Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Birthday dilema

29 replies

mumontherun14 · 02/04/2017 22:17

My Dsis has stopped getting me and my DH birthday gifts for the past 2 years. Fair enough I thought as she doesn't have kids and always got gifts for my 2 kids. I still got her and her DH birthday cards and gifts and made a fuss on their bday. My mum is ill so I overcompensate a bit for that and like to do what my mum would have done and I know that is my own choice. However this year she didn't get anything for my DD such as a card or a gift even though she came along to her party. My DD didn't really notice at the time but I was a wee bit surprised as she usually always remembered the kids and she did get something for my DS on his bday. Now its her husbands birthday next week, She has mentioned a few times about it to me today when they were at mine for dinner and talked about us (ie me) getting a birthday cake for the restuarant when we are out for a meal next week (not something we usually do for the adults). I would normally always get my BIL a card and a voucher. Do I go ahead as normal or do I mention at all my DD's birthday. DD is 10 and they are pretty close which is why I am a wee bit surprised she has forgotten. I know she will defeintly get gifts for my 2 nieces in a months time and that will grate on me a bit. She did say to me at the time that she had a gift for DD but it has never appeared. She is a bit touchy about things my sis so I don't want to make a big deal of things but also feel things should be fair for the kids and cousins. I have posted about this before when she didn't acknowledge my DH's bday and the consencus on here was that adult birthdays weren't always recognised which I accept but now that it is my DD's I don't know if I should say something or not. I am thinking it is hard to broach things with her and we think differently about things and there are only the 2 of us (5 years age difference) so I would like to be closer. Am I being petty -is this even worth mentioning in a subtle way or do I just carry on as normal if my DD hasn't really noticed?

OP posts:
Leeds2 · 05/04/2017 20:43

No need to buy him a gift at all. And if DSis questions you, explain why you haven't.
No need to order a cake, as long as you are sure she knows that you aren't doing it.
And work out who, exactly, is paying for the birthday meal out.

Galla · 05/04/2017 20:52

I agree with everyone. If you must, a card to open if you meet for a birthday meal, but nothing else.

Strokethefurrywall · 05/04/2017 21:14

I don't understand all this pussy footing around someone who is "touchy" - why are you walking on eggshells? Just tell her no, you're not getting your BIL a cake, that's her sodding job!

Seriously, you seem scared of her, just ask her why she's expecting you to make a big fuss of a, presumably adult man when she either forgot or couldn't be bothered to make a fuss of her own niece's?

mumontherun14 · 06/04/2017 23:34

I have had a few run ins with her before where she has ended up very upset and I have thought I was being perfectly reasonable. I would describe her as highly strung at times and leaves me to deal with all the adult/hard things.....I guess we do walk on eggshells a bit. My mum was always the voice of reason between us but she has Alzheimer's/dementia so she can no longer talk sense into her. Some of the worst run ins we have had have been where I have asked her to help with my mum's care or been something to do with my mum. I don't know how to fix things as I'd love to be able to gently mention DD's birthday but I am worried she will kick off. For BILs birthday I will get a card some small chocs and we'll call/text him. My dad is paying for the meal he treats us all every once in a while so it leaves the cake up to her. I have been thinking about it a bit and while I said she was close with my DD it is all on her terms -she sees her once a month or so at family meals and seldom takes my 2 out and very rarely babysits (once a year and usually only if I am stuck). I don't want to sound too down on her she is a kind gentle family loving person but can also be opinionated and a bit of a spoiled princess. I feel like I need to lower my expectations with her for birthdays etc as others have pointed out -the other problem is that we also have a brother who lives away and he is always great at remembering us & kids bdays and we always do the same with them and swap gifts for adults/kids. So I feel a bit bad about not giving gifts to Dsis/BIL but at the same time hacked off with them for forgetting DD.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page