Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To just not know how to handle this awkward situation anymore?

55 replies

Makehaywhilstthesunshines · 24/12/2017 19:22

In a nutshell SIL doesn’t like me, never has and I am really struggling to be around her anymore.

Been with DP 5.5 years, from the very first moment I ever met SIL I could tell she wasn’t at all fussed about me. She has NEVER once in 5.5 years struck up conversation with me just us two, or asked me anything about myself. It has always been me constantly asking her Q’s about her and her life, trying to make conversation etc.

It goes beyond that now though to the point where if I speak she looks pissed off and rolls her eyes/ huffs. If there’s a conversation going on in the room and I join in, she instantly stops talking and talks over me to whoever we’re talking to and changes the subject.

She’ll sit next to me in awkward silence for hours without attempting to make any conversation, or, she resorts to plan A which is just walk out of the room completely rather than be alone with me for even 10 minutes.

In all honesty, we don’t have that much in common anymore (I think we used to share a few things before she had kids) so it’s fine, except my issue is she is OBSESSED with my DP, she is constantly texting/ ringing him, wanting to see him. When we do see her, she won’t leave him alone and practically combusts with love/ excitement and yet won’t even say hello to me, hell, she’ll barely look at me.

She’s like this when she comes to ours, I’ll barely get a hello and she certainly won’t speak to me yet is all over my DP/ my dogs/ house etc.

All this wouldn’t be an issue if I didn’t have to spend that much time with her, but we live a 3.5 hour drive from them and so when we see her, it’s either her coming here for days on end or us going up there and I literally have to spend 48-72 hours in the same room/ house as someone who will barely even look at me.

I know it’s easy for me to say this on this thread but I honestly am the sort of person who gets along/ can find common ground with almost everyone. I have lots of friends, am sociable etc. I guess what I’m trying to say is, it’s not a common theme for people to dislike me, or take an instant dislike to me like she did.

I accept that that’s life and not everyone in life is going to like you etc, you’re also not going to have loads in common with everyone you meet, but in 5.5 years she honestly hasn’t ever tried to initiate any conversation with me. She knows absolutely zilch about me and yet is very close to my DP which just makes it awkward. I’m not a massive fan of one of my SIL’s, but she’d never know it, I’m always really friendly, chatty and polite to her because at the end of the day, although I find her a bit irritating sometimes, shes my DB’s wife and he loves her so therefore I make the effort for his sake.

SIL was just rude and hostile to me this afternoon and, after spending an awkward 7 hours in her company I’ve just had enough. I’ve finally plucked up the courage and told DP how I feel and he’s said he will subtly try and get to the bottom of it. I really don’t see what good that’s going to do as himself and his whole family adore SIL, pander to her every need/ want etc and I really don’t think would ever hear a bad word against her.

I just don’t know how to move forward from here, I hate confrontation, do anything to avoid it (which is why it’s been 5.5 years and I haven’t ever said anything) luckily as we don’t live near each other I probably only have to see SIL 4 times a year on average, but unfortunately those times when I do see her it’s for days at a time and is really intense. I was so tempted tonight to say to DP that I don’t want to see her anymore and so therefore wouldn’t be going to any more family meals etc but that would go down like a lead balloon with MIL/ FIL etc and cause WW3. If I took that stance there wouldn’t be any way of coming back from that as it would be so awkward.

How do others deal with in laws that they don’t get on with but have to see?

OP posts:
MaisyPops · 24/12/2017 19:26

She sounds insufferble.
I think you've done amazingly not to lose it. I'd have ended up resorting to passive aggressive sarcasm so much sooner. People like that are rude and frankly unpleasant.

statetrooperstacey · 24/12/2017 19:26

Hav u upset the apple cart a bit op by joining the family?
If u say she has been the centre of attention for a long time, are the first 'newcomer ' for a while? Sounds like plain old jealousy to me. Has anyone else noticed it?

Maelstrop · 24/12/2017 19:27

I’ve never been in this situation, so I can’t imagine how you’re coping! It’s all very odd. Is she resentful of you “taking” her db away from her? Resentful that he chose you over her? I think she will minimise if he asks her and tbh, she needs to be openly asked what the problem is. She’s making life unnecessarily awkward for you but also for her, bit dumb of her.

