Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Family expectations too high

33 replies

Whatwouldwebewithoutfamily · 29/01/2019 10:01

I had a rough few weeks arguing with my siblings and my parents over Christmas as I refused to go to visit.
It is a very expensive trip for me and family and we are usually treated to icy accommodations, no hot water and my siblings expect me to take over with looking after very elderly parents while my own family (2 DCs teenagers and DH) sit around in the freezing cold (they can wear extra layers apparently) doing nothing as where my family lives there’s virtually nothing to do in the winter. We have done this in the past but now teenagers kids and DH refuse to come! I also work full time and can’t take much time off around holidays.
Siblings say it’s not their problem and that they look after elderly parents all year and they should relieved during some of the holidays. I can’t go on my own and leave my own family at Christmas... plus I don’t really want to go honestly.

Backstory is that I left home young as I didn’t get on with any of them apart from one sibling and my mum who tried to understand me but disagreed with me and I was told I was a rebel and would never amount to anything good.

With maturity I realise that I am very different from all of them, I am one of those annoying people who are always happy and trying to see good in everything ... I used to feel ashamed of being so cringe but I have come to accept and appreciate the way i am now but they are all the total opposite. Everything is doom and gloom... all is bad and there’s no solution. They are all sick or talking about what sickness they might have. Or how likely is they might lose job and have no way to support themselves.
In reality they all have good homes, good kids and easy jobs. It’s just the constant worry that is always hanging over them.
On the other hand I have much less than them but I am grateful for my work , my health and my family. So when I see them I feel constantly drained. Like I am the lucky one and they are unlucky.
As I live away they imagine I have a splendid life with no problems!
So their attitude to me is that I am selfish and they highly disapprove of me not going. However I have never been able to ask them for help as I know they are too far away and If I ever try to talk about my own problems they are brushed under the carpet with a smirk and saying aren’t you the happy one.... so I never expect them to do something for me. I don’t even expect moral support or a good word saying poor you. Whereas they would just spend hours on the phone talking for hours about what’s wrong with their lives and I have to show sorrow and concerns. And be careful about the words I use as if I try to cheer them up it then becomes “ here we go again! You never grow up you always believe in fairies!”

I know I could just go no contact but I love them and also feel lonely that I don’t have that family relationship that so many have around me. My kids would love to have cousins over and go and see uncles. But we pretty much avoid each other.

Not sure why I am writing this...probably just a rant as in RL nobody would understand or know my struggle and how much it affects me.

OP posts:
user1473878824 · 30/01/2019 01:06

I think you have to take into account that while your parents may have carers your siblings are also there and worried and responsible. You aren’t. And it seems like you won’t help, even at Christmas. If I were them I’d be making a scene too.

Whatwouldwebewithoutfamily · 30/01/2019 07:41

Cantstopmenow are you me? It’s complicated... the cultural side of things too that people like User1473878824 won’t be able to grasp.
When I left 15 years ago there was a lot of grudge as I was early thirties and unmarried so expected to become my parents maid and look after them even when they were healthy.
I don’t blame them as it’s their culture and expected. I am glad I broke the rules as I can see now my nieces are allowed to dream about a career and they will quote me as their example.

But you are right, the sense of duty and guilt and the love is all there. So I will go and my best anytime

OP posts:
StreetwiseHercules · 30/01/2019 08:07

I wouldn’t bother TBH. It sounds like these people aren’t very nice to you and haven’t really been very nice throughout your life. “Family ties” and “duty” are just a way of controlling people mostly.

People can be quite entitled and expect too much from each other.

MoreCheeseDear · 30/01/2019 08:28

My father's carers came on Christmas Day, Boxing day and NYE. It's their job and they did it gladly. They got him up, breakfasted and dressed and we drove over to bring him to us for the day then they were there to put him to bed.

There's no reason why your parents' carers can't do the same, especially as they are paying.

Namenic · 31/01/2019 06:31

OP - sounds like a good plan to go over summer. I think they would appreciate the gesture - try it at least and see how it goes. If not then maybe try paying for respite carers for holiday periods so your siblings get a break and visit when flights cheap/you have a spare weekend. You can only try your best! Good luck.

punishmepunisher · 31/01/2019 06:49

What culture is this out of curiosity? I'm shocked you'd have been expected to be their maid. Sad

Whatwouldwebewithoutfamily · 31/01/2019 22:36

Punish
Can’t say as it’s outing... moreover it is not put that way. So if you are female and unmarried the expectation is that you live at home and don’t go out to work. The cleaning and cooking and looking after parents other males in the family is taken for granted and expected. Even after getting married the daughter is expected to do most of the care of the elderly parents. Sons are not expected to contribute in any way.

So by leaving I reversed the norm.. hence my brothers are not happy with me... and they pay for carers and a cleaner. However I have noticed that having carers is more accepted there Now. But having carers on Christmas or holidays is frowned upon and seen as shameful as parents left with strangers so they would never do that.

It’s complicated...

OP posts:
Baconmaker · 31/01/2019 22:50

YOu sound like a lovely person OP. It's difficult I do think you should make some effort to help with parents but do so in your own way with as little misery incurred to you and your family as possible.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread