Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - middle aged brother asking 82yr old father to host his child's birthday tea.

46 replies

llamalana · 25/09/2018 05:32

First time poster. My father is 82, in fairly good health (despite a brain aneurysm last year), lives in cosy-sized pensioner housing and looks after himself although does get tired. Every holidays he enjoys hosting a small morning tea for his five grandchildren (3 are my children). He does a bit of fruit and buys some crisps and an apple pie. We are in and out in an hour (in respect of his age and tolerance for smallish children being noisy and childlike). My brother has two children and for some reason asked our Dad to host his one year old's first birthday this year. My Dad asked me to do the cake. I thought it was a bit odd at the time but made the cake and we attended the morning tea party. This weekend just been, we hosted one of my children's birthday parties at our own home. Whilst extended family all there my father asked myself and sis-in-law to come up with a convenient date for next school holiday morning tea. Fair enough and would've done this over the next days. However as my father was leaving this has now changed and I was being asked would myself and three children be free to attend my brother's 4 year old son's birthday party on X date at my 82 year old father's home, just let him know if date worked. Apparently my brother asked him during the day if he could do this for them. Birthday tea going ahead hinged on my agreeing this. My brother has his own house and a wife and is perfectly capable of hosting a party. I have said I feel uncomfortable about agreeing to this. My father has asked me to speak to my brother and has now said he won't host any morning teas for us this holidays which is awkward but I wasn't declining to attend a morning tea, I just think my brother and his wife should be putting on their own children's birthday parties. AIBU? I now have the deep joy of communicating all of this to my brother! Sigh.

OP posts:
bimbobaggins · 25/09/2018 07:45

What bananamanfan said. It sounds as though your dad was happy with the arrangement until you said you weren’t happy. It’s not as though they are inviting a class fully round, just relatives. You could just suggest your brother steps up a bit more and prove some of the food

BarbaraofSevillle · 25/09/2018 07:46

Sounds cheeky, especially the 'fuck off and leave all the mess behind' bit. Do you ever visit this brother and family at their home? Are they trying to keep the mess of a children's birthday tea out of their house, or are there issues that would make it unsuitable (hoarding etc, although as they have their own DCs, I wouldn't have thought it made a difference for family visiting).

Cardiganandcuppa · 25/09/2018 07:46

I think it’s ok for it to be at your Dad’s house if he’s happy with that, but your brother needs to bring all the food and do all the set up and clearing away.

LillianGish · 25/09/2018 07:49

I agree MereDintofPandiculation. If he is happy to host this may be a great way of making him feel involved with his grandchildren rather than just a spare part.

BigChocFrenzy · 25/09/2018 07:51

At least, the DB & DSIL should PAY for their own child's party and clear up all the mess afterwards

Dollymixture22 · 25/09/2018 07:59

Have you asked why they are getting your dad to host? I find it really odd. Especially for the four year old who surely is at he age where a birthday party involves friends balloons and Haynes? Is there pressure in your family to have a family only celebration in addition to the other festivities? Has there been a fall out which means some people aren’t welcome in your brothers home. Are you sure your dad isn’t offering to do this then pretending it was brothers idea. Sorry but it all just seems so odd.

Dollymixture22 · 25/09/2018 08:00

Mayhem not Haynes!!!

roundaboutthetown · 25/09/2018 08:23

I think you need to be more communicative with your own family. How can strangers on the internet possibly know how reasonable or unreasonable your brother is when you haven't even spoken to him, yet? I do agree with the poster who suggested your df might actually quite like feeling useful, though, rather than being treated like a frail old man who can barely cope with a tea without it turning into a birthday tea. Maybe that's why he originally agreed to it? You can't work any of the motivations out without talking with an open mind to those concerned, though.

llamalana · 25/09/2018 08:33

No communal area. It is lots of little apartments all stuck together.

OP posts:
Piffle11 · 25/09/2018 08:43

Even if it's a case of celebrating at DF's so he doesn't have to travel, your DB and his DW are being incredibly selfish in not providing all food, etc. And they really must tidy/wash up afterwards. Think they are either being thoughtless or total CFs.

7yo7yo · 25/09/2018 08:58

I wouldn’t go and I would tell my brother why too! Cheeky fuckers will make a habit of it and it’s unfair on your parents. I know on MN people say they are adults and capable of saying no if they wish but I think if they are frail and old they need an advocate sometimes! (Sorry, paragraphs not working in phone).

mowglik · 25/09/2018 09:08

OP don’t go along with it just to keep the peace. It’s up to you and your other sibling to look out for your parents as your brother and his wife look to be selfish arses. My parents are the same age, my dad also has a pacemaker etc and none of us would ever dream of asking them to do something like this. Please have a word with your brother

Stringofpearls · 25/09/2018 09:13

I can't help feeling that if your dad wants to do it then its up to him. Perhaps it is something he really enjoys doing?

Sleepykate · 25/09/2018 14:12

I dont see the problem if your father doesn't mind. If you dont want to do the cake just sat no. It sounds like your father is perfectly capable of making his own decisions

footballmum · 25/09/2018 14:22

Hang on, so your DB and SIL won’t even be supplying, making or paying for their own child’s birthday cake?! CFers of the highest order!!

llamalana · 25/09/2018 21:08

Update: I have spoken to my brother. It hadn't occurred to him to offer to help or provide anything. He's reminded me that our DF also did the birthday last year so this is the second year. They have a bigger party booked in a hall for the four year old's friends. (This was news for me and I feel slightly sad for my own three children to not be invited but that's their choice so will just make sure my children don't know about it. His four year old and my three and half year old son are really good buddies so am especially sad about that as we always invite them to our children's parties.) Thank you for all your thoughts. MereDintofPandiculation discreet protectiveness really resonates for me. I am going to speak to my DF again and just make sure he knows we love coming for morning teas and just try and soothe the waters a bit.

OP posts:
Dollymixture22 · 25/09/2018 21:18

Did your brother explain why he asked your dad to host?

llamalana · 25/09/2018 21:36

Because DF was already inviting my children and brother's children and wife as per our usual get together, brother thought he would just tag it on as it saves him having to host a separate family get together on another day. He has admitted he hadn't given any thought to offering to help, arrange cake etc. I think I have felt uncomfortable as felt a bit blindsided by the change as I wasn't around for that conversation. So last I thought, I was working with sis-in-law to find mutual date for low key tea and next nephew's birthday family get together all hanging depending on my saying yes.

OP posts:
Aeroflotgirl · 25/09/2018 21:47

Your brother sounds like the ultimate cf to expect his I'll father to host his child's birthday party, offering no help and leaving his elderly father to clear up the mess.his father not wanting to rock the boat. I would be telling my brother what I thought of the situation.

MidniteScribbler · 26/09/2018 00:31

I'm a bit confused by all this. So he already has a kid party booked, but the regular morning tea has now turned into a bit of a bigger event by inviting some extra people to celebrate?

You haven't said how your DF really feels about this? When I'm older, I can't imagine not being happy about being allowed to host an event for my family if I was physically and financially able to do so. It seems like you are getting your knickers in a twist (jealousy?) and are the only one upset about it.

llamalana · 26/09/2018 00:41

MidniteScribbler regular morning tea isn't ever related to birthdays. My other brother and other family also not happy about it because we're concerned DFs goodwill being taken advantage of as it seems to be becoming a thing that my brother asks him to do to save him doing a separate family one. (Don't even know why there has to be two celebrations!)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page