Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU about being annoyed re giving/receiving xmas presents

33 replies

beardymcbeardy · 01/12/2017 11:11

So bit of background, in our family there are several siblings so it was decided that we only do presents for the nephews and nieces. Oldest Dbro has double the amount of children of everyone else, but this has never been an issue, I've always spent the same on each of his children as I do for everyone else. Dbro sent a round robin saying that things were tight this year for his family and that he wouldnt be buying any presents for any one this year. No problem with this, have been poverty stricken in the past so can understand that sometimes you hit hard times. We have already bought gifts for their children and I still intend on giving these. However, dbro has just posted on his fb something him and his dwife have just bought that is quite expensive. Its not an essential item but something quite frivolous and now my dh is pissed off at the principle of them not buying for our single child (even if it was a £1 selection box, just something for dd to open from them) whilst we have spent £20 on each of their 5 children (Prices are for context, and its never been an issue before that we spent more so please dont think this) Im struggling to disagree with dh. On the other hand its not in the spirit of xmas, giving to receive. Help me, i'm conflicted.

OP posts:
Shiftymake · 01/12/2017 13:26

I would be giving the presents to the children as they have no real say in their parents choices and should not have to feel the consequences for their parents choices. As for you DB, just tell him the truth that you buy presents throughout the year so you will be giving them to his kids, but that you are disappointed that he lied about him having tight finances and that if they wish for all to stop giving gifts then just say so rather then coming with excuses. If he, DB, acts up point to expensive non essential thing and make it clear that you don't buy that on a tight budget. Then again I am not afraid to stand up to my brother :P

DancesWithOtters · 01/12/2017 13:28

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

remaincalm · 01/12/2017 13:30

It's not the children's fault that they have selfish parents. We have a very similar situation in my family too. I'd give the presents this year and agree that you will all just give selection boxes next year. It's such a shame as I'm sure you enjoy buying them nice gifts.

BackforGood · 01/12/2017 13:33

I wouldn't put anything on the FB post - don't like the whole 'washing dirty linen in public' approach, but I'd drop it into conversation when I next spoke to him. He's your brother! Never needed to 'be overtly polite' or tip toe around a sibling. I'd say "Oh, I was surprised to see you could afford {item} when you haven't got a fiver to spend on your nieces and nephews at Christmas".
I'd still give the presents to his dc though - not their fault after all.

LondonGirls · 01/12/2017 13:38

Similar situation here Dbro told everyone he wasn’t doing gifts this year then a week later phones Dm to ask when she was coming up to do the gift exchange,
When she explained she wouldn’t be able to visit until early jan & would love to see the grandkids open their presents for once
This wasn’t good enough & for some reason he wants the presents before Christmas & expects my Dm to travel by train with arthritic knees with gifts in suitcases stay for a cup of tea then travel home again
😬 he has always been a CF

5foot5 · 01/12/2017 13:39

I think BirthdayBeast has hit the nail on the head.

It really comes down to communication. Did he say "we are not giving gifts" but mean "we are not giving gifts and don't expect any" or do you think he is still expecting them for his DC.

If the latter then YANBU
If the former then YABU. It is your choice to buy the gifts for his DC. They may have decided to forego all external gifts and spend the money saved on whatever it is they are posting about on fb.

implantsandaDyson · 01/12/2017 13:44

But he told you not to buy anything - it's hardly his fault you're organised. Tbh if my sibling or their spouse decided to berate me for what I spent my money on after I'd made it very clear not to buy gifts I'd be telling them to catch themselves on.

beardymcbeardy · 01/12/2017 15:38

Thanks for the replies. Just to clear up, dbro hasnt said that they are not expecting us to buy presents. Only due to not having any money, they are not buying gifts. Another sibling replied to the round robin email (pre fb showing off pic) that she was still buying the nephews and nieces prezzies and at no point has dbro said that they do not wish this. I cant say what he has bought as it would be too outing but its a frivolous luxury item. I will still give the gifts i bought as i guess its not the kids faults their parents are tight asses. Will probably pare back next year though. Also dd will most likely not notice which i realise makes my gripe seem mean, but as dh says, its the principle.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread