Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that there is a time and place for constructive criticism?

30 replies

Marmelised · 22/09/2018 11:51

Once or twice a year I have to be away with work for a week. It’s very intensive, early mornings, late nights, demanding work and on duty the whole time. It can be rewarding but it leaves me with very little in the way of emotional or physical energy when I get home. After a night’s sleep I’m usually fine but I need that sleep.

Every time, within about 30 minutes of getting home, my husband brings up some character flaw or aspect of how I do things that could be improved. I have asked him to hold off on initiating these discussions for say 24 hours until I have caught up on sleep and have the mental energy to process his suggestions but he still does it every single time.

He can’t see what my problem is. He acknowledges that I’m upset but just says he doesn’t do it deliberately. He thinks I’m unreasonable for asking him to remember, just this once or twice a year, that I’d prefer not to have heavy discussions about how I could improve myself when I’m almost sleepwalking with exhaustion.

I do try to take criticism constructively at other times (not saying I succeed but I try). It’s just on these particular instances that a 24 hour delay would make all the difference.

He says ‘there’s never a good time’ for these conversations. My point is there are stupendously bad times and, once that has been pointed out, it might be a nice touch to be aware and try not to do it.

Is it so unreasonable to say, I know you don’t deliberately try to upset me but I think you could try harder to be on your guard about starting this specific type of conversation on the specific one or two times a year that we both know I am unable to cope with them?

OP posts:
Marmelised · 22/09/2018 16:27

RibbonAurora not quite that. I’m not saying anything negative about work In this instance. I’m usually still in the nice to see you how was your week mode. Not unloaded anything of negative import at that point, still telling the good things that happened. It’s more him saying you were tense before you went away and wanting to discuss it then and there. My point is absolutely not that he shouldn’t raise these matters, more that it’s probably better to wait until I’m not on my knees from exhaustion before he does it.

I never said he was an arsehole. Other people made that comment and I took pains to try to describe how my actions contributed to the situation.

OP posts:
Lougle · 22/09/2018 17:02

So you're basically saying that you want him to be a nodding donkey? He should have no ideas, opinions, thoughts or comments about what you're saying. Just a suitable range of encouraging phrases that indicate that he's listening while you tersely vent in your clipped, dismissive tone? Because you've already considered and dismissed anything he might think about your issues and you don't want his input anyway. Yup, I can completely see how that would go down if this was a man posting about his wife criticising his behaviour after being away for work!

Marmelised · 23/09/2018 00:27

Nope. Not that at all. Big difference between nodding donkey and empathetic listener,

Back after a week away, happy, taking about positive occurences in the week, glad to see each other,

Husband shifts emphaisis and refers to conversation over a week ago where I was describing a work situation, he interrupted with a solution. I had responded saying that had thought of his proposed soluton but decided it would not work because of (stated reasons), and carried on with my story. He perceived this as me being terse. That was not my intention, I was just mid story, responded to his interjection, and then continued with story.

This was then brought up over a week later when I returned from my trip away. Other times it hasn’t been that, maybe something about my family, perhaps something about interactions with our children. Just always a negative thing brought up for discussion within half an hour of me getting home.

As stated before, not saying this should never be discussed, just wishing that it could occasionally be delayed from when I have no emotional reserves to maybe the next day when I’ve had a chance to catch up on sleep.

OP posts:
Shoxfordian · 23/09/2018 00:42

Yeah he sounds like an arsehole

Birdsgottafly · 23/09/2018 09:31

He's deliberately taking the wind out of your sales.

You've probably enjoyed yourself a bit too much for his liking.

I'd look for other little signs and have it out with him.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread