Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask those that get on with their mil...

69 replies

ILoveHumanity · 04/12/2018 09:17

Did you go through a phase where you tried to “make it work” against the grain ?

Have you forgiven her for something major before and has it come back to bite you ?

How do you communicate boundaries ?

How do you rebuild trust once it’s broken ?

OP posts:
BarbedBloom · 04/12/2018 10:17

We get on well, but at first it was a little difficult as she struggled to let go of my DH. I was his first very serious relationship and it just took some adjustment really as she was used to him going to her about things first and running all decisions by her etc. He also lived with her at the time, so she was used to him being around a lot and found it hard when he was coming down to visit me a lot. It is fine now and she is a lovely woman. At the end of the day I tried to empathise with her, especially as he was her youngest and the most like his dad who had died years before.

Tinaarena · 04/12/2018 10:18

I love my Mil now, although after ds was born there were so many boundary issues that at one point I told dp I never wanted to see here again on my house. She's an alcoholic and I never wanted her around my child.

It was her first grandchild and I see she was just so excited by him but it continually felt I was being pushed out so she could play mum. Time healed and she settled down and I actually realised she could play an important part in his life - my own mother isn't the nan id love her to be but mil is.

We lost fil last year and I watched her care for him through her own pain. of all the people I would have bet my life savings on her not pulling through - she's amazed me no end. She signed up to a college course, she signed up to AA and has been sober for nearly 18 months now, she went and got herself a part time job and now her and ds have sleepover that he adores.

Sometimes you have to go through the pain, let it heal and then you can see them as a different person than you once thought.

Hideandgo · 04/12/2018 10:19

In answer to your four questions,

Never needed to
Never needed to
Never needed to
Never needed to

BertrandRussell · 04/12/2018 10:20

I get on with mine. I don’t like her very much, she doesn’t like me very much, but we are cordial, which is all that is needed. Her main relationship is with my dp and the children and they love her - she’s a good mother and a fab grandmother.

As to your questions-I would deal with any of those things the way I would deal with them in any other relationship.

DontCallMeCharlotte · 04/12/2018 10:21

I expect some of our MILs are just normal people, who don’t need boundaries established

This.

My MIL was just delighted that I was making her son happy and when we announced our engagement, she vowed not to interfere and she never has.

We're not soulmates (there's a 40 year ago gap for goodness sake), but we are hugely fond of each of other and would both drop everything to help each other.

I'm sorry OP that's not really answering your question.

DontCallMeCharlotte · 04/12/2018 10:22

*age gap

SauvingnonBlanketyBlanc · 04/12/2018 10:22

Mine is fine in small doses Grin our relationship has improved as my ds has got older,I had pnd and she used to grate on me a lot.Im friendly,polite and all that jazz but we are very different people so haven't got a lot in common unfortunately.

SylvanianFrenemies · 04/12/2018 10:24

No. She's just a nice, normal person, who I care for and respect.

We don't have a friendship beyond our family relationship, but that's fine. There's never been any drama.

Augusta2012 · 04/12/2018 10:25

Mine is very sadly deceased but she was a lovely lady I would have chosen to be friends with if I’d met her in other circumstances.

I do think a lot of people go into relationships expecting to hate their MIL and it becomes a self fulfilling prophecy.

It does sound like you might not be the easiest person for a MIL to get along with - you seem to be working from the assumption all MILs are horrible.

WorraLiberty · 04/12/2018 10:26

I love my MIL and my ex MIL.

No need to 'establish boundaries' etc.

doyouneedtoknow · 04/12/2018 10:27

My mother in law was a kind, wonderful lady but she did used to annoy me now and then. She was a proper 70's housewife and a single mum with three boys. She felt like she had to do everything for them. She would jump up to make tea and sandwiches whilst they lounged in a chair. She even did eldest sons washing and ironing when he was well into his 40's and divorced. However, she was a wonderful mother and grandmother and I never heard her say a bad word against anyone (unless they really deserved it). She died a few years ago and she is greatly missed

TidyDancer · 04/12/2018 10:27

My DP was in a very long and unhealthy relationship prior to being with me so I think MIL was just grateful that I loved her boy and wasn't going to stomp all over him and make him miserable! So we got on from the beginning I think.

On paper, we have absolutely nothing in common whatsoever but we respect each other and both love DP. I think even when you don't get on or like each other, being able to respect the other persons position is a good starting point.

BertrandRussell · 04/12/2018 10:28

The only time I ever hear the word “boundaries” is when people on here talk about their mils.........

myselfandme · 04/12/2018 10:28

I try very hard to like my mil, I really do. And she has some very good attributes.
She's an amazing cook and has taught me a few things, she is great at organising anything, She's good at talking! (im socially awkward and I watch and learn from her).

But the second I let her in just a little bit, she oversteps her boundary and starts trying to control everything, from my Dcs haircuts, to their after school activities, to how our house should be laid out, to what I should wear everyday! Honestly it's suffocating.
She even told her daughter to get pregnant asap and I heard her asking her if she's had sex with her husband that past week to make sure they were trying!

I admire her in a lot of ways but I also dislike her for other things and that's sad to me.

Hoppinggreen · 04/12/2018 10:31

Up until a year ago I would have posted on here about how well I get on with my MIL. Unfortunately I actually challenged her on something ( nothing major and I was polite) and I’ve seen what she’s really like
She is a genuinely lovely helpful person UNLESS you won’t agree with her version of reality and then she is bloody awful. After “the incident” me and DH discussed it at length and with hindsight we could see how she truly is. After that because we refuse to get drawn into her drama she swings from “poor me, how could you treat me so badly” and other emotional blackmail to a really nasty spiteful woman as we still refuse to engage beyond a minimal level of politeness.. Even the dc now see it ( although we are careful not to say too much in front of them) and they aren’t bothered about seeing her either.
Unfortunately I don’t see how things could ever go back to the lovely relationship we used to have because even if I decide to completely forgive and forget things she said can’t be unsaid. It makes me sad but if I was to ever be the same as I was with her before it would just be me pretending and the relatiinship wouldn’t be genuine any more.

LavenderBush · 04/12/2018 10:32

Mine is truly lovely and I would defy anyone not to like her.

She is kind and thoughtful and I don't think we've had any of the issues mentioned in your OP.

Obviously she is human, and I might think she's a bit misguided sometimes. But in general she's probably a nicer person than me and deserves a lot of slack cut for her when she (imo) makes the wrong decision about something.

anothermothersusername · 04/12/2018 10:32

I think a lot of depends on the reasons why the mil and dil don’t get on to be honest. In my case she just didn’t like me and nothing will ever change that. I was never rude to her or horrible. I don’t see her now because she along with her partner were rude to me one too many times. The last time they were rude to mad it was in front of my son and that was the last straw. They go to church, like to be upstanding members of the community. They were horrible to me for years. I wish I had a mil I was close to. I feel like I’ve missed out.

PurpleCrazyHorse · 04/12/2018 10:34

I get on absolutely fine with my PIL. My MIL tends to over love and certainly feeds you up to show how much she loves you!! DH has had to help with some boundaries and I'm quite a strong personality so I guess she realised I was doing it my/our way when DD was born.

Only a small number of hiccups along the way, mostly over the DCs when they were babies and how things have changed since MIL had children. I think the key was that DH always had my back (and our parenting decisions were always joint so he was on board). I never felt that DH chose MIL over us as a family, which has made it so much easier. Yes, she's his mum and very important to him but not at the expense of our family.

Of course we don't always see eye to eye or agree with everything they do, I doubt they do in return. But we're respectful (so are they) and honestly I know they would help us out in any way they could if we needed it. No questions, no judgement.

