Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Division of costs in 50/50 shared care situation - one party won’t contribute

5 replies

Isleepinahedgefund · 16/09/2018 08:32

A friend of mine has 50/50 shared care for her two kids. This is supposed to include the costs for them aswell. Both parents earn the same and have roughly equivalent circumstances otherwise (neither has a new partner so one income per household). The way their schedule works means that they aren’t allocated set days, so you couldn’t say that judo always happens on Dad’s day for instance. They claim child benefit for one child each. Neither is entitled to any benefits (salaries £40k plus).

My friend thinks she shouldn’t have to contribute to any of the usual running costs for the kids - clothes, shoes, uniforms, out of school activities, school trips, school dinners, mobile phones, travel etc. She thinks her ex should pay for everything. Her reasons aren’t that clear aside from feeling that it’s very unreasonable because she is their mother, and the only reason he wants 50/50 was so he wouldn’t have to pay any maintenance to her. TBH if she did have majority care, I think she would expect him to pay for everything else aswell as maintenance anyway. She just doesnt pay for anything, so he has to or the kids go without. She keeps going on about how he is forcing her to pay for uniforms.

She doesn’t understand that what I see is someone who refuses to pay for their children, the same as if a NRP goes out of their way not to pay maintenance. She thinks she is entitled to not pay for anything.

Of cours she is BU. But her ex has taken out an expensive smartphone contract for one kid (11) and expects her to pay towards it, when she would have got him a bogstandard PAYG. Ex prefers the kids to have school lunches whereas she would rather spend less and give them a packed lunch.

If this was a man refusing to pay for his kids’ upkeep in the same situation we’d all be up in arms.... so what’s the smart way to agree shared costs? Surely also it is unreasonable for one party to take on a cost without consultation and expect the other to pay for it?

PS no this isn’t a reverse, and no I am neither the friend or the ex!

OP posts:
Needahairbrush · 16/09/2018 08:38

I can understand why she doesn’t want to pay for an expensive phone contract, but the other stuff sounds like essentials. Uniforms, shoes, lunches etc. I can’t understand why she doesn’t think she has to pay for these just by being the children’s mother? How does she explain not providing essentials for her children.

LemonSqueezy0 · 16/09/2018 09:34

This is always going to be the issue with 50/50. You are back into a situation where you need to have a good relationship between exes to make it work, as you need to agree costs, expenses and communicate more about things in general.

Does she not give a reason when stating she shouldn't have to pay? She is being unreasonable about that, clearly.

She needs to sort her priorities, figure this out as her ex might also refuse to pay, or he'll get expensive items she doesn't want and the circle of hate continues, the children lose out and relationships will irretrievably breakdown. Plus it's bloody exhausting!

Shednik · 16/09/2018 10:07

She's in the wrong.
We have shared care, slightly more with me than him but no maintenance paid.
We split costs.

It only works because we cooperate. "I paid for ballet, can you pay for music" etc.

The phone, if dad got it, he pays. I got my son an iphone contract. I pay it.

Isleepinahedgefund · 16/09/2018 10:37

Her reasons for not paying are mostly centred around the oppression of women, there is no tangible, reasonable reason. She also says that she had no maintenance from her other child’s father and had to pay for everything, (now grown up and left home, not a dependent) so she doesn’t see why she should pay for things for her younger kids.

I think you’re right communication is the key here, they don’t get on and don’t communicate well if at all.

OP posts:
TeachesOfPeaches · 16/09/2018 10:41

Why are you posting if you're not any of the people involved?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread