waxon you seem unable to comprehend that children are different. Some children may respond to a conversation as you propose, but others won't.
Nope, don't be so condescending. I have two very different DC, one has always been very compliant, the other not so much. But, at the end of the day I am the adult and they are the child and I wouldn't be taking any shite from a 5 year old. Strangely, mine are now nearly 18 and 17, we have a great relationship and they never give me a days bother. We just never got into the long drawn out negotiation thing. We either said yes or no, yes a lot more than no, but when it was a no it was a no. They learned that a lot earlier than 5. I don't think I'm superior and there are definitely things I would do differently but I just can't stand namby pamby parenting.
There are different ways of doing things, your way is not necessarily superior, and goes against medical advice.
I'm not saying my way is superior. Wasn't the medical advice last time I looked but if you have links and things are different I'm happy to be proved wrong.
People have to find a way that suits them, but there is no way I'd be stripping ad washing a bed every night and maybe more than once, or leaving a child in a wet bed just because they decided they didn't want to wear a pull up.