to wonder why on the back of the madeline McGann 'incident' places like butlins still ofer a baby sitting service....

[LowFatMilkshake]

So parents can leave thier children in thier apartments and go out for the evening?!

I am only asking this because I have been watching the cinema thread about MM and this though cropped up.

we are staying at Butlins in Sept and I was told about this service by an aunt.

sorry to correct btu mcCann

not sure she belonged toa legendary acting dynasty

because people still want to use it.

baby sitting?

whats wrong with baby sitting?

Thank you Cod!

Whats wrong with wanting to use a babysitting service to look after your child? Haven't thought about whether I'd use it or not but there is obviously a market for it! Isn't it being a responsible parent to make sure your child is being looked after while you go out?

Because it's not actually sittng in the room with the shild, but walking round responding to monitors.....

lol enid - yes, why would anyone want to go out at all??!

'child'

I thought that Madeleine wasn't being 'babysat'. I wouldn't be keen. But other people still might be.

cross posted....

I think you have to leave it up to individual parents to make decisions about what they are happy with in this situation.

Why - are you saying it was the McCann's fault for leaving their daughter? Sure they think this every day but I know several people who have since admitted that they have either done the same or would have happily done the same in the past.

because the point is they weren't using it. It was offered, but they said no. So that really has got nothing to do with how useful the service may or may not be.

because the McCann's weren't using such a service so the "incident" has no bearing on whether it is safe.

because what happened was a 1 in a million tradgedy and you can't live in fear foreverything that might happen.

because you are more likely to lose your child in a playground accident at butlins than have it kidnapped...

Because people will still want to go out, so at least them offering a service is better than nothing at all

doon think the mcGanns were involved

Floss is right, Madeleine wasn't being babysat. So case has little relevance to babysitting services.

Butlins 'babysitting' service is just staff walking round the camp accomodation responding to monitors wherre parents have infomraed them a child has been left alone.

Call me eccentric, but every child has a right to call out in the night and get responded to by thier parent, grandparent or someone else they know.....

Oh, my post was to answer OP, btw, not in reply to other responses, in case of confusion!!

A couple of differences:

[a]my understanding is room/chalet doors are locked, sitter has master key.

[b]Monitors are being used.

Neither happened with Maddie sadly.

Sounds more like baby listening ...

But LFM, that has bugger all to do with the McCann case. Persumably you had those opinions before that?

also if the service is offered, people decline offer and leave kids alone and something happens, then Butlins are covered in case of any claim i would think

Yes I did have this opinion before the case and I realise the likenesses are weak.

But I would still not go on a family holdiday to leave my children unattended. If it is late and they are tired and we are hungry we go home and one of us goes out to get dinner and eat in.

However, I did think the McCanns apartment was locked and the abducters broke in by forcing metal shutters - no key required.

In that case this is just a re-hashing of threads ad nauseam and not a discussion about babysitting/listening services and whether or not the McCann case has affected their provision...

And I would like to add that this thread does not mean I am not extremely sympathetic to the McCanns, or that in any way do I think they are to blam for what happened and I wish with all my heart that they find thier little girl alive and well.

I am just saying that thier case has highlighted concerns I have and that given what happened to the McCanns I am surprised that corporations like Butlins are still providing service which would encourage to parents to leave leave children unattended.

No MAMFM it is not a rehash