Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think this is slander?

44 replies

Snappedit · 09/07/2018 11:01

my dps aunt came round to our house a couple of weeks ago to see ds (3).
There is a bit of a backstory (tension about a disagreement between the aunt and I) but I don’t want to say too much as it could be outing. I thought that we had resolved it enough to be amicable and polite to each other’s faces, but clearly not.

On Saturday night, a friend of my dm, who also knows my dp aunt saw her at a wedding reception. Dps aunt made some awful remarks to this woman about me and my parenting. She said that she was concerned for my ds welfare as I allowed him to run all over the house in different rooms, while I sat on my arse and drank tea! She said she was worried he could have an accident. There was no mention by the way that my dp should have been watching ds, if this is what she thought, so some double standards there.

Anyway dm friend has told dm and I what was said. She said that she remained very neutral and said to dp aunt she always observed my ds to be well cared for.
Now for the record, ds is 3, he does toddle about in his own home, and I can’t tail gate him, but obviously everything is toddler proofed and I always have an awareness of where he is, what he’s doing, and will check on him every five minutes or so if I can’t see/hear what he is up to.

I am furious about her comments. They are not true and I feel like this is a form of slander by criticising my parents to others. Dp is upset but he wants to leave it and just see her less. I want to call her out on it, tell her if she has concerns go down the proper channels )I.e call social services) who would come out and see nothing is wrong. I would also like to tell her if I hear anything else about her making up malicious rumours I will contact the police.

Aibu here? Would the police do anything about this? I just think it’s very unfair she can go around saying things like this, which are dishonest and a defamation of my character, with no consequence.

OP posts:
diddl · 09/07/2018 11:58

" but talking about a parent neglecting their child, I feel is on a different level."

But that is all she is doing-talking.

To someone who doesn't believe her.

Don't waste headspace on her.

Why does your husband want to still see her at all?

Tjzmummabear · 09/07/2018 12:02

My Ex's Mother rang Social Services on me 80 times after we split up. She reported me so often they asked her to please stop. They came round twice in total. My son is severely autistic and has learning difficulties.

The SW came to see me after the 80th report and told me that she was ringing weekly and they'd had had enough. My home is clean, I work, his attendance was full. I just think she wanted to hurt me and have custody of my son. The SW said she'd said I did drugs/ slept with my Step-Dad (that's really gross & low - my Mum married him when I was little)/ told the council I lived with my Step-Dad. (He has a large detached home with several acres so that wasn't going to fly). I was a bit unsure as where they as to where he'd fit in a cramped 1 bed that u couldn't swing a cat in. The room barely fit a small bed and a compact cot in.

I digress the point is talk is cheap. Sod em!

ScreenQueen · 09/07/2018 12:03

Also, there's the Bette Midler effect

You mean Barbara Streisand effect, I think.

LeighaJ · 09/07/2018 12:04

Don't dare someone to go to Social Services, they have better things to do.

Just tell the Aunt she's a proper cunt for slagging you off to others and I doubt you'll have to worry about seeing her ever again.

KatharinaRosalie · 09/07/2018 12:16

Anybody who is not as batshit will just roll their eyes, when she complains that a 3 year old is allowed to walk around in their own home. She's just making herself look ridiculous. Seriously, there are people who follow 2 steps behind their 3-yo 24/7?

henpeckedinchief · 09/07/2018 12:16

@ScreenQueen you're right, I do! Thank you Grin

bakedlikeabun · 09/07/2018 12:26

Did she use the word neglect? When people don't have a child of the same age - even if they did once - it's hard to remember how much freedom they have at what age. And even among people with three year olds there will be a wild variety of approaches to supervision, from helicopter parenting to that benign neglect stuff.

Perhaps she has an experience of a small child dying from an avoidable accident, that kind of thing is haunting. I'm not sure it's possible to toddler proof an entire house either. She shouldn't have gossiped about you and the person should then not have passed it on!
Massive overreaction from you though.

