Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think its weird people use siblings as godparents

94 replies

Gimmeareason · 10/10/2017 15:02

I mean, they will already be the kid's uncle or aunt, so whats the point?

OP posts:
MarthaArthur · 10/10/2017 20:29

True star. The bible also says mothers are close to God as they too create life. I have read into all kinds of philosophy and its fascinating.

drspouse · 10/10/2017 20:58

Christening and baptism are two words for the same thing.

AveAtqueVale · 10/10/2017 21:04

I'm RC/ having a mental relapse according to Strauss, and chose godparents based on who I think are good people and will be a good influence on my children, whether or not they remain in the church as they grow up. DS1's godparents are my sister (Catholic but no longer practicing) and my best male friend (technically C of E but agnostic), DS2's will be my best female friend (C of E), my mother (to fulfil the requirement that one godparent is a baptised Catholic) and DH's friend (Church of Norway but not practising). It was important to me that the children were baptised, but as the godparents will have no role in their religious education it was more important to me to choose people who I think are good examples of kindness and moral behaviour, and who will care about them, than to choose on the basis of how RC they are.

Their legal guardians should we die are my sister and her wife, so a bit of overlap.

Riversleep · 10/10/2017 23:43

I'm a lapsed catholic and thought the church had given up on all the purgatory stuff?

beachygirl · 11/10/2017 00:49

I agree. Godparents have no obligation to care for children in the event of a parent's death. They commit to overseeing the child's spiritual development within their church.

peppapigearworm · 11/10/2017 08:48

Christening and baptism are two words for the same thing

no they are not.

StraussN · 11/10/2017 13:46

@Riversleep

Yes, despite the bible being the word of god, there's often just enough wiggle room to keep it closer to being palatable i.e. Genesis is a 'fable' now science has proved its nonsense.

drspouse · 11/10/2017 14:03

@peppapigearworm what's the difference according to you?
All churches that practice infant baptism call the service baptism.
Only parents/family call it christening. Not clergy.
My children were baptised as babies. The vicar and the service sheet called it baptism.
We got some christening cards to be fair but there is no different service called christening in any church.
CofE
"During a christening your child will be baptized with water. "

LapdanceShoeshine · 11/10/2017 14:09

My parents, in their wisdom, decided that 2 of my godparents should be my dad's aunt & uncle who were already ancient. Both died within about 5 years. What was the point of that?

(Prob explains why I lapsed so young Wink)

Shadowboy · 11/10/2017 14:14

We chose siblings as they are known well to my children, have similar stance on most aspects of life and won't come and go (hopefully) as friends might. I trust them too. Plus they we both christened/baptised- I'm not sure which of my friends were!? Says it all really- if I don't know that about my friends am I close enough for them to be Godparents?

peppapigearworm · 11/10/2017 18:07

Technically "baptism" is the rite in a Christian Church by which water symbolizes the washing away of sins and admission into the Church, whereas "christen" is to name (a baby) at baptism.

SparklyUnicornPoo · 11/10/2017 18:09

drspouse The difference is Christen means to name, it is when a child is given a name and welcomed into the church. Baptism in the Catholic church cleanses the child from original sin and is one of 7 sacraments/rites (Baptism, Reconciliation, Eucharist/First Communion, Confirmation, Marriage, Holy Orders and the Anointing of the Sick). The words are used pretty interchangeably in most churches but not in the Catholic Church.

Riversleep The church do still believe in purgatory, that's why there are bidding prayers for those who have died every mass, the actual word just doesn't seem to be used as often these days.

drspouse · 11/10/2017 18:36

Sparkly that was a copy and paste job and doesn't mean anything. There's no separate service to name and welcome. Baptism does that too.

SparklyUnicornPoo · 11/10/2017 19:12

No it really wasn't drspouse and what you mean is it didn't mean anything to you or you didn't understand what I was trying to say. Basically in most churches you get baptised as part of the christening, Catholic baptisms don't have the christening part. So all christenings are also baptisms but not all baptisms are christenings, kinda like how every Mass is a service but not every service is a Mass.

drspouse · 11/10/2017 19:18

So there is no such thing as a separate christening?
So what is it then?

Rachie1973 · 11/10/2017 19:25

I had my 4 christened, I made sure one of my own 3 siblings was a godparent to each, and my own children and now choosing their own siblings as godparents in turn.

Its just something we do in my family

peppapigearworm · 11/10/2017 19:26

you're wrong drspouse. Sparkly is right. Christenings are also baptisms, but you can have baptisms without christening. Adults are baptised but never christened.

SparklyUnicornPoo · 11/10/2017 19:39

drspouse It's an extra part to the baptism that Catholics don't get.

notanotherNC · 11/10/2017 20:34

God parents are weird full stop. The whole idea is fucked up indoctrination.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page