Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is the 'sisterhood' a myth?

35 replies

FairytalesAreBullshit · 27/03/2017 08:10

I read posts on here from women, or people who identify as female parents or just females, if their valid viewpoint, which they are entitled to as a human being, is disagreed with, it opens them up to all sorts of vitriol.

2 posts yesterday, one about parenting and dating with an infant, another those who had been knocked slightly by what they experienced on Mothers Day.

In particular, you had people going, 'Oh it's only a bloody Clintons Card day, why do you need validation on this day in specific, when parenting is much more.' Which is a valid view point. I offered the fact that when Mothering Sunday falls has little do to with the card and gift industry, stating the theological relevance, I got a 'hilarious' response back, put the bottle down love, it's not long past 12PM.

I know AIBU is a pit for those wanting to abuse others in such a way. There's offering a viewpoint, then there's being rather unpleasant at someone's expense. You wouldn't want either sex of child to behave in such a manner. What is it about certain boards that open people up for such comments?

I always add after stating a viewpoint that this is solely what I believe, it has no bearing on the validity of what others believe. A statement I hope awakens people to the fact we can all believe in different things, like fairies, or religion, politics, etc. I don't believe one persons beliefs outweighs another's.

If you take that away from feminism and apply it to humanity in general. In a discussion with a friend, they may state something outrageous they believe to be true, like fairies, you can offer an alternative view point without getting so personal.

You see it in lots of places, where the notion of 'the sisterhood' is mentioned. I wonder how many, that attribute themselves to holding feminist values, also think I can have a laugh at someone else's expense. Doesn't that go against the concept?

OP posts:
bignamechangeroonie · 27/03/2017 10:52

My view of the sisterhood is to (among other things) ; support women where I can, be feminist, not slag off how other women look, don't fuck attached men, help advance the rights of women, help my female children self determine.

This doesn't exclude me from debating and arguing.

theonlygeorgie · 27/03/2017 10:52

Who said the idea of 'sisterhood' is about agreeing with anyone who is a woman???!!! Nobody!!

Sisterhood: "an association, society, or community of women linked by a common interest, religion, or trade".

Eolian · 27/03/2017 10:55

I think it's a myth too. Women deserve equality with men because we are human beings, as men are. However, we are not inherently nicer (to each other or anyone else) than they are. There is plenty of evidence of that on MN and in rl.

PoorYorick · 27/03/2017 11:06

This is rather a pompous response to a few people disagreeing with you or gently taking the piss on an internet forum that's known for being a bit acerbic.

Is everything that happens to you of such global, humanity- wide significance? You remind me of someone. I've got the urge to take the piss a bit myself.

Pinkheart5915 · 27/03/2017 11:18

I hate it on here when someone comes to thread and says won't somebody think of the sisterhood.

Just because I am a women it does not mean I have to agree with every single thing a women says and it does not mean that I can't say she's being daft or a bit silly either.
I am a women that knows what her opinion on things are and I am allowed to say what I think

theonlygeorgie · 27/03/2017 11:19

Eh?

greenlipstick · 27/03/2017 11:31

Can I believe in feminism, hate the term sisterhood and think Mother's Day is commercialised bullshit? I bloody well think so!

Absintheshots · 27/03/2017 11:33

I don't even understand the concept of "sisterhood" frankly. So what, it's "us" against "them"? Them being men I suppose? It doesn't make any sense at all.I believe in people, I don't agree with judging them based on their gender/colour/ religion or language.

Some argue that women are generally more bitchy and unpleasant towards each other than men. Not sure it's strictly true either, do we need to judge all women in the same way?

I have been insulted on this forum because my opinion was too "harsh" or controversial (allegedly). I am so much more honest in real life, I don't tone it down nearly as much but things never turn into arguments because people also react to the tone of your voice and let you explain what you really mean. People get offended at the drop of a hat on this forum.

Werkzallhourz · 27/03/2017 12:04

I believe in the sisterhood, but I probably have a very wide interpretation of the notion.

To me, it is the desire and ability to view another female's situation from your own personal position as a female with female experiences.

In shorthand, it's more the "wwyd" rather than the "aibu".

To me, the sisterhood means that I bristle at a room full of men deciding maternity policy without a female present, even though that policy is for a country I do not live in. It's listening and talking through options with one of my female friends, even though I wouldn't have made the decisions that have led to her predicament in the first place.

And to be fair, mn is very good at this kind of thing outside of aibu.

Absintheshots · 27/03/2017 12:21

bristle at a room full of men deciding maternity policy without a female present

Whilst I kind of agree with you, it can also go horribly wrong. To go with this example, you are always going to have a mother explaining that she was back at her desk 2 days after giving birth so all mothers should just get on with it like she did.
I mean that there is not one female mindset, and find the concept to be more positive - or negative - towards a gender than another very strange.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.