Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I cant find a solution anymore - can i go against "convention"?

11 replies

BrightLightsAndSound · 09/09/2018 12:14

Hi Mumsnet, first time poster but long time reader.

I need your help because I'm just so confused and at my wits end with everything.

I moved to be with my boyfriend 3 years ago. I love him to bits and we have a great relationship. There are literally no problems between us, we talk loads, it's just a great balanced dynamic and I love being with him.

The problem is I grew up in cities and I moved to the "sticks" to be with him. He's really attached to his family and friends here where he grew up, sees them every day etc, whereas I have a much looser albeit close relationship with my family. Sorry I'm not explaining things in the right order!

Basically the problem is that its been 3 years that Ive tried to integrate into life here. Ive been made to feel a part of the family and accepted by his friends, ive made my own friends and gotten involved with stuff etc, but I just cannot shake the feeling - I miss city life desparetly. It feels like a part of me has been slowly dying. I miss the stimulation, seeing and experiencing new things, meeting loads of different kinds of people. One of my partners uncles gets it, he's from a city too, and I was speaking to him last night. He said to me "its like you have a hunger and curiosity for and about other people - but you wont get that here".

The truth is I feel unhappy living like this, I feel like im not in the right environment for me. My partner cant relate but understands. He will not move. He's in the right place for him.

We've tried loads to solve the problem. I tried going into the city several times a week for day trips but it just felt like i was one foot in, one foot out. We "compromised" and moved to his local small town - but its a small town, and the result is he's having to compromise because ita not the countryside, and me because its not the city.

I feel like ive reached a watershed moment now where either i have to lose something of myself/kill it off and just accept livinflg here. Or I have to take action and allow us to both have what we really want.

We do not want to break up. We want to have kids together.

The city is a 45 minute train ride away.

My plan was for me to move to the city, him to move back to the country, and for us to spend every weekend together alternating places, and the odd week evening here or there.

Half my friends think this is a great idea and will also positively feed back into the relationship.
The other half think ot means the relationship is doomed.

He would be open to it. We're both very independent and thats one of the things we appreciate about one another. And deep down I know it would work.
But his community is very conservative and they would judge us/me and think theres something wrong. I worry he would think it means im slowly trying to make an exit.

What do you think? And how would this work if we wanted to have kids in 2 or 3 years? Sorry for rambling but I just feel so unhappy and cant think straight. I love him and dont want to lose him. But I also dont think its right for me to sacrifice so much of who I am. Its starting to create tension.

OP posts:
StealthPolarBear · 09/09/2018 12:17

If the alternative is to split up then what have you got to lose in giving it a go? Don't have children until you're sure about stability though.

TurnipCake · 09/09/2018 12:18

I think there is such as a thing as the right people for the relationship, but the wrong time/place.

The situation you're suggesting might work for the short-term, but throwing children into the mix won't be fair on either you or them.

Flyingpompom · 09/09/2018 12:18

Don't have kids with him. Which one of you would lose out on living with them full time?
I understand you love him but love is not always enough.
I think you are incompatible and should go your separate ways, honestly.

Santaclarita · 09/09/2018 12:19

This won't work especially with kids. Either put up with it or split up. I don't think you should put up with it though. I'm sorry.

WhatsGoingOnEh · 09/09/2018 12:21

Have you posted about this before? It rings a bell.

If it'll suit you both, do it!

I miss London. Be glad you're only 45 mind way from your city; I'm 2 hours from mine.

kenandbarbie · 09/09/2018 12:27

It could be different when you have kids as your life changes so much and revolves around all their activities, so it doesn't make much difference where you live. However as others said it's not a good idea to have kids until you're stable.

alwayssaynever · 09/09/2018 12:27

The situation now isn't working, so you can't continue like that.

Why not trail the long distant relationship. It will be hard when you have kids. The resident parent will be a single parent in the week, but then there are families which make these arrangements work. Remember though, being as you talk about this as a permanent relationship, that you are looking at this being a permanent change, year in, year out, decade after decade until you die. You aren't planning it as a temporary move until job circumstances change or one of your retires. So go into it with your eyes open. There are financial implications too, especially when the cost of kids comes along (on the plus side if you ever split up it will be so much easier to do : )

What other people in the community think about your arrangement is irrelevant. You can't let that dictate your decision.

HollowTalk · 09/09/2018 12:31

I've read this thread before, too!

Live where you will be happiest, OP, but unless you're willing to live like a single parent, I wouldn't have children with someone who wanted to live elsewhere.

Jaxhog · 09/09/2018 12:50

Live where you will be happiest, OP, but unless you're willing to live like a single parent, I wouldn't have children with someone who wanted to live elsewhere.
That's it really.

BathroomLights · 09/09/2018 13:31

Yes it's familiar, you went away and he wouldn't even feed your cat for you?

PickAChew · 09/09/2018 13:33

So you're expected to make all the compromises and he won't shift at all?

If you have kids with him, you'll be doing all the parenting.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread