Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to move DS to a new nursery at nearly 3yo?

46 replies

flamingofridays · 13/02/2019 11:03

DS has attended the same nursery since 9 months old, he is now almost 3.

No issues with nursery, but we moved house to around 20 mins away. Had always planned to keep him at the same nursery as that's all he knows, and I work in the same town as nursery to I drive here anyway.

However, doing every single pick up and drop off is taking its toll on me, and I don't think the drive is doing DS any favours as he's falling asleep on the way home most nights.

We also realised that when he goes to school, none of the children he knows will be at the same school as him, and I don't think that's ideal for him.

We thought about moving him to a nursery which is a 5min walk from our house, and also DPS work.

I would drop him off on a morning (DP at work at crack of dawn) and DP could pick him up most nights, and me maybe once or twice a week. I would also get stuck in a lot less traffic, because I would be setting off 15 mins earlier from the town my work is in because I wouldn't have to stop at nursery.

The nursery we have in mind is actually now managed by the previous manager of our current nursery. She is fabulous and I trust her implicitly. It is also £25 a week cheaper, which is a bonus but not something im making a decision based on. We don't have the money now, so its not like we miss it.

it seems like a no brainer when you think about it with no emotion.

However, I am really getting distraught about it. I am wondering whether I am ruining my childs life by even considering this. This is the only nursery he has ever known, he has bonded with most of the staff (some are quite new) and the children. There are 4 especially wonderful women who have worked there since he started and he absolutely adores them and so do I. I would almost feel as though I was personally insulting them. In an ideal world I would be rich enough to hire one of them to be his nanny but unfortunately I cannot afford their wonderful services!

I have weighed up the pros and cons of each nursery and I just feel stuck. Its a real head vs heart decision, and although DP is v reassuring that we are not in fact going to scar our child for life and cost him £££ in therapy, I still don't know what to do.

On one hand, I keep him in the nursery he knows, and he is exhausted for the next 18 months (and so am I), but generally happy and settled. He however wont know a single child at his new school when he goes.

On the other, we move him, take him away from everything he knows, but he will hopefully settle and it will set him up a little better for school (its next to the primary school he will most likely go to, so environment / walk will be familiar) , and hopefully he may meet some other children who will go with him. I will also get a bit of a break and DP will get a little more time with DS which I know he would appreciate.

Can anyone tell me if they have done something similar at a similar age? or whether I really am being an awful and selfish parent?

thank you

OP posts:
flamingofridays · 13/02/2019 14:48

its reassuring to hear positive stories of children settling well. I think DS will settle quite quickly, I think I will probably be more sad than him and that's half the issue isn't it.

Nothing can last forever.... ahhhh

OP posts:
CottonSock · 13/02/2019 14:50

I moved mine when a new nursery opened that would guarantee kids from the school we decided on (different language). It did take a little while to settle, but worth it.

Rach000 · 13/02/2019 15:14

My dd moved nursery recently at 3 years and 10 months. She had been at her old one since she was 19 month old. It was a hard decision and I was worried I was making the wrong one and did feel bad about telling the old nursery she was leaving as they had looked after her for so long.
We moved as there was a couple of small issues with the old nursery and there was another nursery I liked nearby that was outstanding and did longer hours which will help. Also have a younger dd who I wanted to put in the other nursery as well.
Anyway she settled in really well and loves it now. I explained she would be moving to her and told her about the new toys etc so she was excited. She did miss friends a little but has made new ones now. Also for you it would be great if he could go to school with some from nursery. So I would say definatly move him. Sounds like the best plan all round.

reluctantbrit · 13/02/2019 15:28

We ha this dilemma. In the end we kept DD at her nursery but it was a difficult time.

The main reason for us is that the area we live in now does not have any decent full day nurseries, it is an ideal of childminder and pre schools. As lovely as it may be, it wasn’t for us. So we took the other way, drove 4 days a week during road work, bad weather, frost in the morning (you learn fast to get a decent car cover).

From a child’s point of view we found that from 3 onwards a lot of new children came where parents opted for the funded hours in a nursery setting compared to a pre school, some mixed and matched, so I think getting used to new children is ok and the staff knows how to handle it.

DD is best friend with one of her nursery pals and close with two others. But that was because we parents became friends, just based on the kids it wouldn’t have happened.

Re schooling, due to this, DD knew just 2 out of 60 children in her year group, one she had only met 2-3 before, the other a bit more. It didn’t matter at all. It mattered a bit more for me as the other mums were close but I wasn’t there to make friends, just enough to create a bit of networking and knowing people to contact in emergencies, the rest came on it’s own.

BubblesBuddy · 13/02/2019 15:38

flamingofridays: Your Ds really does not love the nursery children. He will not remember who they are fairly soon because new children will come into his life. You are being over dramatic. Be practical. Just move him. It really will not be a big deal for him and will make life easier for you.

He will have to get used to friends coming and going throughout his school life and nursery children really do not form firm attachments. It is fleeting and pragmatic.They just play. They do not care deeply for other children. If you should ever decide you want him to go to a secondary school where none of his friends are going, what anguish will you go through then? This is not a big issue for a nursery age child. So relax about it.

WeeDoughball · 13/02/2019 15:44

We had the same scenario and moved DS the month before he turned 3.

It was almost exact situation as we moved and there was a brilliant nursery across the road from our house vs old nursery near our work in the city centre.

He settled no problem and it made life much better as rather than sit in the car for 40 minutes he can play with friends until pick up and then it's less than a minute home. It also means he'll be going to school with kids he already knows which is nice and highly unlikely if he'd stayed at the old nursery.

Another (unplanned) bonus was that during mat leave with DC2 I can walk across to drop off/pick up. If he'd still been in city I'd either have had to do the hellish journey during rush hour with a baby or DH would have had to do all drop offs/pick ups and have DS1 getting home late even when I'm off.

flamingofridays · 14/02/2019 10:00

bubbles you don't have to be so dismissive.

I had actually already said I wasn't worried about him making friends with new children, it was the bond with the adults I was more concerned about. If you're going to shoot me down at least read my comments!

to everyone else...

I called the nursery to have a look round, they may not have any full time places until September, but we're going to have a look round anyway, and if we like it we will put his name down for one of those places. He will still have a year there, and as his key worker mentioned, most of his friends (he tends to play with the older ones) are leaving for school in September anyway.

OP posts:
flamingofridays · 22/02/2019 12:02

hi again everyone,

we saw the new nursery last night. DS was straight in there playing, the staff seemed nice, plenty to do there, nice garden also.

really short walk from home as well, so will be much better for DS than a 40 plus min car ride stuck in traffic each night!

I am going to hand our notice in at the current nursery tonight, I told one of the ladies this morning and we both had tears in our eyes! I am genuinely gutted for him to leave there, but its the right option for him right now.

my next task is to organise some lovely thank you cards and a little presents for the main ladies who have cared for him, and maybe some chocolates for the staff in general. Does that seem like too much?! they really have done so much for us in 2 years, and I know its their job and they get paid for it but they have gone above and beyond.

thanks again for all your advice and helping me decide!

OP posts:
waterrat · 22/02/2019 12:04

OP I'm sure you will cry a lot - but it sounds like the right option.

flamingofridays · 22/02/2019 12:06

yes I think there will be lots of tears on his last day!

OP posts:
MrsJayy · 22/02/2019 12:14

Of course you will have a cry it is normal. Fwiw i used to be a nursery nurse and i used to have a little cry when kids moved on you get attached to little peopleSmile

mystifiedinbrighton · 22/02/2019 12:17

I did this and moved my DC just after 3rd birthday, for much the same reasons as you. It was a thought at the time but he'd made great pals with those he will go to school with.

It's totally the right thing and much easier at this age.

mystifiedinbrighton · 22/02/2019 12:18

he'd = he's

hsegfiugseskufh · 22/03/2019 10:56

hi everyone (I don't think it will show me as OP as I have since de regged, and re regged under a new name)

so today is DS last day, he is not at all phased but I cried like a baby, so did a couple of the staff there. I feel absolutely awful, have no confidence in the decision I have made and am pathetically worried that i've inadvertently ruined his life.

DP is trying to reassure me and logically he's right, better the change now than just before school, his keyworker is actually leaving today too, and most of his friends there are older and will be going to school in September anyway.

It broke my heart to see him running in happy, and knowing it would be the last time.

NWQM · 22/03/2019 11:06

Totally get how hard this decision. We also moved our daughter after much thought. We talked to her about going to the big new nursery, brought new bag etc.

She settled in quickly and much better than the first time at the first nursery.

Having some friends when he starts school really is a bonus. No doubt the nursery will have links with the school and he is likely to have visits from his teacher etc. Is that possible at the nursery he is at?

hsegfiugseskufh · 22/03/2019 11:15

to be honest, DS is fine. I have told him its his last day, that he needs to have a lovely day and enjoy himself, because he will go to his "different nursery" (what hes been calling it) on Monday.

I don't think he gets it, which is whats making it hard for me. I know that I'm taking away everything he knows, and he doesn't. Its honestly awful.

I think he will be fine, he's had 3 settling in visits, cried each time I left, but each time they have called me within 5 minutes to tell me he's settled, and when I have gone back to pick him up, he's been happily playing / eating / listening to a story.

Its so selfish but I am finding it so hard! he seems excited to go back to "different nursery" but he doesn't realise he wont see the adults he trusts so much anymore.

WRT school, he would v possibly get a short visit from his teacher at his current nursery but that would be it, the new nursery is attached to the school and they go there often on the run up to school, and obviously hes a far far bigger change of some children from this nursery going up to school with him.

SheldonSaysSo · 22/03/2019 14:06

Maybe you could see if any of the old nursery staff babysit privately? Then if you need someone for evenings out etc, you could stay in touch.

hsegfiugseskufh · 25/03/2019 09:39

I don't think they do tbh, but I have added them all on facebook, and a couple have suggested meeting up for lunch or something so that would be nice, just have to leave it a few weeks so we don't confuse poor ds even further :(

Gooseygoosey12345 · 25/03/2019 09:52

Please don't worry. I had to move my daughters nursery, and I also had to move her schools. She settled in just fine and now she's a bit older I actually think it's helped her develop the skills to make new friends and feel confident in new environments as she learned to adjust from a young age. We also moved schools as children and I feel it's done the same for us regarding adaptability skills

hsegfiugseskufh · 25/03/2019 12:18

im trying not to worry, it's just really hard to take your child away from their comfort zone though choice isn't it! TBH I feel like bit of a twat for even considering it, though I hope it will be the right decision in the long term.

I dropped him off this morning and he cried for his old nursery and asked if he could have his last day again. Felt absolutely awful about it.

They did call me 5 mins later to say he was fine, but am anxious to see how he is at pick up.

hsegfiugseskufh · 26/03/2019 13:41

pleased to report that he seemed fine at pick up, happy enough and was talking to the carers (never sure what word to use there!)

he cried again this AM but hoping hes settled!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread