Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Change of school for DD (9) Y4

13 replies

whylie · 27/04/2019 11:10

So my DD 9 has had some difficulties at her current school, she has been at current school since nursery.
Over last 6 years her group of friends she formed friendships with have slowly and gradually all left her current school ( moving some where else in the country etc)
So eventually my DD is on her own.
She has tried to form other friendships but they have not turned out as these children have already formed their groups.
What I found happening was she would play with a certain group of children, who she thought were her friends, but what they did was manipulate her into doing things she had never done before ( saying things to other children like name calling etc) basically it was like she had to prove herself. Then when she did do what they asked her to do, they would go tell the teacher or dinner lady and DD would get into trouble.
Obviously I told DD not to do those things etc and explained what that group was doing and to stay away from them.
DD started to play with some nicer children and was slowly forming a friendship with them. As DD was not interested in the other group anymore, they then decided to manipulate a boy, who they know is troubled and has behaviour issues.
They would say to this boy that DD said this or that about him or his friends (group leader is apparently this boys gf ) so he would go hit DD.
DD would tell me what happened and I spoke with the teacher. (This continued for few months)
I may get slandered for this but I told DD to hit him back!
DD is not a fighter in the slightest so what she did as in fighting back was to push the boy away from her (she would lift her leg in front of her more bracing herself from a kick she would receive from the boy, and using her arms to block from punches to her body) then to get away from him she would push him or kick out to stop him hitting her, To staff this her hitting him! I've told staff I have told her to hit him back but she won't, what she is doing is more a defensive move than actually hitting hit!

Now DD is not allowed out at lunchtimes, she has to go to clubs and is only allowed out on a Wednesday lunchtime, Same goes for the boy but he is only allowed out on a Thursday.

I've spoken to the HT about the whole situation and exactly how this all came about. But for some strange reason she seems to have excuses for each every time this boy has physically attacked my DD
HT;
( oh you see, Ms cottontail this boy had been to the dentist this morning and is feeling really groggy after having a filling, so he is more likely to be sensitive a lot quicker as he is in a lot of pain)
ME;
( you all ready know this child has behaviour issues (not Sen) if he was in that much pain, why not keep him off as my DD now is in pain due to been punched in the back by the boy)

My DD has been following the lunchtime decision for over a term and a half without no issues of her own, However the boy has not been sticking to it, continuously running out at lunchtimes, even on Wednesdays when it DD day out, May I add physically hitting her when doing so.

So this week DD comes home and tells me this boy was out on her day out, she told dinner lady it is not his day his day is a Thursday (has been for the term and a half) dinner lady says " I know it's not just keep away from him" ( nothing happened between boy and DD this time)
Do I phoned school spoke to AH and she said there was miscommunication between staff as to what day boy is out, to which I responded this has been the same for over a term (same staff) and there is a time table stating who is were what day, so I don't understand how miscommunication happened, She assured me won't happen again.

DD spoke to me and said she feels like it is unfair that she is sticking to the timetable and still is only allowed out on a Wednesday, why can't she go out Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, stay in on Thursday away from the boy and go out Friday.
I realised she had a point and spoke to AH to which she said " as DD is struggling with friendships that it would be better for her to attend these clubs to form friendships and to build a friendship with this boy!" I told AH " she was forming a friendship with the nicer kids but as she is in these clubs this is preventing her from doing so as they don't attend these clubs and as for forming a friendship with this boy, why should my DD be kept away from those nicer kids to form a friendship with this boy, at the end of the day your trying to form a friendship with a boy who physically hits her due to been manipulated by the other group and because he has issues and tbh I don't want my DD any where near him, let alone a friend!"

So I decided to look at a different school for DD, the one I viewed is absolutely amazing and she will thrive.
There is space and could start next term.

AIBU to move DD? She did ask if she could go to a different school as she does want to go to current school as she feels she is been treated like the boy (to which she is) I have not told DD I've viewed this school, i have another viewing booked for Tuesday with DD. It is just such a big change and I'm in to minds wether to do it or not, there is more positive than negatives, any advice would be massively appreciated Thanks

Very well done getting through this post too Thanks

OP posts:
AJPTaylor · 27/04/2019 11:19

Change.
Youngest dd changed schools in y5 due to a house move. She went from having a friend and a target to having 7 good friends she is off to secondary. She is a different child.

PlainSpeakingStraightTalking · 27/04/2019 11:21

If she is genuinely not happy, as no friends and you don't feel supported, then move her. BUT. Always a but, IF the problem is with your DD's inability to make friends, then that problem will go with her. It wont be a magical cure.

That said, for my DS moving him from a similar school to one with a better SEN provision meant he thrived because bullying was absolutely stamped out

Don't take this he wrong way but, a couple of things you've said lead me to think your DD has some form of additional needs too.

Also bear in mind, that depending on your area, it is possible all these children will meet up again at secondary. Our local secondary has 76 potential feeder primaries. But I realise not everywhere is like London.

SnowyAlpsandPeaks · 27/04/2019 11:23

Do it!!!!

outsho · 27/04/2019 11:23

I wouldn’t even hesitate OP.

My DC (including DS who is same age as your DD) moved schools in September due to house move. My DS only had one friend in the previous school and very little confidence, he has come on leaps and bounds in this school and I’m so pleased- it’s lovely to see.

The school isn’t working for your DD so don’t even hesitate. They’re seriously letting her down imo, she shouldn’t be forced to stay indoors all day like a prisoner!

Madasahattersteaparty1749 · 27/04/2019 11:32

Definitely move her. I moved my eldest dd after a turbulent start to year 4 and she is absolutely thriving.

Louloulovesyou · 27/04/2019 12:56

I moved my kids around that age. Best decision ever. Nicer Head teacher, lovely teachers, nice parents and lovely children. Go for it!

Louloulovesyou · 27/04/2019 13:08

Also i think the Head teacher is literally mad saying your daughter should make friends with the child who hits her. It's an absolutely terrible life lesson....you don't want your daughter to think that the way to deal with being physically abused is to offer friendship. Not a great lesson for the boy either, i wonder what goes on in his home. She is worth much more.

BarbarianMum · 27/04/2019 13:12

Without a doubt, move her. Seriously, I wouldn't hesitate.

Ihatemyseleffordoingthis · 27/04/2019 13:18

The school is handling this awfully, they are not addressing this child's behaviour or the bullying behaviour that has caused it. There is no way I would have countenanced my child being excluded from playtimes for a term - tbh even more than a couple of days as a sanction would have been sufficient. The other child deserves better too.

Move her like a shot. And complain.

whylie · 28/04/2019 09:21

Thank you so much for replying and getting through my post!Thanks

My gut after seeing the other school instantly said "move her"

Thank you again Smile I was really hoping to hear lots of positives about others moving school at similar ages.
ThanksThanksThanks

OP posts:
Justgivemesomepeace · 28/04/2019 09:41

My dd moved in year 5. It was like a breath of fresh air. Do it.

Monny1 · 28/04/2019 09:58

Yes, move her. I moved my son (year 5) to a new primary school, as we had issues at his last school. I only wished that l had moved him sooner.

Marylou62 · 28/04/2019 10:00

OP.. I could have written your post, almost word for word! Move her..Best thing we ever did although it was to a school 7 miles away . First school walking distance. Fresh start. My DC is now 22 and still says it was the right thing to do. (Even a teacher told me they were upset on my DCs behalf about always getting the blame and unfair punishments, so would be better for DC to move!)
I could write an essay but I don't need to..you wrote it for me!
The only difference being we just took them out after yet another incident..We didn't have another school lined up. Luckily new school was fab!
Good luck

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread