Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Auntie being pushy with her parenting methods. Am I disrespectful / bu?

39 replies

Mummblebee · 15/11/2018 07:49

I have an auntie who has been incredibly supportive towards me and my 7mo dd. Very generous with time money and council. During this time however she has also given a lot of unsolicited advice and been quite pushy with it. Eg telling me not to pick up dd when she is crying and not to hold her as she will get too used to it. So if I'm not feeding or changing her she will go on and on about putting her down and leave her to cry. My style is more toward "attachment parenting" I have realised. If dd is crying I will see to her in a reasonable time as soon as possible. Literally everytime I see this auntie she is constantly pushing her way on me and I find it so irritating that I try to limit my time spent at her house and don't go around to see her as much as she would like because Im not very good at being assertive, so my way of managing that situation is basically to just try and limit contact. To be honest I find she undermines me quite insessently and I find it both tiring and irritating.
Said Auntie asked me to come to her house for the afternoon to help her out with something. I went over as she has done a lot for me and I want to try and be more helpful and generous which is something I'm working on. Whilst at her house whilst she was yet again repeating how I should leave dd to cry if she is changed and fed so I can get on with things, the conversation led on and I mentioned my dd had bit me whilst feeding and auntie said "did you smack her?" I said no and she said "youre silly. You should just tap her so she knows.. Not hard. You want her to be a good baby etc etc". I kind of brushed it off but didn't sternly address it in anyway. I don't plan on smacking my dd, even lightly and would not tolerate anyone else doing this. I just thought to myself.. OK well I won't be leaving dd with you then as its clear she has a very different parenting style than me.
A few hours passed and dd had a good day.. Towards the end she started to get fussy and started crying and auntie sat in front of her and just said "I'm not picking you up. No I'm not picking you up" and dd just sat there crying. I went over and picked her up and as I was walking away with dd in my arms auntie patted her twice on the bum! I kind of erupted in anger and said "don't do that!" and she was startled and said "what.. That? (did it again lightly) and I said" "no I don't like it". I was very angry. She just said oh "you don't like it. I'm sorry". She then used her fist and banged the couch twice next to where me and dd were sitting.. As if to tell dd she is naughty for crying. I didn't say anything.. Very annoyed and not wanting to say something I would regret in a disrespectful way to an auntie who has been really supportive but unfortunately just does does things in a different way to me that I really don't like. I put dds coat on and we left.

BTW this aunties two daughters are my dds godmothers. I saw them the next evening and they basically told me there mum was very upset as she was playing with my dd and I snapped at her. They basically told me not to speak to their mum like that again and I over reacted and was disrespectful. I have said I will apologise to the mum today. I'm very upset about the whole thing. I'm starting to notice a pattern.. I do have a bit of a complex of thinking people are undermining me when it comes to dd whether rightly or wrongly so I am aware of this.

AIBU? How would you handle this?

Thank you

OP posts:
Mummblebee · 15/11/2018 13:42

Italiangreyhound

OP your family, your choice. I am afraid I would be seeing very little of someone who behaved like your aunt. Her loss.

This is what I plan to do.

RibbonAurora

Thank you I will do if and when I see her at some point.

Quite upset because I agree with most of the comments on here and would have loved to but its just not worth the hassle. I'm already disrespectful to everyone who matters in mine and dds life. I honestly feel like I was born into the wrong culture. Feel completely isolated in my mindset. Thank you mumsnet for the clarity. Xx

OP posts:
Italiangreyhound · 15/11/2018 14:17

Mummblebee "I honestly feel like I was born into the wrong culture."

I think lots of cultures had these odd ideas about babies. It's just our British culture has moved on and the older generation is less respected (not necessarily a good thing!)

You are right to manage this how you want to. Good luck. It's now been shown that letting babies cry is not good for them so you are 100% right to pick baby up. Just comfort yourself that you are a great mum.

jerkkneed · 15/11/2018 14:21

I was about to say maybe she didn't have children herself, but then I saw she does!

Please don't apologise. State your case again in case Auntie has given an inaccurate version and then leave it at that.

sophiec123 · 15/11/2018 14:40

Just because these people are your family members does not mean for any instance that you owe them anything.. you are that babies mother, you are the parent. Start as you means to go on, if you continue to let this happen it will go on like this forever!

Personally I would tell them all to do one including the god parents, their mother obviously can do no wrong and raised them the same thinking that she is somewhat omnipotent! DO NOT BE UNDERMINED BY ANYBODY.

As for smacking children, I have a 9 month old and would never dream of smacking her! Despite what everyone recommends nowadays. That baby is innocent and doesn't even understand! I also would not allow anybody to even tap my child, even if that was my parenting ways, it's not anybody else's "job" (if you get my point)

Unsure why this has infuriated me so much, I just don't want you to be bogged down by these horrid people, I'm one of the young ones of my family and know what it's like but I can't stand up for myself and my family. Honestly this will ruin your self esteem and confidence which you don't want to pass on to your daughter. Lead a happy life with your own family, who you choose to have in it

Xx

sophiec123 · 15/11/2018 14:41

Can

layercake9 · 15/11/2018 14:54

YANBU and please don’t apologise to her. She sounds mean and overbearing. Anyone ignoring a crying baby is mean. You’re not alone in your mindset. I always pick up or check my infant dc whenever they cry as that’s how they can communicate to me that something’s not right.

Mummblebee · 15/11/2018 14:55

Thank you sophiec123

Wish I knew more people in real life with this mindset!

Where can I meet people like this. I will tell them to do one not literally but just by distancing myself. Looks like it's just me and little one as I'm a single mum! X

OP posts:
redexpat · 15/11/2018 15:06

I know it takes a different angle but I found reading Nice girls dont get the corner office really helped me be assertive. It's more focussed on work but honestly I have found it works wonders in my private life too.

Mummblebee · 15/11/2018 21:36

redexpat

Thank you so much! I'll order a copy for Christmas [santa]xx

OP posts:
user1471426142 · 15/11/2018 21:54

If am by no means an attachment parent but suggesting smacking a 7 month old is so far removed from the norm now, it is quite shocking to hear someone saying this as parenting advice. Distancing yourself really is the right thing if you do not feel able to challenge effectively. You can never leave your baby alone with her.

ReflectionsofParadise · 15/11/2018 22:00

Op are we talking parental sibling Auntie or wider family/friend 'Auntie' like in the indian community where every older female is 'Auntie'?

Thehop · 15/11/2018 22:06

Steve bidulph makes good reading too. Raising boys and the alternative raising girls are excellent

Can you get to a children’s centre or any playgroups OP?

IHopeThisIsAGoodIdea · 15/11/2018 22:21

When a 7 month old cries it's because they NEED something. Your Aunt is being ridiculous.

Mummblebee · 16/11/2018 00:55

ReflectionsofParadise

It's wider family/friend auntie. I've known her my whole life and she is very close to my mum and slightly older so basically treated like the "matriarch" of the family..

Thehop
Thank you for the suggestions.. Will add to my reading list! In answer to your question yes we go to a children's centre once a week but I will increase this to 3 or 4 I think as its good for both me and dd to meet new people!

Thank you Everyone who has read and replied I feel so much better and suddenly have strength and clarity on my new role/life with my daughter.

Flowers
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page