ZigZagIntoTheBlue · 24/12/2017 19:28

Is she his sister or his brothers wife? I think that will colour the responses!!
I'll go out on a limb and guess brothers wife, maybe they used to do a bit of flirting, maybe your dp is the more attractive of the two?? She's annoyed you've lasted and have 'her' man that she's probably using as an ego boost!
I'd recommend repeating yourself loudly as if you're thinking she's hard of hearing or just not inviting her anymore!

Fairybella · 24/12/2017 19:31

You have done better than me I would have lost if by now

MaisyPops · 24/12/2017 19:35

zigzag
I hadn't considered that. Without thinking I assumed it was husband's sister, but now you've said it it does sound like you could be onto something.

Makehaywhilstthesunshines · 24/12/2017 19:41

No, she is my DP’s sister.

She is the baby of the family, completely and utterly doted on. She has 2 kids herself and the whole family just completely dote on her and her children. They are everyone’s entire world, which, I’m not going to lie, she loves. If the attention/ conversation isn’t centred around her/ her children then she gets a stony look on her face and brings the conversation back to them. I have ‘pandered’ to this mostly by making most of MY attempts at conversation with her about her and her children.

To the poster saying they would have lost it by now, that’s exactly it. I’d have loved to have lost it by now because it’s at the point where I can’t stand her, or to be around her anymore, but you can’t really ‘lose it’ with a much loved member of your DP’s family without causing some SERIOUS issues can you Sad and I think she knows this and this has enabled her to behave this way throughout the years.

OP posts:
buttfacedmiscreant · 24/12/2017 19:49

I think I would say that I'm done spending time with her unless it is something like a family wedding.

Encourage DP to meet up with her halfway once a month or something for a long lunch and tell him that you are done having her visit. If he insists then plan a weekend away. If he wants you to visit parents for big occasions then you need to stay somewhere other than family so you can have a break.

I would also ask DP to think about how I'm being treated and ask him to pay attention and make sure you are treated with respect. If this is the family dynamic he grew up with it is unlikely he even notices much of it as that is his normal. It took my DH a good number of years to notice how I was treated by a couple of members of his family and it took a pretty unpleasant experience for him to really see it as anything other than "you have completely different views and values from them". He stuck up for me once he figured it out.

EMSMUM16 · 24/12/2017 19:52

Nightmare. You've done pretty well I think. And probably the right thing to talk to your DP.
I have this with my MIL. Ok to start with many years ago but after a couple of years she made it clear that she didn't like me. We don't see her at all now, not even Christmas cards. There was no big fall out just nasty letters from her which my DP didn't kniw how to respond. Then nothing.
Nowt stranger than folk.
I wonder how your SIL would tespond if you asked her outright if she had a problem with you? And that you notice she doesn't speak to you at all?

Aeroflotgirl · 24/12/2017 19:55

My goodness she sounds awful😫. I would totally distance myself from her, don't have her in your home and don't go to hers. I would have lost it ages ago and ask her what her problem is.

purplemunkey · 24/12/2017 19:57

Is it just your DP and her or are there other siblings? Sounds like she's been the little princess all her life and another female entering the family is a perceived threat in terms of attention share. I doubt it has anything to do with your personality.

Gemini69 · 24/12/2017 19:57

I couldn't be with a Man that allowed his Sister to treat you in such a way.. let's not kid ourselves.. it's obvious what's going on.. they're simply not addressing it.. brushing it away with comments like.. oh you know what she's like just leave it... to avoid confrontation.. this needs to be addressed .. the alternative is she does not come to Your home.. ever again... and he visits his Family at their homes... You Lady deserve tenfold better from your DP and this Family Xmas Grin

Lloyd45 · 24/12/2017 19:57

I have the same problem with my SIL, it's a hideous situation. I can't bare it anymore. I don't want to be in the same room with her. I don't have the answers but feel your pain

SnowBallsAreHere · 24/12/2017 19:58

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

ZzzMarchhare · 24/12/2017 19:58

She is rude, so you are totally allowed to be rude back. When she visits, go out. Have a weekend to yourself when he goes there. I've given up with my in laws- why should I make an effort when they don't. It does help that I work in the NHS so I quite often have to work when it is a 'family ' day.

ButchyRestingFace · 24/12/2017 20:00

Have you posted about this before?

I could swear I’ve read this before, practically to the letter.

If she’s as much of a cow as you say, hard to see how this has gone unnoticed by your husband and his family. Are they especially dopey unobservant?

HelpTheTigers · 24/12/2017 20:00

Hope that your DP does make some progress and that he will be honest with you. Tbh, my DP would prefer to cover up for his (adored) Sis and lie to me. I tolerate her, even though she has done some really nasty, sly and sneaky things to us (and to me in particular). DP s just shocked that she would do such things and that there "must be some sort of mistake", rather than believing the very blatant and quite shocking facts.
I have become quite adept at disguising my feelings and thankfully, contact is relatively rare apart from at Christmas. I certainly don't go out of my way to talk to her or spend any time in her company.

Fingers crossed that your DP does what he says he will do and manages to make some progress. Maybe one day, your SiL might grow up!

WhatchaMaCalllit · 24/12/2017 20:01

Have you tried love bombing her? Go OTT on hugs and welcomes and calling on her to join in the conversation and if the room goes quiet, specifically ask for her opinion on the topic being discussed or if the subject changes ask for her opinion on the new topic?
Maybe if you can have a quiet word with her (which you can deny at a later date if you feel like it) and say that you've noticed how she behaves when you're around and when you join in the conversation and ask if there is anything that you've done or said that she has taken offence at? Put her a bit on the spot as she'll either have to buck up and keep her behaviour in check or tell you if there is something bothering her. Either way, you'll find out.

stopfuckingshoutingatme · 24/12/2017 20:08

I’d stop being nice to her . I would not bother to waste one word on that bitch ever again TBH. But in a really polite passive aggressive way . I would also encourage them to do stuff without you . Fuck her !

You need to have words as life is too short to spend hours and days with someone like this . Surely some occasions you can miss ? Make some new traditions

Tough though and I cannot say my advice is right just what I would do !

SassySausageSupper · 24/12/2017 20:15

Your DP hasn’t noticed this before? She sounds awful. I’d seriously consider having a coffee 1:1 with her and asking her about being friends - I hate confrontation too, but I honestly can’t think of another way to improve the situation.

MrsExpo · 24/12/2017 20:25

She’s jealous of you. You’ve ousted her in the affections of her DB and she can’t / won’t forgive you. Don’t even try to make this better, it’s her problem.

JennyWoodentop · 24/12/2017 20:27

I wouldn't stop DP from seeing her if he wants to, but she wouldn't be welcome in my house if she couldn't be polite to me. I certainly wouldn't be travelling to see someone who walks out of the room when I come in, ignores me & does the huffy eye rolling, so DP would be visiting her on his own.

It's gone on for so long I'd be beyond caring why she disliked me so much or if I'd done anything to offend her. Manners cost nothing, it's perfectly possible to be civil to people we don't like if we only have to see them 3 or 4 times a year - she is making a choice not to be polite, so I would be making a choice to leave her to it and disengage.

If that raises awkward questions in the family as to why you no longer host her or attend various gatherings, so be it, you don't need to justify yourself. If someone pushes it as to why you are not attending, you only need to be honest and say you don't feel welcome and drop the subject.

Cheekyandfreaky · 24/12/2017 20:28

I and my order SIL (dps brothers wife) have had the exact experience you describe with dps sister- the peak being when she cried when I said I was pregnant.

DP has my back every time. I had to point it out at first because she did things like gossip to other family members which came back to me and not him. He has always backed me, but I’m a people pleaser so where he would have had it out with her and has many times, I’ve been the peace maker and we’ve come to a happy point these days. I mean it’s not perfect but our boundaries are clear.

Gemini69 · 24/12/2017 20:33

I'm willing to bet .... Everyone has noticed It..... but everyone panders to SIL and you OP say nothing... so you inadvertently allow the cycle to continue....

Tell your DP it stops today.. no more pandering... it's Stops NOW Xmas Grin

Aquamarine1029 · 24/12/2017 20:36

Honestly, you just need to LET IT GO. She is INSANELY jealous of you and that will never change and you will never change her. The ONLY way to deal with this situation is to ignore the fuck out of her. She doesn't want to talk to you? Perfect! That makes your life a whole lot easier. Just pretend like she doesn't even exist. If she can't manage to act like an adult and be civil, then stop wasting your time trying to interact with her. Stop making her issues YOUR problem.

Swipe left for the next trending thread