Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To write a really really terrible online review for our builder

6 replies

bakingdemon · 21/08/2017 17:39

We had one of those nightmare experiences of buying our new house/selling our previous one - first buyer pulled out on day of exchange, vendors & their solicitor were hopeless leading to long delays, vendors let themselves back into the house after completion, they still haven't forwarded their post, etc etc. I have found a lot of comfort in reading old MN threads where the same - and much worse - has happened to others!

Now we are about 3/4 through renovating the new house (BIG project - loft, side return, internal walls, plumbing, wiring etc) and I've had it up to here with our builders. They have:

  • continually increased the cost of the project, the latest being an email today which has added £10k out of nowhere
  • demanded that we order a whole bunch of stuff which wasn't on the client supply list, like data points and shaver sockets and all sorts of stuff I've never heard of but which we only wanted standard fittings for. This has taken us hours and hours and then there's always something else we should have known to order at the same time (nails for fence posts, screws for hinges) which he comes back and has a strop about
  • called our joiner behind our back to tell him that he couldn't come at the time we'd agreed two months earlier to start fitting shelves etc
  • refused to do things we've asked for and which were in the scope of works from the very beginning, like install an extractor fan and demolish an old shed in the garden
  • demanded lots of feedback by email and yet seemingly not read any of our emails to him (e.g. quibbling about not knowing the types of fans/oven which would need to be installed despite having been sent the client supply list with them on three times)
There is a lot more - he is incredibly petty and a total prima donna and there is something to be resolved/ordered/discussed/challenged every single sodding day. DH is ill with the stress of the project on top of work and wakes up every morning wanting to fire them. The builder has totally fallen out with our architect, who is also project managing. The only redeeming feature is that the work is really good quality and the end is in sight so although we have been close to firing him, we've so far just decided to grit our teeth and hope that he'll be out of our lives soon enough. I have been comforting myself with the thought on the online review I'll leave on Houzz (and anywhere else I can find he's listed) saying basically 'do not hire this guy'. Is it fair to do that? On the one hand, he's made our lives miserable. On the other, I would still feel a bit bad if he went out of business thanks to a review we left. AIBU? Or just being an idiot?
OP posts:
Booboobooboo84 · 21/08/2017 18:02

I think you need to be honest. If his work is of good quality make that literally the first line of your review. And then say however we did struggle with the day to day demands and feel he's a builder that needs to be project managed by someone with extensive experience

MyLittlePickleBoo · 21/08/2017 18:09

He won't go out of business over one review, but at least it will warn unsuspecting victims potential customers what they should be aware of if hiring him. I always read reviews when hiring workmen and would be so grateful if everyone were honest about their experiences. It might even make crappy trades people stop their crap and sort themselves out! (We can only hope!!)

bakingdemon · 22/08/2017 09:29

@MyPickleBoo it is staggering just how many people have a bad experience with their builders - my guess is that most of us just do this kind of thing once, so there's no incentive for them to build customer loyalty. Hopefully the growth of online networks like Houzz as a place for reviews might change that!

@Booboobooboo84 that's a good point. We are not experienced project managers and our architect has also let us down by not coming down on the builder like a ton of bricks from the start.

OP posts:
RedHelenB · 22/08/2017 09:42

I would be very glad the work is of such good quality. But Yes, mention the other bits too. Costs always go up on building projects don't they?

Fosterdog123 · 22/08/2017 09:47

I had a terrible builder and desperately wanted to warn others about them but I worried about repercussions to be honest.

kali110 · 22/08/2017 09:53

I'd have fired him! Yes leave him a bad review! This is awful.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page