Cantchoose - you may well be one of the "good guys" - that doesn't negate the experience of myself and others who have repeatedly come across gp's who:
don't listen
are dismissive, even outright rude
prescribe medications without checking for allergies or contraindications that are unsuitable for the patient
fob patients off with clear symptoms of conditions that require specialist input to even get a correct diagnosis
call patients - even within medical notes - neurotic and hysterical
dismiss them as parents when they KNOW something is amiss with their child
call patients with mental illness "time wasters" and "attention seekers"
claim to have given patients advice on smoking, drinking when that's not true to gain financially for their practice...
And in my personal experience the good GPs are very much few and far between. Due to my background (army dependent for 30+ years) I've had a lot of GPS I estimate (quick tot up) I've seen approximately 20+ in my life of those 4 I would describe as good, conscientious, non-dismissive, genuinely helpful GPs.
I have asthma which went not properly Dx for several years as a child, endo which went undx for 14 years and I lost 3 babies before it was despite classic clear textbook symptoms, I never got a referral to gynae until after it was Dx as a result of a complex mc which required surgery and the surgeon spotted it. Dd has a disability which I know now (I'm not a dr and certainly this condition outside my realm of knowledge) she was ALSO displaying clear symptoms from birth - and in fact I'm now concerned it's actually a different condition which is very serious possibly life threatening, but which has some similar symptoms - but which she has glaringly obvious physical characteristics which again dd had from birth. She's also had all year - since January - ongoing very distressing gynae symptoms which the GPs keep just giving her treatment for thrush/bv/uti - even though test results keep coming back saying that's not what it is! I think it may be related to the disability, her and I have both said so to the practice and been dismissed - even though none of the GPs have ever had training in the area related to her disability. She's a 17 yr old worried, in pain, experiencing other very distressing symptoms and she is terrified that if it isn't Dx and treated soon she may lose her fertility or even worse. I'm trying not to show her but I'm equally worried. There's a history of female cancers - at very young ages - in the family - this info has also been dismissed!
My mum had clear cancer symptoms dismissed, only Dx when she was admitted to a&e for something else and the dr noticed something 'not right'. We are very lucky she had that minor fall!
Several family members I only learned relatively recently had clear symptoms of gall bladder disease dismissed until the situation reached crisis point.
My grandmother had medication she had used for years and was fine on, changed without warning from a branded version to a generic one by a new GP - the reason she was on the branded version was because she was allergic to something in the coating on the generic version - this was in her medical records - it wasn't something immediately obvious especially to an elderly woman with poor eyesight. Cue allergic reaction and unnecessary hospital admittance.
So you tell me exactly why I should trust GPS? When my experiences tell me to do the exact opposite!
The 4 GPs who were good ones:
Listened
Didn't dismiss or patronise
Didn't simply settle for treating the symptoms.
Were conscientious in checking medical history & allergies etc when prescribing - my current one (I've so many meds allergies now it is awkward) asks me "is X one you can take?" Before starting the prescription process on the computer. And understands why I get nervous about trying one I haven't taken before and gives me advice for what to do if I am allergic in relation to the likely symptoms with that med.
Went above and beyond on occasion for myself or my dd, getting quite insistent on our behalves when on 2 separate occasions we were both extremely ill. I believe literally saving our lives.
If I could replicate/clone those 4 or have them train all the other GPs and tell them not to be such arses I would!
Gp's also have the status and power to CHANGE the system - either individually or via organisations like rcgp.
The 4 "good" Gp's I've referenced have also campaigned - in their own time - on issues like mental health, childhood allergy Dx & treatment, gynae issues, mc & stillbirth. Have voluntarily attended support groups for patients to answer questions etc.