Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Giving stuff to people

42 replies

Crapuccino · 17/04/2017 12:41

I have NCed for this since it's potentially outing.

Dripfeed version: we were given a bunch of stuff that was gross and needed a huge amount of cleaning/sorting. Skip to bottom for question...

Dropfeed version: we're expecting in a few weeks, and have been given heaps of baby stuff, for which I am beyond grateful. For context, stuff from A and B was freshly laundered, in good or great shape, i.e. I'd happily use that stuff outside of the house right out of the bag. Then C offered us all her leftover stuff, and again I was thrilled and accepted. Our schedules cross like ships in the night a lot, so it was easier for her to drop bags off outside our door (she lives very close by) whenever she'd got it sorted. In the first drop was about four half-binliners of clothes and I'd say half of them smelled strongly of mould. Absolutely nothing had been laundered. Dirty tops, trousers, knickers, everything. Some of it was really dirty - covered in mud, paint, food, play-doh, sellotape, stickers, and more. Some had been "modified" with scissors - literally sleeves/frills/whatever hacked off, threads left hanging, ragged zig-zag edges. About half the toys/books were damaged beyond use. Overall, it meant a massive clean-up operation before weeding out anything that still hadn't come out usable, but I figured people live different lives and got on with it. Then, more bags kept appearing - probably about four more altogether over the space of a week. Thankfully they were getting smaller - the last was a carrier bag - but the stuff was in increasingly poor shape to the point that the last lot went entirely into the bin. Latter items included books with 80% of the pages torn out, slot-on block things that were missing the main toy, a welly missing its mate, a pair of shoes, one with the main buckle snapped off, an opened bag of nappies that must have gotten damp since they were unused but were halfway-fat, the nuts and bolts for... something, a very out-of-date opened box of baby food, that kind of thing. At that point I actually started to feel a bit annoyed and was on the cusp of saying something but thankfully the "gifts" stopped.

To play devil's advocate on my own AIBU, after the clean-up operation, we did get a pretty decent haul - I'd say a stuffed-full binliner of clothes, and a carrier-bag full of toys and books. We ended up keeping about 50%, donating about 5% to charity shops that we just didn't like (not C's fault of course), and throwing the remainder away.

So... the AIBU, because I can't figure out if I'm being a precious arsehole: When you hand stuff over to others (e.g. baby clothes, maternity clothes, toys, etc.) do you make sure they're clean and ready to use? WIBU to start getting annoyed with the last few bags of stuff?

OP posts:
glueandstick · 17/04/2017 14:04

That's really lazy of her. I have to admit I won't give anything away and would rather it go to landfill after the experiences I've had. Including the charity shop sneering and sifting through and a friend requesting a photo of each piece so she could decide if it would suit her child.

photograph · 17/04/2017 14:05

I still wonder what kind of people keep dirty stuff, let alone give it away. Their house must be horrendous, yuk.

ImNegan · 17/04/2017 14:07

I love how you've tailored your post to reading-style requirements. "Drip-feed" and "drop-feed" is a great concept; I'd go so far as to say it's genius.
-grossly misses point-

GavelRavel · 17/04/2017 14:09

I'd be embarrassed to give my children stuff away in that condition. I've just scrubbed a load of wellies with fairly liquid and bleach in preparation to pass on. Clothes are washed and usually ironed. Everything i have ever received has at least been washed. You were an easier place to dump things that going to the dump.

SaveMeBarry · 17/04/2017 14:15

At first I thought maybe she mixed up bags for the dump with the bags she'd put aside for you but clearly not!

Yes she's used you as a convenient dump with the added bonus of being able to act like she did you a huge favour. Some people have hard necks. TBH I probably would have phoned after the first couple of bags and pretended I thought there had been a mix up i.e. rubbish to you, good stuff to dump in error but I've grown a harder neck over the years myself Wink

Now let's just hope you're not back here in 12 months:

AIBU - last year friend gave me lots of baby stuff. Now she says it was a loan and she wants it back. How do I tell her I binned half her grotty shite?

Grin
Crapuccino · 17/04/2017 14:30

Barry - Now let's just hope you're not back here in 12 months: AIBU - last year friend gave me lots of baby stuff. Now she says it was a loan and she wants it back. How do I tell her I binned half her grotty shite?

OP posts:
PicardsCombOver · 17/04/2017 14:39

I feel for you OP, I was told by a friend of a friend (who knew me locally) that her daughter had sacks and sacks full of boys clothes to give me. Well I was gobsmacked at the generosity, I didn't even know the lady. So the day comes when this lady (let's call her Jenny) had a time and date from her daughter (let's call her Karen) to drop off all the baby clothes. I waddled to the door and Karen had two black bags with her as promised and then drops this: 'Oh hiya, it's £20.00 for the lot, we're really struggling for money at the moment and we're about to go to the pub to watch the game' Hmm I was at no point told by Jenny that Karen was selling the baby clothes so being told I had to buy something was a shocker.
To make matters worse there was a used fucking sanitary towel stuck to one of the black bags and some dust/dirt which led me to wonder if she'd emptied rubbish bag and then reused it. Chancing cow.

Chloe84 · 17/04/2017 15:06

Did you give her the £20, Picard?

PicardsCombOver · 17/04/2017 16:17

Yes Chloe Sad

wizzywig · 17/04/2017 16:43

Yes i like the 2 versions too. Yes this happens to me from a more wealthier relative who was brought up with no money. So she was firmly of the opinion that fourth-hand designer clothing with holes in it was still ok because it was designer and kids should look bedraggled. I just used to chuck it in the recycling.

Willow2017 · 17/04/2017 17:19

I once got a bag of what was supposed to be clothes for my boys and it ended up as stuff meant for the rag bag collection at school😀 it was a genuine mistake friends kid gave me the wrong bag but by time I got to check it it was too late.

Never told her she would have been mortified all the other things she had passed on previously were perfectly fine😀

WankingMonkey · 17/04/2017 17:22

I would never give dirty stuff to people. Thats awful.

AnneElliott · 17/04/2017 17:28

I think that's grim. I wash and iron anything I give away and stuff with holes/stains gets out in the rag bag.

saucyxjack · 18/04/2017 05:26

I launder most stuff I'm taking to recycle into rags. No way would I ever give anyone dirty clothes.

TitaniasCloset · 18/04/2017 06:04

Wondering what her house is like? That's not normal. Even our local charity shop tells people not to leave crap. I sort through anything I donate to make sure its decent.

junebirthdaygirl · 18/04/2017 08:18

When l had my first baby a friend gave my dh a big bag of clothes while l was still in hospital..When l got home l cried when l saw the stuff as it was badly stained and grotty. No way was my newborn going into that. I had to keep the bag intact and gave it straigbt back as soon as she got pregnant again. I only ever passed on really good stuff. If there was any doubt l just dumped it. Baby clothes can be bought quite cheaply.

SecretNortherner · 18/04/2017 08:40

I got given loads of bits when I was pregnant, I always washed everything I was given, regardless of who gave it to me.
Maybe she thought even if it had a few marks on it would be useful? I passed a few bits of my sons on and one had a tiny little hole, I told them if they didn't want it to throw it.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page