Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to give gifts to CF MIL and SIL

39 replies

SailorBean · 15/10/2018 12:55

This is my first ever post (though I’ve stalked AIBU for a while now) but finally cracked as I need a rant and some advice. I’ll try my best not to drip feed so this might be a long CF ride...

I know it might be a bit early for some to discuss Christmas and start planning presents but my partner and I have recently become parents for the first time this past September so we’re wanting to get ahead of things. All fine and good.

Then on Friday things took a turn for the CF. MIL and SIL decided they wouldn’t buy DD a present postbirth and instead opted to buy me an experience, something lovely where I could be pampered (at their instance that I needed it). All fine and good as I wasn’t expecting anything postbirth for either DD or myself. It wasn’t until we arrived at the place that I realised all was not well, it was one of those photo shoot deals where they throw in hair and makeup and you’re expected to spend X after the fact. Not great when you’re on maternity leave and DP’s last wage was rinsed by paternity leave...MIL then insisted that we go ahead and have our family photos taken and she would spend £150 on whatever we wanted. Once we were at the viewing stage MIL dropped the bombshell that the £150 was the sum of our family Christmas money meaning we wouldn’t be receiving anything this year. She had paid a £10 deposit for the voucher and that was my treat, the photos we hadn’t really wanted were for Christmas...and we’d have to pay the other £100 to comply with the terms of the deal.

I could move past that if it wasn’t for the fact that this would be the 2nd Christmas in a row where we would go without Christmas presents from MIL as the previous year she had insisted she would use the money to buy trips for a family holiday which DP and I had to drop out of last minute due to pregnancy complications. She hasn’t mentioned the money since.

SIL is a similar type of CF, though she and her DH work full time with no children she constantly contacts my DP to ‘lend’ her money as she’s over spent (on holidays and her 3rd new car in 2 years) which is causing tension between herself and DP...spurred on by the fact last Christmas we, like civilised adults, decided on a £70 limit for presents which we promptly bought SIL and BIL a fancy coffee maker she’d asked for. She in return sent us something which never arrived and had no tracking information and, quite honestly, didn’t exist.

So here is my predicament: AIBU to just stop buying for them? DP’s dad is lovely and would still buy his whiskey as normal but the rest of them would get a lovely Christmas card and sweet FA.

(I am expecting to get flamed for being petty and juvenile about presents and money but in all honesty this is just the cherry on a shit sundae with DP’s family)

OP posts:
SailorBean · 15/10/2018 13:59

Thanks everyone for your responses, so glad I’m not just a raging hormonal cow after all!

Think I will go with the pettiness suggested and send them a nice photo frame with a picture of baby in it as (unfortunately) we were tied into spending the money to complete the deal. On a plus we got some lovely shots of DD so there’s that!

OP posts:
ButAIBUtho · 15/10/2018 14:04

You shouldn't be tied in to pay anything.

No one can force a person to go somewhere and cough up £100 unexpectedly.
Just say no.

SailorBean · 15/10/2018 14:04

TheOneWith

The present is supposed to be from them both however MIL has total control over their joint finances to the point where I would call it financial abuse.

She has multiple bank accounts and credit cards, she cut up FIL cards and convicted him to close his personal account in favour of a joint account but he cannot hold the card for it as MIL must have all cards in her possession at all times Hmm so, as far as DP and I are concerned, he isn’t the problem here and is simply too under her thumb to say anything.

OP posts:
PennyMordauntsLadyBrain · 15/10/2018 14:09

Good for you OP!

In fairness, I had newborn photos taken of DD and gave them to my parents’ and sister (who treat DD as the Second Coming) as part of their Christmas present- they were chuffed with them, so it honestly isn’t a bad present either.

DingDongDenny · 15/10/2018 14:11

I'd also get in touch with SIL and ask her if she can 'loan' you some money as you are short this month after the unexpected photo expenses.

I'm use she'll say no - but after that you won't need to feel guilty at ending the handouts from now on

SailorBean · 15/10/2018 14:13

aaargh

DP is honestly just very upset, his relationship with MIL hasn’t been what I would call...warm...for as long as I’ve known him (12 years) and money has been a large factor in every conversation I’ve ever been involved with/observed between DP and his DM in the 4 years we have been together.

At this point he would prefer to go NC with MIL but doesn’t want to punish DFIL for her CF behaviour (DFIL is also 75 and DP is concerned he would pass away thinking DP was angry at him rather than MIL). Plus now DD is here it gets trickier as DP wants her to have a large extended family as he didn’t have one as a child.

I think we are a united front on the whole gift thing but we try not to discuss it as he says it makes him feel shit (digging into his DM’s behaviour)

OP posts:
AcrossthePond55 · 15/10/2018 14:25

Poor FiL! I think my gift to him this Xmas would be my spare room!

Piffle11 · 15/10/2018 14:34

Let them know that from now on, you won't be buying for adults in the family (I'm sure FIL won't mind buying his own whiskey! Or keep a bottle at home and tell him he may as well take it home as you won't drink it - sneaky gift-giving!) And make sure DH doesn't give SIL any more money.

EK36 · 16/10/2018 10:50

If they invite you out again for a nice suprise/gift. Either don't go or if you do, leave you purse at home. Just bring a twenty pound note. If they ask for money again just say sorry money's a bit right at the moment!

eddielizzard · 17/10/2018 19:36

Can't you see FIL on his own?

BlueJava · 17/10/2018 20:05

But your DH handles the presents his side... it's not your fault they didn't get anything :)

NoThatsNotMyName · 17/10/2018 20:18

I think the most surprising thing from your original post is that your mother in law didn't want to get anything for your little girl when she was born. It's not all about material things but a little gesture of welcome- a little outfit or a small toy is cheap and just shows they care. I might have read it wrong but it sounds like the £10 she was going to spend on your daughter was used to book you in for this makeover, which as makeovers go sounds like a great price because they make the money back on the prints.

My mum fell over herself with gifts for my baby boy. She doesn't have a lot of money but she's knitted him two blankets, booties, socks and about ten cardigans. My sister keeps raiding sale rails for little gestures and she knits stuff too.
BIL hasn't got anything yet not even a card but that's ok, I just won't be getting him anything.

Singlenotsingle · 17/10/2018 20:27

Christmas (and birthday) presents are overrated in my book (bah! humbug!). It's children only in our house! I can't see any point spending my hard earned money on some rubbish for people that I can't afford and they don't want! Give her the photos, and the whisky for dfil.

Greyponcho · 17/10/2018 20:30

Give SFA to MIL & SIL. for DFIL, get him a bottle of whisky. Wrap it up and put your DHs name on it. Say that someone at work bought this for DH, but he doesn’t like it, so perhaps DFIL would enjoy it instead.
It’s not a gift to him then, and MIL can’t get snotty about it Wink

New posts on this thread. Refresh page