Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU in wanting my best friend at my birthday party?

36 replies

NoSunNoMoon · 05/11/2016 07:07

DH and I both have landmark birthdays in the new year. We don't normally go in for big celebrations but decided we would for once. Our DCs have grown up and left home as have the DCs of our close friends and families. We thought it would be lovely to get the old crowd together. We are still all friends but more scattered now. DH and I still live in the place where we were brought up. We have made a provisional booking of the village hall and some caterers.

A and I have been best friends since we were 5. She began dating DH's brother not long after DH and I got together. We got married and had DCs and so did they. 15 years into the marriage A's DH had an affair and after a messy few months prevaricating he left her for the OW. It was a horrible time. We managed to tread the fine line of staying friends with both of them. BiL and OW married 10 years ago. OW hasn't been the most loving of step mothers and for a while the DCs refused to see their dad but it's been glossed over now and pretty civilised.

A was heartbroken but time heals and she is now married to a lovely man who was instrumental in healing the rift between the DCs and their DF.

BiL has told DH that his DW says that she won't come if A is there and that he feels he won't be able to either, in that case. DH wants his DB there but it's his choice not to come and A has been more than a sister to me for many years.

I'm going to sound like a bitch now but the years have not been as kind to BiL's DW as they have to A. A's DH is very well off and since they married her lifestyle has changed dramatically from the early struggles when her marriage broke up and she had to fight for money for the DCs. Bil's DW is jealous of her change of circumstances and often makes barbed remarks.

DH and I rarely argue but we are about this. He says family should come first, despite us being close friends with A and her DH. I've said invite all and if some choose not to come then that's up to them.

AIBU?

OP posts:
paranormalish · 05/11/2016 07:54

Your BiL has made his bed, he needs to lie in it.

Ledkr · 05/11/2016 07:56

I hate this. I had a very difficult time when my xh left me for a younger model but we have all grown up and matured and I'm so happy with dh so why would I feel even a stitch of animosity towards them?
We are off to their fireworks display later, so much easier than wasting so much energy on being mean.
Just invite them all and let them decide.
It sounds as if karma has done her job nicely here for once and Bil and his wife know it Grin

NoSunNoMoon · 05/11/2016 07:57

They have all been in the same place many times over the years. A has never had a problem putting her feelings aside for the sake of family. This is quite a small community so they are going to bump into each other a lot of the time. They have always been polite to each other after the initial break and bad feelings. I'm pretty sure SiL feels she's never been truly accepted and she may be right, to be fair to her. DH's mum had no time for her and as she got older didn't hide her feelings.

Not sure why she's throwing a fit this time but it's not going to work.

The wisdom of MN had spoken and I'll tell DH that when he wakes up.

OP posts:
blueturtle6 · 05/11/2016 08:02

Tell A, as if she could turn up an hour later if she's agreeable and tell bil/ow they can leave early if they don't wish to be in same room.
A then gets the best of party, and you fulfil family obligations
Yanbu to also want a there

Ahickiefromkinickie · 05/11/2016 08:03

A's DH has charisma in spades and is totally unaware of it. She says she pinches herself hard every morning Smile

Be still my beating heart 😍

Love a happy ending!

ChimpyChops · 05/11/2016 08:10

YANBU as everyone else has said :)
Invite all but let them know, they have to be together at future events in their children's lives surely? If my other half didn't agree I would tell him to have his party but me and my best friend will be off on a little getaway together!

NoSunNoMoon · 05/11/2016 08:19

DH has caved. He knows he was wrong but those words haven't passed his lips, obviously.

All invited. BiL to be told it's up to him whether he comes with or without his DW.

I love MN.

OP posts:
LetsAllEatCakes · 05/11/2016 08:32

Good news op. Given your bil was the wrong un in the relationship anyway he didn't have a leg to stand on. His wife needs to get over herself too. She was the ow and a shitty step mum. They should be glad that it's all been smoothed over, A could have held a real grudge and made things hard.

Sounds like A got the best deal of them all.

mysistersimone · 05/11/2016 09:12

Most excellent outcome! Well done. I freaking love that A met a Prince charming and the OW sounds like a hag. BIL and his harlot just have to suck it up really. They can have a nice chat about A's globe trotting mwah haa haa

FrancisCrawford · 05/11/2016 10:21

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

CustardShoes · 05/11/2016 10:37

YANBU

Your BiL chose to cheat on his first wife, your friend. His 2nd wife, as OW, has no right to dictate who is at your party.

Have a lovely time!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread