Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL’s expectations of DS

36 replies

cadburyegg · 04/06/2018 19:49

For some background, both DH and I have good jobs but aren’t very academic. However it’s always been a sticking point for mil that DH “didn’t get grades in the subjects that matter” - her words not mine.

She’s now started projecting this onto DS. She’s always said how “bright” he is but as he gets older the expectations are increasing. I now take him to a “science” group for preschoolers where they do little experiments with paint, water, colours etc. It’s just a bit of fun! But it came up in conversation once and mil took it really seriously and said “that’s great it might mean he’ll be good at science at school and go on to get a good job”

Then this past weekend her and FIL visited and she openly said to DS in a serious tone “you’ll grow up to be a solicitor or a doctor” he is 3 ffs.

AIBU to think this attitude is potentially harmful and want to say something? I thought she was just being a doting grandparent by saying he was bright etc but I want to bring up my children to have a good work ethic and try their best etc rather than pushing them in a certain direction.

OP posts:
AcrossthePond55 · 05/06/2018 00:30

She wasn't telling him what she expected, she was complimenting him.

"Ooh, you'll grow up to be a doctor or lawyer" is a very common "Aren't you bright!!" statement. A friend of mine used to tell one of my sons "You'll grow up and go to MIT". She wasn't telling him she expected him to.

"As bright as you are, you better grow up and be a doctor or lawyer" is telling someone what you expect of them.

You need to relax and ramp it down a bit.

Fuckwithnosensesauce · 05/06/2018 01:11

Your child should expect to be anything at all, and you should encourage him in this. She is just aspirational for him and that’s great! Count your blessings that she wants the moon for him.

MooseBeTimeForSpring · 05/06/2018 01:23

Being a lawyer is not all it’s cracked up to be. My salary was never more than £40k.

DH doesn’t have a degree, is severely dyslexic and earned over £200k last year.

sobeyondthehills · 05/06/2018 01:48

I wouldn't worry, my DM wants DS (and has made subtle hints about) being a doctor. Last time she mentioned it, DS told her he was going to be a policeman during the day and Batman at night.

he also mentioned to be batman he can't have parents

PomPomtheGreat · 05/06/2018 04:44

It might be more fun if he wanted to be Batman by day and a Policeman by night ...

PerfectlySymmetricalButtocks · 05/06/2018 04:49

At 3 Gen? DS2 still wants to be Spiderman at 6! 😂

AskAuntLydia · 05/06/2018 05:30

"You'll grow up to be a solicitor or a doctor" is not having high aspirations, it's having a very limited palette of what a good, high status, high reward career is.

And it is projection.

"You'll grow up to have a really good job" is high aspiration. "You'll grow up to do something important in medicine or law or engineering or science or art or something clever like that" is nice and wide and encouraging and high aspiration.

I don't think the OP is OTT to think it's not on to be telling a 3 year old what job they'll be doing. I wouldn't say it's harmful, but it isn't helpful either.

If the MIL could restrain herself from restricting her GS's horizons and keep them open, then her aspirations would be more welcome.

hildabaker · 05/06/2018 05:58

I think that it's important to open horizons for children, and to facilitate their learning. What's worse is telling children that they must achieve but then not supporting their academic progress. So long as your child is supported to aim high, then I see no problem. Far better than sneered at and told 'you'll never amount to anything' as some tell their children.

fabulous01 · 05/06/2018 09:01

It depends on what she is like on other things
But I would be saying something like... yes grand am wants you to go to university and has offered to pay. That might shut her up

sobeyondthehills · 05/06/2018 11:57

It might be more fun if he wanted to be Batman by day and a Policeman by night ...

Batman only comes out at night. He has it all planned including where the Batcave is going to be.

He is 6 and has been planning this for a few years now

waterrat · 05/06/2018 11:57

OP you are massively overthinking this.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread