Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have my Dad I wasn't happy with what he said to DD (15)

28 replies

Newname44 · 16/04/2017 17:59

I'm feeling like I need another perspective on this- it's petty I know but really festering for some reason:

The background: My parents come to stay a every couple of months. On the latest visit last week they arrived shortly after DD (15) had been in a minor car accident when her friend, who is lovely and sensible, was driving. The incident will probably end up being 50/50 blame. DD was shaken up and said she had a bit of a stiff neck for 2 days after the accident. She was then absolutely fine.

The issue- when my parents were staying, my Dad tried, more than once, to encourage DD to claim compensation for the accident. I know that there are legitimate circumstances where people have been properly injured where a claim is understandable, but my general feeling is that ambulance-chasers and those seeking compensation for non-existent or incredibly minor injuries (especially from an incident where a good friend was doing a favour) are pretty reprehensible.
The second time he brought it up I overheard my DD say to my Dad "I don't think Mum would like that" and he replied "it isn't up to your Mum". I later told my Dad that she was fine (which she then was), her friend was kind and sensible and that our values were such that we wouldn't want get money by those means.
Now: unfortunately my parents have never been ones to actually talk about anything, they have always give me the silent treatment when they are annoyed. This is what I am now experiencing- I called to wish them a happy Easter- my Dad answered and quickly made an excuse to call back later when and my Mum spoke with the children and then hung up. On past form I assume it is because I had the audacity to actually say I didn't feel putting in an injury claim for nothing was okay.

Am I missing something? I think it was particularly the "it isn't up to your Mum" comment which REALLY pissed me off and made me say something to Dad. AIBU?

OP posts:
CheeseCakeSunflowers · 16/04/2017 19:27

A quick google tells me that normally you have up to 3 years to make a claim. Someone under 18 cannot claim themselves, a parent has to claim for them but if the parent does not claim once the child reaches 18 they then have 3 years to claim themselves so dd has until she reaches 21 to decide.

Sleepybunny · 16/04/2017 19:40

Maybe I'm being daft, but is it not up to your daughter? I'd be worried about imposing my values on her too much and would let her make her own mind up. Give her all the facts and explain why you don't like it and why your dad wants her to claim.

Getting her to make her own decision might help her to see what the right thing is to do, rather than make decisions based on family politics.

YANBU

Mo55chop5 · 16/04/2017 19:56

Play your parents at their own game and cold shoulder them right back and the next time you do speak tell them to never undermine you again. I would be furious in your shoes and wouldn't hold back from telling them what I thought

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread