Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to feel short-changed by this Godmother?

41 replies

thesoundofscreaming · 25/02/2017 23:12

Dh is from Italy. He and I are both religious, but DH's family approach baptism with a lot of pomp and circumstance (family church, priest in the family, family christening gown, huge ceremony, spend loads of money, everyone invited, massive meal in hired restaurant and people flying over from abroad.) I really quite enjoy the elaborateness of it all and with our other DC have taken the opportunity to ask my old female friends to be Godmother to show how much they mean to me.

With DS (DC no.4) Dh asked me if I would please let one of his oldest female friends be Godmother. I didn't know her very well and English is her third language, so communication with her in the past has been broken at best, but I wanted to make DH happy and wanted to affirm my positive support of DH's culture and his friends, non-verbally, considering I do not speak Italian well enough to have a strong connection with them, so agreed. I also hoped that it might be a way I could get to know her better or forge a friendship, like a gesture of goodwill.

Anyway, the day before the christening came. She and the Godfather (another friend of DH's) stayed over the night before the ceremony because the church is quite hard to get to. DH and I prepared a dinner for the four of us and drinks with both sets of Grandparents and the kids.

Dh's friend arrived and from the moment she got into the house, she completely walked past me. She greeted DH and his parents and then went to sit by the Godfather, ignoring me and my parents. My Ddad (80yo!) had practiced a few sentences in Italian to greet her, and he tried them out and she looked at him dismissively, corrected him, and walked off. I went up to her eventually and said hi in italian, making an effort, and she gave me a quick HI back. I took DS over (who she hadn't yet met) and she made a few noises but mostly ignored him. I didn't expect her to take him or to swoon over him or anything like that, but I did expect her to acknowledge somehow the reason she was there, and to touch base with me in some way.

I'd cooked dinner for us as a four, and DH's friend directed conversation at the Godfather only, and had turned her chair around to completely face him. Everything was in Italian so I couldn't really understand what was being said. Godfather and DH were occasionally translating the bits I didn't understand, but even DH was mostly left out of the conversation too.

Dh and I had made a big effort with the meal and were looking forward to reconnecting with the Godfather who we hardly see, and her. In fact, they talked so much, DH and I felt like we were intruding because they looked annoyed whenever we asked them anything, and so after dinner, we left the room early and they didn't notice and carried on drinking wine.

At around 2am when I got up to feed DS, I saw them stumbling up the steps together holding hands. The next day, DH went to get Godfather from his room because both were late for the baptism, and found them in the same bed.

She spent the entire day fixated on Godfather, moody with everyone else and trying to be alone with him again. When he went to speak to other guests or to carry DS, she got moody with him and stormed off out of the restaurant at one point. All very dramatic. She didn't want to hold DS for photos, got upset when he dribbled on her, and spent most of the time in the loos or trying to speak to Godfather.

AIBU to feel a bit shortchanged by the whole experience? Or am I putting too much importance on it? This whole culture takes it very seriously, so it's not like we were trying to impose our expectations of what the role should be. I feel now that I should have asked one of my friends to be Godmother because she obviously has no interest in DH, me or DS but now it's all done and that's her role and we're not going to do it again. DH says that's just what she's like and not to be offended - it's not personal. Godfather says it was just a one night stand and has fizzled out now.

OP posts:
MyKidsHaveTakenMySanity · 26/02/2017 10:06

Been playing with google translate and I think this little MN nugget would have been very appropriate:
hai intenzione di essere così maleducati?

MyKidsHaveTakenMySanity · 26/02/2017 10:10

I'm afraid I would have said very loudly in front of everyone, "Is she normally this rude to people or is it just me and my parents?" and then let DH or other Italian speakers translate for her when she wondered what you just said.

The best you can do in this situation is choose another godmother, have a quick, small ceremony at the church and don't make any secret of it.

notnowfrank · 26/02/2017 10:15

Another one who thinks your DH is really the first port of call for blame since he knew she was 'like that' and still gave her this significant responsibility, and, when she insulted your dad and flounced about the ceremony didn't take her to one side and tell her - in Italian - to get a grip.

mammmamia · 26/02/2017 10:18

Also feel so sad about the rudeness to your dad. I would never speak to her again let alone give her responsibility for the moral and spiritual guidance of my child! Totally inappropriate GM. Sorry OP.

emwantsbiscuits · 26/02/2017 10:19

YANBU it's such a privilege to be asked and she behaved appallingly.
I have more of a problem with her rudeness than the one night stand.
Your poor dad :( bless him for learning some phrases in Italian. What kind of person dismisses someone making an effort like that?!

JessieMcJessie · 26/02/2017 10:23

Shocked that your DH wintnessed her be so utterly rude to your aged father and STILL says "oh it's nothing personal". That is borderline unforgivable if your DH, has he no respect for your family?

WateryTart · 26/02/2017 10:27

I wouldn't want either of them back in my house. Both exhibited awful manners.

hollyisalovelyname · 26/02/2017 10:27

I would relieve her of her godmothering duties.
She will not get better at it.
She appears self obsessed.
How can your dh be friends with her?
She sounds horrible.

SuperFlyHigh · 26/02/2017 10:32

I'd not expect her to be a godmother but on the night I'd have had a word with your DH and then the godmother and told them both that her being godmother was rescinded.

Hopefully she'll be like 2 of my godparents whom my family don't see hide or hair of now!

AnotheBloodyChinHair · 26/02/2017 10:34

They have both behaved appallingly in you home and I would not want them involved in my kids lives in any way. Can you 'divorce' them and start again?

llangennith · 26/02/2017 10:35

DH knew "that's just the way she is" and still wanted her to be Godmother??!Confused
Your DS won't miss her.

XiCi · 26/02/2017 10:46

Was your DH romantically involved with her or is there some sort of history between them other than them just being friends?

Because to turn up at yours and DH house, completely ignore you and your family and fuck DH friend looks very like she is making some sort of point.

thesoundofscreaming · 26/02/2017 10:58

I agree about what she did making a point. I have always questioned internally whether there is history between her and DH but he has always denied it and said that the defining point of their friendship was that they were not involved with each other. DH and I are also friends with two other ex gfs of his so it's not like he keeps that stuff a secret from me.

OP posts:
XiCi · 26/02/2017 11:04

Maybe she has feelings for him then and he just hasn't realised. She sounds toxic and I would be making every attempt to cut her out of your lives, godmother or not

DearMrDilkington · 26/02/2017 11:11

Why on earth did she agree to be godmother when she clearly doesn't like children very much?Confused

PyongyangKipperbang · 26/02/2017 14:25

he has always denied it and said that the defining point of their friendship was that they were not involved with each other.

There is your problem right there. Either she always wanted something to happen with him or she placed herself above you in the hierarchy of his close relationships and either way was pissed off that the day wasnt in fact about the two of them. I also wonder if the ONS was about a) stealing your thunder and b) making DH jealous.

I would be rescinding the Godmothership immediately and having words of the loud shouty kind with DH if he didnt see why it must happen.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread