Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to tell my mum to STOP interfering!

52 replies

annebancroftbag · 10/05/2018 11:19

She seems to think she’s helping, by offering solutions to problems that don’t exist, or aren’t her business. She’s always been like this but it’s worse lately, as the older she gets, the more she seems to think she’s entitled to say what she thinks. (This is not an ageist dig, my aunts and dad aren’t like this and they’re the same age)

What she doesn’t seem to get is how she ADDS to the mental load rather than alleviating it. This very morning she’s pushed my buttons with the simplest thing, I commented that DS had forgotten his lunch bag and I’d drop it off and she launched into a “well why don’t you put it where he can’t forget it, like hanging in the front door handle?” So I start to say that he had left it in the car, not the house so then “well why don’t you check he’s got everything before he gets out?/Why doesn’t he have school dinners? Why doesn’t he walk round to auntie Sandra’s at lunch, she would love to have him for lunch, shall I ring and talk to her?” Etc etc. It’s so so exhausting.

I’ve tried to talk to her about it but she doesn’t get how a lot of the time her questions and suggestions are really actually an insult to the intelligence, and she seems to start each phrase with “why don’t you” or “what you should do is...”

An elderly relative died recently, and she was talking to a cousin, and helpfully chimed in “why don’t you move in with Widowed Relative? There’s plenty of space!” Even though it’d mean the cousin completely uprooting her and her children’s lives, and is also none of her business!

She means well but how can I get through to her?

OP posts:
annebancroftbag · 10/05/2018 11:32

Meh! Suck it up Anne, then?

OP posts:
LapinR0se · 10/05/2018 11:34

Love how you’re talking to yourself Grin
Tell her tell her tell her. I’ve had to do it with mine. “Thanks but that’s not terribly helpful right now” on repeat with the odd “I am not looking for advice I’m just venting” thrown in.

annebancroftbag · 10/05/2018 11:38

Thankyou! Me chunnering to myself is probably part of the problem! She hears me and then comes up with “solutions”.

Yes I’m going to have to be firmer. I find myself answering her questions rather than doing what politicians do, and ignoring the question and carrying on regardless!

OP posts:
echt · 10/05/2018 11:38

So what do you want her to say? Nothing? Tinkly laugh?

TestingTestingWonTooFree · 10/05/2018 11:39

I think you need a line you can say to politely cut her off. Maybe “I know you’re trying to help Mum but I really don’t want any advice on this”.

redexpat · 10/05/2018 11:43

Why don't you ... because I don't want to.

What you should do is ... I didn't ask for your opinion. So please don't give it unless I ask. Defending my choices to you is actually pretty wearing and if it keeps happening I will have to draw back.

FatBottomedGal · 10/05/2018 11:43

I also have a very interfering DM. I moved in with her briefly when my DF died and she drove me up the wall with her constant suggestions and “solutions” to things, as well as trying to make me packed lunches everyday, cleaning my sheets, panicking if I came home unannounced etc etc. I ended up having a very frank conversation with her about how I was a perfectly capable adult and she was making me feel like a child, she backed off a lot after the initial upset.

I’ve now moved 200 miles away so am not affected as much, however my DB and his gf have now moved in temporarily and the same is happening to him - only issue is he doesn’t have the balls to say anything!

My advice would be as above, keep repeating that it’s ok, you don’t need a solution you’re just moaning. OR try as hard as you can not to let on that something is annoying you/ something has gone wrong so she doesn’t have to find a fix for it!

HMC2000 · 10/05/2018 11:43

I've got a friend like this and it's exhausting. The only thing that works for me (when I remember/can manage to do it) is silence. So every time she makes a suggestion just meet it with silence. Or wait half a minute and then start talking about something unrelated. Otherwise it gets into that back and forwards thing of suggestion and rebuttal. It hasn't stopped my friend doing it completely, but she doesn't do it as much. It's like she can hear how much she does it, I think. But anyway, I with you - it's bloody infuriating.

Neverender · 10/05/2018 11:49

I'd vent to someone else, personally.

shitmother123 · 10/05/2018 11:51

My in laws are like this. It does drive you mad because you feel you can't say anything slightly annoying just to vent without some ridiculous "solution" that's actually more hard work.

Nanny0gg · 10/05/2018 11:54

What you should do is ... I didn't ask for your opinion. So please don't give it unless I ask.

And my response might be...I didn't ask to listen to your moaning/venting so if I'm not allowed to speak, complain to someone else.

Loonoon · 10/05/2018 11:55

My mum is like that too. She is also deaf and refuses to wear her hearing aids 'because she likes not being able to hear people, people are exhausting' . She then complains about being left out when she doesn't know about things that have been discussed in her presence. I just don't tell her anything anymore.

Storm4star · 10/05/2018 11:56

As a mum to adult kids, though they don’t have their own yet. I think I am used to dishing out advice to them as that’s what they usually want so it might just be a hard habit to break. However, I fully understand the just wanting to vent thing so if they ever said to me “mum I just want to vent” I would totally understand and shut up! Lol. So I think I would just be honest with her.

KurriKurri · 10/05/2018 11:58

I had a friend who did this (advice ranged from the ludicrous to the illegal !

SacrificialAnode · 10/05/2018 12:00

You're being ridiculous. Seriously, what would you expect her to say to your comment about the lunch bag? Nothing? Or just "oh"? She's only making conversation, this is not interfering. Maybe you're spending too much time together, that's all. She's probably sick of you too, as you're so touchy if she dares to offer an opinion.

annebancroftbag · 10/05/2018 12:11

Thanks all, for understanding how knackering it is. It sort of takes up mental space whilst I’m trying to think of a respectful reply.

SacrificalAnode wtf? I muttered “Jake’s left his lunchbox” and within moments she’s suggesting phoning Auntie Sandra so he can go round there at lunch!
(Possible drip feed: Auntie Sandra works most days, he wouldn’t be allowed out of school to walk there as he’s only 7, It’s over a mile, and neither he nor Sandra would want this! But all of this is lost in my mother’s need to stick her beak in!)

OP posts:
annebancroftbag · 10/05/2018 12:12

And the point, which perhaps I haven’t made clear is that this isn’t an isolated event, it’s all the bloody time! Over everything both minor and major!

OP posts:
LittlePaintBox · 10/05/2018 12:13

My sister is like this. It seems to be part of an anxiety disorder. She worries about things that aren't her problem - like how someone at work is going to cope with various domestic problems - and overthinks everything dreadfully, so nothing ever just happens because it happened, she's always trying to tease out some meaning from it.

I've had to learn not to feed her information that she's going to start problem solving on, and not to bother explaining why I don't want to apply her solutions to my problems. She's usually just not the right person to sound off to.

Mind you, my son often tells me off for trying to suggest solutions for him if he rings me to sound off, so maybe it's a family trait.

annebancroftbag · 10/05/2018 12:16

Littlepaintbox you might be on to something with anxiety actually. Especially overthinking the mundane. I was going to the next town to pick up something and she launched into the “where will you park” fret, “will you take your car or DH’s? Yours is smaller so it’s easuer to park but will you fit it all in the back? I could ring your dad and get him to borrow the truck from work and he could go with you and and and”

Angry I’m nearly 50.

OP posts:
mimibunz · 10/05/2018 12:19

Just try to tune her out. She'll never change.

MrsArthurShappey · 10/05/2018 12:21

I work with someone like this. It is exhausting!

LittlePaintBox · 10/05/2018 12:22

The anxiety was only diagnosed and treated a couple of years ago - the behaviour has gone on much longer. She has a bit of self-understanding now, and I do point out to her when she's overthinking. I think it's difficult to deal with partly because the anxiety communicates itself to me and it puts me on edge. I completely understand the strain of trying to deal with inappropriate suggestions to solve my problems, though!

sockunicorn · 10/05/2018 12:25

@annebancroftbag I fully get this, my DM is like this. Sorry to say it gets worse the older they get. Mine has now graduated onto randomly giving advice BEFORE things happen. She will remind me to "make sure she takes her bag to school" Confused. My child is 10. Thats approximately 900 days she has gone to school and NOT forgotten her bag. But thank god my mum reminded me today or she may have done Hmm

Also, she likes to pre-empt my stories and give advice. For example the other day I said "I took DD to the dentist as her wobbly tooth was hurting...." and she instantly dove in with "THATS BECAUSE SHE HAS TOO MANY SWEETS! I TOLD YOU! I KNEW IT!". I gave her a Hmm look before informing her, no, shes 10 and has never so much as had a filling. The dentist said her teeth were perfect and it was just because its wedged between 2 other teeth.

Sorry im of zero help, I just wanted to let you know it gets worse and my mums batshit crazy too Grin

Babymamamama · 10/05/2018 12:26

It sounds like she's quite annoying but also you come across as if you've got very low tolerance for her. If you don't like her don't involve her so much in you life.

sockunicorn · 10/05/2018 12:27

She also gives directions!! "Im going to sainsburys". She will then direct you there! Despite me going pretty much daily for the last 20 years and having a sat nav in my car anyway! My standard answer to most things now is "i dont care" and i turn away or busy myself.