ApolloandDaphne · 09/07/2018 12:27

3 year olds aren't even toddlers are they? They are fully functioning children who can make their way around their own home easily. Who would be watching them every minute of the day? No-one that's who. Just ignore her and let her bash on with referring you to SS if she wants to.

Snappedit · 09/07/2018 12:46

Baked she said she was worried about my lack of supervision and about him having an accident.
Now if a parent was not providing adequate supervision for the environment and the child was at risk of harm due to lack of supervision I was say that is neglectful.
For the record she doesn’t have any children of her own and I don’t think this is anything to do with my care of ds, it’s becahse she doesn’t like me.
I just want this nipped in the bud now so there is no repeat. Dp just wants to see less of her and not really raise the issue with her. I feel like I don’t want to see her at all anymore, or for ds to see her, and I feel like I need to explain why.

I dare say social services get a lot of malicious allegations, but I don’t think she would be stupid enough to do this, as she knows nothing would come of it. There is no conviction behind her words, it comes from malice.

OP posts:
Snappedit · 09/07/2018 12:47

Thanks everyone for supportive responses.

OP posts:
bakedlikeabun · 09/07/2018 12:48

Appollo you're overreacting almost as much as the OP!
How long would you be happy for a childminder to leave your three year old alone? They are not independent beings.
There is clearly a back story of dislike between the OP and the aunt, which might shed more light on the motives of either character. In itself though it's a storm in a teacup. I don't think the mother gets to decide that the father's aunt can never see his child again either.
In fact, let her babysit and she might change her tune!

Snappedit · 09/07/2018 13:02

Baked if you/when you had children, once they were mobile enough to walk around your home unaided did you always have them in your eye site?

All cleaning products are high up, safety still on stairs, and anything glass/breakable is out of reach. So whilst the house wouldn’t be safe for long periods of time, I have an awareness always of which room ds is in, listen out for him, and check on him frequently. Is this not what most parents of small children do? If I’m in the kitchen cooking for example, he may be in the dining room playing/watching a dvd.
How else would anyone get any tasks done? I also think it would be restrictive to a child’s development to completely deprive them of any solitary play.
Dont you think if dps aunt had genuine concerns about the neglect of my ds, she should be directing this at dp also. Why was it just me who should have been supervising him? It’s been a total attempt to make me out to be an unfit parent, defamatory to my character. She has set out to cast me in a bad light with the poorly thought through comments she has made.

When dps aunt makes malicious comments about my care of ds, I think I do get to dictate whether or not she sees him.

OP posts:
flumpybear · 09/07/2018 13:03

She's being a sticky beak!

I have to say I had an eagle eye on my two crazy toddlers but that's just because they were bonkers - some children have easier toddler years so don't have to worry so much about permanent damage ... if you've bomb proofed your home and he's safe don't worry

I'd perhaps reciprocate with 'oh you mean alcopops aunty' ... let the gossip be about her for a change Wink

rainbowstardrops · 09/07/2018 13:20

You've already had issues with her previously , so I can't see her changing.
I'd cut all contact (DH can choose to see her if he wants) and then she won't be able to see your parenting or your DS's behaviour.

Ginorchoc · 09/07/2018 13:29

She sounds a nasty bitter person but ffs don’t call the Police. Ignore her.

ApolloandDaphne · 09/07/2018 14:06

I am amused at anyone thinking I am overreacting. Most 3 year olds should be able to amuse themselves for periods without constant supervision and should be able to move freely around their home without being hovered over.

HollowTalk · 09/07/2018 14:11

It's quite simple, though. You just never let her into the house again. You'd have to be nuts to let her anywhere near you and your child in future.

FfionFlorist · 09/07/2018 15:06

We all parent differently, if you are confident in your parenting decisions then ignore all other unsolicited opinions. Don't feed the drama.

MissVanjie · 09/07/2018 20:08

‘Nip it in the bud’ by having no further contact with her, in life or on social media

If she can’t see your parenting she can’t gossip about it

It’s really that simple. Unless you live for drama and showdowns and ‘don’t ever set foot in this house again’ eastenders type carrying on, obviously.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page