Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this teacher being unreasonable or am I?

36 replies

poopsqueak · 24/01/2018 15:51

DD is 5, school talent show on. DD wants to audition, so we have practised a song together and I wrote her lyrics down so she can read them.

Teacher told the class auditions would happen in a few weeks last week.

DD very upset yesterday as teacher said 'who is applying for the talent show?' and about 15 children put their hands up. Teacher called out a few names (dd included) and said 'come to the front and do your audition'. So none of the kids were prepared.

Teacher then said she would be holding auditions over the rest of the week so 4 kids a day could audition a day (ish).

DD was asked to perform and she forgot her words and panicked. She asked if she could go tomorrow when she had her words. The teacher said 'no, this is your one and only chance' so DD improvised a dance (lord knows what that would have looked like).

My AIBU is that if all the children were told that the auditions were in a 'few weeks' then held a week later, of course they aren't going to be prepared. 2 girls did 'half a dance routine because thats all they practised' (dd has told me) and one boy apparently was going to do jokes but got up at the front and only remembered one.

I know this isn't massively important or outrageous, but my child cried on my knee for 20 minutes and I am sad about that, especially when she had practised a lot.

We did it verse by verse, so she had only remembered the first verse and panicked.

Even if the teacher gave one days notice - i.e 'the auditions are tomorrow' so the kids could have been prepared.

Anyway, my DD took her words in anyway so I suspect she will ask the teacher if she can try out again. I don't think she will be allowed to though.

I just dont think it sounds particularly fair on the children who are only 5 and 6.

OP posts:
Twogoround · 25/01/2018 09:14

To perform on stage you have get on with it .
Your daughter forgot her lines but did a dance so she perform so she did good.
The girl who partner was off what if that happen on the day would she refuse to go on ...
Yoy daughter did good praise her and take her to stage school classes.

NK493efc93X1277dd3d6d4 · 25/01/2018 09:15

Chances are that it was he show that is in a few weeks - not the auditions?

DancesWithOtters · 25/01/2018 09:21

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

AlmostAJillSandwich · 25/01/2018 09:21

If your child gets a second chance, all of the children who auditioned today should get a second chance too.

MycatsaPirate · 25/01/2018 09:33

Bloody hell, they are only 5! Still so little and learning about life. This is a harsh lesson for them to learn.

Grossly unfair. And really not a great way to run a talent show either.

clarrylove · 25/01/2018 09:35

I can only think you or your DD have misunderstood. Were you specifically asked to prepare in advance at home? I think this is just a run through/practice for anyone who wants to join in. She is 5!!

Maursh · 25/01/2018 09:38

As someone who has been involved with the running of talent shows, I can say with some confidence that the purpose of the audition is not to audition. It is to make sure that Johnny doesn't blow "when the saints go marching in" six times on his recorder, Geni's magic can actually be seen by the audience and Peter and Susan's beat bop dance doesn't last too long.
It is also helps organisers determine the order so there are not four vocalist back-to-back.

Mishappening · 25/01/2018 09:39

A talent show? - at primary school? What are they thinking of? It can only cause upset, so what is the point? The talented children (everyone will already know who they are) get a chance to preen, and the also-rans (who probably have lots of other virtues and skills) get to feel bad all over again - and the point is.....?

saladdays66 · 25/01/2018 10:05

Our primary used to do this. Each class auditioned and the best few were chosen from each class. They all then performed at the evening talent show.

If more kids from each class had been allowed to perform, it would have gone on all night!! There were gymnasts, musicians, comedians, magicians, singers, kids doing football skills....

But your teacher was VU. The dc are only 5 and 6. If they are to gain confidence in performing then they need time to prepare their routines, so she should have done auditions when the dc were expecting to. I'd have a word.

poopsqueak · 25/01/2018 10:38

DD decided not to push it the day following although she had discussed taking her words in an asking to go again. But she decided at the last minute not too.

She also kept her tears in until the playground so I'm not sure the teacher knew how upset she was.

The girl who cried in class' Mum is going to have a word with the teacher today as she (and I) don't think it is acceptable for the teacher to say 'oh stop being so dramatic' Her DD.

I'm in the camp of rather letting my daughter fight her own battles with support and only really intervening in extreme circumstances. That's why I suggested she take her words in and ask the teacher herself instead of complaining myself.

OP posts:
poopsqueak · 25/01/2018 10:39

PS she showed me the 'dance' she did. Just wow. Confused

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page