Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU re DSis new relationship?

9 replies

XTina75 · 20/11/2017 16:06

My sister is 4 years older than me. When I was 20, I married my now DH and we have 3 children together and we have been together for 8 years. I have two brothers, one is younger than me and married and the other recently got engaged.

My sister was in a long term relationship with a lovely guy but unfortunately he had commitment issues and let her down big time in the end when it came to the crunch. To everyone’s shock & surprise, he recently married someone else.

Around the time he got married, my sister met a guy and within 3 months, they were talking about getting married. They even began looking at venues. By 6 months, they were engaged and living together. They also set a date for their wedding which is in 6 months time.

My sister has a history of problems, some mental health issues and in my honest opinion, a bad relationship with alcohol. I have been known to drink to excess on occasion so believe me, I’m not judging. If I think back to just over a year ago, she was having a break down and telling me she’d been drinking alcohol every day for the past 3 months. She then told me a few weeks later that she’s stopped drinking and was fine.

It’s almost as if one minute, she’s in a great place and 6 months down the line she’ll be in an awful place. A lot of that depends on whether she is in a relationship or not. I also feel like her personality changes depending on the guy that’s in her life and I feel like she’s lost her sense of self. I truly believe she doesn’t know who she is anymore.

She likes to be seen as someone who knows it all. If I tell her I’m going to learn how to do something (a new hobby for instance) she’ll start telling me exactly how to do it, as if she knows everything about everything. I just try to ignore it. It’s as if she has insecurities which make her feel the need to be superior to me.

Anyway, I’m very worried about her new relationship. I think her and her fiancé definitely have some stuff in common but since meeting him, she’s started smoking again and on a recent family trip, she was really drinking to excess and smoking (out of her bedroom window, with the bedroom door open whilst one of my DC slept in the interconnecting room.

She used to be so conscientious and such a meticulous person when we were younger. Someone who liked to take good care of her health and wouldn’t drink the day before a big event as she’d want to feel good the next day. She is not that person any more and I think she’s lost herself.

I’m not sure the happy persons she’s giving off with her fiancé is true or whether it’s all a smokescreen. Sometimes in the past she’s been on a sort of high like this but I’ve had a bad gut feeling about it and then lo and behold a couple of moths later she’ll have a breakdown.

I feel guilty because I’m struggling to feel as happy for her as I wish I was. She’s moving so fast with this guy, which in theory is okay but I just can’t help but worry about her.

Do you think this is all in my head?

OP posts:
XTina75 · 20/11/2017 16:06

I tried posting in relationships but very little response so posting here for traffic.

OP posts:
HakunaStigmata · 20/11/2017 16:15

could she be bipolar?

KC225 · 20/11/2017 16:42

If her ex left her then married someone else quickly, he didn't have commitments issues he just didn't want to commit to her. It is soul destroying, hanging on in dying relationship. She probably knew it wasn't right and that would have been a lot to deal with. Moving into your 30s without the relationship you spent your 20s would have been a big deal. So she went off the rails a bit, it happens. Chances are she met her current partner and and she knew what she wanted, him too.

The timescale doesn't seem that outrageous. Sometimes you just know. I think there is less game playing in your 30s. I was living with my DH within six months and we married at just under 20 months. We almost 14 years down the line and 2 kids later. She's around 32/33 is that right? (judging by your timescale) I would have thought she would know her own mind and has had some life experiences, including love and heartbreak.

As someone who married young and has 3 kids by your mid twenties, you seem quite critical of her choices. Can you really say she defines herself by men/relationships when you married at 20 and she is planning to get married at 33/34 to a gut she has been with for over a year and had been living with for six months.

Do you not like her husband to be? Do you think he is a bad influence on her? Do you not think her feelings are genuine?

XTina75 · 20/11/2017 17:00

KC a lot of what you’re saying is totally correct. My biggest concerns are that she seems to go from high to low and I haven’t seen her be herself in years. That’s why I’m weary of this relationship and the fact they’re heading towards marriage. I’m weary about the drinking also. I just want to see her happy, truly happy. I care a lot about her. She was once very strong but I think life events have changed that. I wish I could give her that strength back somehow. My fear is that if this wedding is a mistake, it could set her back a million miles further. I don’t want to see that happen to her.

OP posts:
ZombieVampireHedgehog · 20/11/2017 17:18

Why are you worried? In her eyes it could be that every other sibling is settled, you have your family, she doesn't, the clock is ticking, it's now or never.

She's doing things you don't agree with, but it's her life choices, she might find it difficult having her younger sister question her on that. If she had her own family yes, but it's her and her fiancé, she could be enjoying life before it's all nappies and bottles.

She was smoking out of a window, in her room, yes your DC was in the room next door, but her mindset was probably the child isn't in the room. Was she in her own house or your parents?

If you have concerns I'm not sure if they're better off coming from you or maybe your parents or a brother. It might appear condescending you saying in my opinion you've rushed into this relationship, plus the smoking and drinking...

I don't really see why you're worried. She has to live her own life, it might not be to your standards, but she's old enough to make these choices.

ZombieVampireHedgehog · 20/11/2017 17:26

If the marriage were to fail, she'd get divorced, but she'd still have her big day and all the excitement. Unless there's any red flags about the guy she's marrying, there's no reason to doubt it won't work.

You mentioned about hobbies, maybe she does know this & that. You don't realty like her interrupting though. Is this you trying to do similar to her?

She possibly thought the same about you getting married young and having DC. How would you have reacted to her saying DSis you should live your life, explore the world, plenty of time for DC & marriage later. You'd still have got married and had DC I'm sure.

XTina75 · 20/11/2017 18:56

The guy isn’t my concern, I’m only concerned that she isn’t acting like herself and I’ve seen her make choices that have really negatively impacted her life whilst shes been acting this way in the past. I just wish she realised how amazing the real her is. I feel like, once she has figured out how to be that person again, happiness will most definitely come her way. I just worry about her a lot because I care about her. I just don’t want to see her crumble and I believe that if this marriage fell apart, that scenario would almost certainly happen.

OP posts:
MagicMoneyTree · 20/11/2017 19:18

You can’t live her life for her though. It’s not your place to make her life decisions. You need to let her do her own thing, even if some of her experiences make her unhappy.

Most people want to see their loved ones happy, but you can’t do it for her. I’ve seen plenty of young people settle down and have kids and never really “know” themselves as single entities. Maybe that’s what she thinks of you? On the other hand, lots of people who experience breakups and a few different relationships as well as some single periods can find it easier/quicker to settle down as they know what they want from a partner. My point being, you live your life the way you want to and she’s entitled to live hers in the way she wants to.

Whatever her reasons for choosing this guy, she obviously feels like he’s right for her and the absolute best thing you can do is to support her/ be happy for her/ make an effort with him... and be there for her without judgement if it doesn’t work out.

KC225 · 21/11/2017 12:51

In your first post you said she is a bit of a 'know all' - not in a horrible way but we knew what you meant (every family has one and if your family doesn't it's you) is she approachable? Could you talk to her.about the drinking, the fact she has taken up smoking again or would it cause a huge drama. Perhaps it may be better coming from your parents. Is the husband to be concerned? Maybe broach it to him long the lines, 'Inotice sis has started smoking again, is she stressed about the wedding etc.' Maybe he'll bring up the drinking.

With regard to the high/low personality. As hard as it must be you just have to sit back and watch what unfolds. Only she can live her life and make successes or failures.
Your further posts show you to be a concerned sister. The only thing you can do is be there for her ....... And you are already doing that.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page