Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this could help.

4 replies

Getitrightthistime · 27/07/2018 01:26

Hi everyone. Just want to make this clear from the start this is not a mil bashing thread I adore my mil and have a great relationship with her.

Bit of background. Back when I got pregnant with my dd I hadn't been with dh very long so was a bit of a shock me and mil were still getting to know one another but we had a good relationship and I could tell a wonderful friendship was blossoming and it did I was and still am very close to her. My own mum passed away very suddenly a few years ago and for me mil has really helped to fill an empty hole and she's aware of my feelings there and told me that's all she could ever wish for and she's glad I've found some comfort in having her. I won't lie when dd was born I did suffer some pnd very bad experience whilst giving birth, problematic pregnancy, too many visitors too quickly and we were living at mils moved in officially the day after dd was born I had been living with my dad before hand who I'm also very close to. Mil was naturally very excited and its not like we had some sort of rule book or instruction manual and a couple boundries were crossed mil totally admits this and has always apologised as at the time I didn't feel I could assert myself properly and I sunk deeper into my depression and then started becoming stand offish and barely allowing mil near me and my dd it truly was awful I think I felt a mixture of things and i also think I felt inadequate at the time as a mum anyway dh and i ended up moving out of mils and things did improve but still it wasn't perfect I had something against mil even though I still really did love her and enjoy her company I only liked seeing her on my own without dd that's disappeared over time and I'm so glad and relieved pnd does some strange things and really mil never did anything to deserve this kind of behaviour from me. I was out or order to be so disrespectful after she welcomed me into her home.

I am now pregnant with dc 2 and what I really want this time around is for my mil to be there with me during labour supporting me and dh I really think she will help me take my mind of the pain and I just think I will feel more relaxed around her after. I'm just so scared of history repeating itself i really dont want to put mil through that again and I think if she is there with me I will see her as more of a support with the baby rather then someone who is trying to take over which i know would never be her intention. I would never deliberately treat anyone badly or distance myself but my pnd at one stage got so bad that I wouldn't have any of dh family near me. Some of them have been rather unkind to me though so dh and mil always did understand.

Mil said she would be delighted to come and support me but she has said that she wants to step out for the actual birth and let me and Dh have that private moment at that point she said she will go on home and come back when she is asked for to meet the baby. Did any of you have your mil for support during labour did you find it strenghend your bond and also will having someone who makes you laugh and could turn your labour into a positive experience help reduce the chance of experiencing pnd again?

Many thanks for all who has read to the end sorry it was long I didn't want to drip feed and I wanted to make sure I didn't paint my mil out to be some sort of baby crazed monster because she really isn't.

OP posts:
SeaToSki · 27/07/2018 01:41

Didnt want to read and run. I have no personal experience to help you with, but I think its very unlikely that history will repeat itself as life has so many variations. Trust your gut amd let MIL trust her gut. Together you will find the best middle ground

Getitrightthistime · 27/07/2018 01:46

I think the reason I feel so worried is because before I had dd I would of never of guessed I would suffer with any sort of pnd despite the problems I suffered in the pregnancy I was still my easy going happy self all these horrible negative feelings I had just got directed to mil as I say although it wasn't deserved boundries were crossed so while it's not an excuse it may explain things slightly. I'm also thinking if mil witnesses my labour she will have more respect for me as the mother. She was on holiday last time so we didn't see her until it was all over this wasn't on purpose I just went into labour early.

OP posts:
SeaToSki · 27/07/2018 01:56

I can see how you would worry that the pnd would roll over you in the same way again, but isnt forewarned forearmed? Also if MIL has had a baby herself (which I am assuming she has) then she doesnt need to see you push a baby out to have respect for you, she know how much work it is and how much it hurts from personal experiemce, she will already know that you are a strong woman. What does your DH want to happen when you start pushing?

Getitrightthistime · 27/07/2018 10:14

Dh said he is happy with whatever i decide and we are all quite happy with mil to leave the pushing part and come back an hour or so after the baby is born with my dad. This is all assuming I have a long labour like last time. No mil admitted before she didn't see me and dh like the parents especially when we were staying at her house. Wasn't nice to hear but very honest of her and I respect that to be honest i didn't feel like the parent then a lot was being taken over not just by mil but also by some of dh family. Mil is the only one to admit stepping over the mark hence why our relationship has healed. To be fair there are all sorts of reasons why I want her there the main one really is she will keep me talking and she's got a good sense of humour it also allows dh to step out and get himself food and drinks without feeling guilty as he knows il be fine with mil.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page