I would absolutely live next door to FIL though. He's wise, level headed and a delight. MIL would feed us all until bursting so best we live further away Grin

Ali1cedowntherabbithole · 04/12/2018 10:43

My MIL is lovely and very much part of our family. I’m very lucky.

narcissistic DM on the other hand...

FrowningFlamingo · 04/12/2018 10:44

Never needed to do any of those things. She drives me potty because she's terrible at asserting herself and should have much more self confidence as she's a great lady.
I almost wish she'd push my boundaries a bit more!!
We don't have children yet so of course it could all change with a grandchild on the way (imminent!) but I hope not and that we continue to get on.

StrawberryFilter · 04/12/2018 10:55

I was really looking forward to having a good relationship with my MIL - in the past had often got on really really well with parents of previous boyfriends, in fact more than once I felt sadder about losing the boyfriend's parents than losing the boyfriend Grin.

Sadly my MIL is pretty hostile and difficult, and often said really vicious things meant to hurt. It's only just starting to get better now after 15 years of marriage, I just avoid her as much as I can and never ever let my guard down.

LavenderBush · 04/12/2018 11:00

FrowningFlamingo - yes, my MIL needs to be more assertive as well!

I'm pretty sure I must have put her out on a number of occasions (we are quite different people and also from different cultures, so the potential for inadvertantly irritating each other is quite high). She is a very forgiving person and puts up with a lot from others, so I'm assuming she puts up with me on these occasions as well. But imo it might be better if she generally put up with a bit less!

cleanhousewastedlife · 04/12/2018 11:01

Mine is not the sort of person I'd naturally be friends with - our interests and experiences are so different- but we have always treated each other with warm respect. Also, over the years I've seen her really try to understand me (my hectic working life, no kids, she was SAHM), her appreciation of what a good marriage I have with her son etc - I think I've been very lucky.

EdwardBear1920 · 04/12/2018 11:10

We did have to work at it for a while. There were things that really pissed me off, not least after my DS was born (and the run up to it). It was born from excitement mostly, and not understanding the boundaries. She had never had to share anything, DH's dad being out of the picture since before he was born, so she called every, single shot. It came across that she was baffled that she was being forced to give up some power now.

What's helped has mostly been time. She adores the children, and has also has come to terms with the fact that they're my kids, they're my (and DH's) rules. She thinks they've turned out well, so she's sort of accepted that I'm doing OK.

She's as tactless as they come. She also will react instantly to a situation before going away, talking or thinking it out and deciding what she actually thought. Point in case, my being diagnosed with bipolar disorder. Instant reaction; well you can't know how other people feel, so how can you possibly know that you're different? You can't compare yourself to being in a wind-tunnel because you've never been in one! (Ditto depression or any other mental illness). She said she thought I took far too much medication.

But...

Within a few weeks, she'd read up, started asking me questions, asking what help is needed with the kids etc., and even has recently said that she's impressed at how well I manage my medication and the situation as a whole, and the way in which I discuss it with the children.

So it's not so much that I have to forgive her. It's more that I have to wait until she gets her thoughts in order, but yes, sometimes those things can sting.

NB: I'm no walk in the park either and can really dig my heels in and return barbs that come at me.

Lizzie48 · 04/12/2018 11:12

On paper, we have absolutely nothing in common whatsoever but we respect each other and both love DP. I think even when you don't get on or like each other, being able to respect the other persons position is a good starting point.

That sums up how I feel. My MIL and I don't get on all that well, and we disagree on most political issues. (She's very pro Brexit for example.) She would have liked a closer relationship with me and wanted ms to call her 'Mum' at the start, but I wasn't able to reciprocate and I know that's hurt her over the years.

But I'm happy for her to have a close relationship with my adopted DDs (9 and 6) and this is what's happened. When she's staying with us (2 or 3 times a year for 3-4 days) she's happy to entertain them for some of the time, which gives me a break, as DD1 has a lot of issues.

We did need to establish some boundaries, as she expected my DH to be constantly available to talk to her on the telephone when we first got married, but she's adapted now for the most part.