AIBU to pretend that I didn't eat half a tub of Phish Food?

[PaintingOwls]

I came home early from work today and DP and me to get ice cream for dessert.

I settled on phish food. Got home and it was slightly melted and I thought I'd have just one little spoonful before putting it back in the freezer. I scooped up a runny bit, then another bit, then I wanted to catch a fish for some crunch, so had to dig a bit to get to that.

Next thing I know, I've eaten half of the tub and given myself brain freeze

WIBU to go back to the shop and buy a second tub and pretend that all this didn't happen?

Ohhh now I want Ben and Jerry's (half baked) , well done for stopping at half OP.
I love this thread.

It's ice cream? I wondered why you were eating fish food.

Frankly shocked you only finished half the tub.

Have you always had commitment issues?

@abbsisspartacus
They do dairy free ice creams too now. Join us....

I buy a tub each. Five of us. Gets expensive.

I’m daydreaming about chunky monkey b&j now!

If I get the job I'm going for this will be my treat. You describe it so perfectly in your op, the gooey chocolate bits and the crunchy little fish

I don't talk to B&G anymore since they stopped selling the polar bear one. I loved finding a bear.

I always wondered what was in phish food. Then it got me wondering if you could get chocolate starfish. Don't Google image that. 😂😂😂

ThroughThickAndThin01

I buy a tub each. Five of us. Gets expensive.

Wow. You may as well buy wholesale, surely.

So after replying to this thread I have namechanged but also been craving Ben and Jerry's all week! Being in early pregnancy my taste buds/ sickness are all over the place and so its taken a week for me to finally feel upto eating a tub! Imagine the horror when the 4 month pregnant lady starts her Ben and Jerry's tub to discover the brownie is actually missing out of her blondie brownie ice cream! What kind of sick joke is this!!!