me and my older brother with jobs, salaries and getting on the property ladder etc. I was shocked by this, especially that my father was too cowardly to tell me himself and left the task to my sm - but possibly that's because it was her decision to do this?

A year later he died. He had 5 children, 3 boys and 2 girls and he made the 3 boys the executor of his will. He always was a sexist dinosaur. She told me that he had left me and my older brother £10,000 each and something for my 2 children (his only grandchildren at the time). I have never seen the will and needless to say haven't had sight of this £10,000 - all I've been given as a memento is one pen.

On his deathbed my dad said to my older brother "please make sure you take care of sm" - ie he wanted him to sort out the will and funeral and everything that she'd have to cope with after he died. My older brother (pretty well off) has done this brilliantly as he is great at practical help, has no children and is to all intents and purposes single and now retired. Dad's younger children were 34, 32 and 29 when he died, my older brother was 54. My dad and my sm have always treated them like babies imvho.

Dad left my sm pretty well off. He had some good pensions (she was always a sahm). A few years later she sold the family house for £680,000 and "downsized" aged 68 to a 4 bed 2 bath house worth £500,000 and bought a £17,000 car. My older brother has done masses of work on this house decorating and doing it up, plumbing, kitchen work, garden work - all sorts. One of her 3 children still lives with her (this half sibling is now middle aged). I expect she has given a generous amount of cash to all 3 of their children. They certainly helped them out with loans and paying fees and rent when they were youngsters in a way that he never did with me.

I wasn't close to my dad, he wasn't a good dad to me even if he was to his other 4 kids. I was the big black sheep and I think we would have lost touch years earlier if I hadn't provided him with his only 2 grandchildren. The rest of them all seem to have him up on a pedestal.

Two of my sm's other middle aged children are not particularly close to her and don't seem to spend a lot of time with her - she's quite annoying so I think I can imagine why, although neither of them have actually voiced why to me. I'm not close to them either (huge age gap and just different lives) so we don't have those sort of conversations. I go months and years between seeing them or being in touch with them.

Anyway, I wonder why I'm expecting myself to maintain a relationship with her? She has 3 children of her own, 2 of whom don't make much effort. The other one lives with her. She gets a lot of help and assistance from my older brother, he obviously doesn't resent the lack of acknowledgement in the will. As she's got older she's become more difficult (as older people often do) and more irritating. I also have my own very old mother to think of as well as my parents in law. My half siblings don't bother with me at all bar the odd facebook message.

Why do I feel obliged to phone her from time to time and spend an hour listening to her woes? Would you bother? If my dad had been fabulous to me and I felt especially close to him maybe it would be different. But he largely ignored me because I was female, strongly feminist and not dependent on him. And they both wrote me out of his will.

Aibu? Wwyd?

OP posts:
Disfordarkchocolate · 14/06/2019 21:00

I'd check the will and ask where my money was.

SemperIdem · 14/06/2019 21:01

Honestly? No I wouldn’t bother. I wouldn’t be dramatic about it, just slowly and quietly decrease contact until it no longer existed.

Sometimes people just aren’t worth your time or effort. This is one of them.

Nextphonewontbesamsung · 14/06/2019 21:16

I have wondered about enquiring after the £10,000 but it seems provocative. I don't need it but it's symbolic I guess.

OP posts:
MonkeyTrap · 14/06/2019 21:21

Your SM isn’t exactly on her own, she has older children to look out for her. If she isn’t adding anything to your life then as someone else has said I would be minded to maintain a distance but stay polite.

Disfordarkchocolate · 14/06/2019 21:22

All the executors must carry out the wishes of the deceased so just ask your brother. It's not provocative to ask for your Father's wishes to be carried out, if you don't need the money set it aside for your children or give to your favourite charity (mine is Shelter if you need any inspiration).

S1naidSucks · 14/06/2019 21:24

I wouldn’t be at all surprised that you’ve been left an awful lot more than your father’s wife has stated. I can’t see him expecting your brother to look after his wife, but giving you both a paltry amount, in comparison to his wife and other children.

KTheGrey · 14/06/2019 21:36

If your brother is an executor he should sort out your inheritance because it's required by law, isn't it? But it is difficult to see that she brings anything to your life, or ever did. Does she actually expect you to keep in touch? Or are you imagining an obligation that you simply don't have?

KTheGrey · 14/06/2019 21:37

I think I mean - let yourself off the hook.

Nextphonewontbesamsung · 14/06/2019 21:45

KTheGrey - she sends cards and gifts and text messages to us. She phones at times of day I've repeatedly told her I'm busy (working) but doesn't leave a message. I think she would be horrified if she actually knew what I thought of this whole fucked up situation.

OP posts:
Millie2018 · 14/06/2019 22:23

You can request a copy of the will for £10 from the gov website
www.gov.uk/search-will-probate
This would allow you to see it without telling anyone. I’m assuming probate is settled as the dates suggest he died in 2011 and you get 2yrs.
I’d do this just for peace of mind.
In relation to your SM? It’s difficult because your father obviously thought he could rely on you and your brother to keep in touch with her for some reason. Maybe he didn’t truly understand how much hurt his actions caused.
In your position, I’d maintain minimal contact, but on your terms. Otherwise you may find yourself ostracised from your brother, who appears to be helping her out a lot.

KTheGrey · 16/06/2019 15:10

So she excludes you so she can bother you with unwanted and unnecessary contact?

I agree that your father wasn't that great to you, and I would both get the Will from Probate and find out about the money - particularly for your children; education is expensive these days, keep as many options open as possible. As nd then I would start stepping back from her. Always switch your phone off at work and only respond if and when you want to. Open new social media accounts you use frequently; leave the others and don't look at them. Write thank you notes for the presents, but otherwise - if you don't want to, I can't see that you have any obligation to her whatsoever. Flowers

New posts on this thread. Refresh page