Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to force DD to go to preschool?

42 replies

manateeandcake · 10/10/2016 13:24

I don't think I am but posting here for traffic as DH and I are at our wits' end.

DD is nearly 4, normally happy and confident though also strong-willed and emotional. In September she started in the preschool/nursery class of our local primary; full time place i.e. 9am-3pm. It appears to be a lovely place. She knew for months she was going there and was excited. Previously, she had been attending a local nursery for first 2, then 3 days a week. She'd gone through periods of being upset at drop off there but was basically very settled. We didn't anticipate any major problems with the change.

During settling in at the new school, she was quite clingy and unsure about me leaving, but also obviously enjoying exploring and getting to know the teachers. Several friends from her old nursery are in her new class. It was all done gradually and although she would be upset at the moment of me or DH leaving, we were assured that she cheered up immediately. Then she went through a period of saying goodbye fairly happily with a wave and smile.

Then suddenly last week, she started refusing to go in the morning. This coincided with her having a cold and sore throat, but her temperature was normal and she was lively at home so we decided she should still go. Since then, it has taken us 25 - 40 minutes to get here there (a 5 minute walk normally). Her throat is now fine, by the way. She cries and screams that she doesn't want to go, begs to stay at home, tries to get back into the house etc. It's unbelievably awful. I can't physically carry her when she's struggling, but I did have to carry her downstairs and force her shoes on this morning. I then got her there by a mix of persuasion and just walking ahead leaving her no choice but to follow, but it took half an hour. Everyone walking past is staring at us and listening to her begging me not to make her go. On arrival at the school, she has to be restrained by the teachers while I leave. I then just walk away and burst into tears myself.

The thing is, the teachers assure me that once we've left her, she settles brilliantly, plays with friends, chats, joins in, eats a good lunch ... in other words, she's fine. I believe this and I can tell by things she tells me that she's enjoyed herself. So I think the furore in the mornings as about the separation from me and DH rather than anything going on at school -- when I ask her why she doesn't want to go, she either can't say or says "Because I will miss you." Our instinct is that we have to keep getting her there, however hard it is. I just feel awful: angry with her, guilty, sad, and at a loss to know how to make this better. If anyone has any experience of this situation, I'd love to hear it.

OP posts:
WordGetsAround · 12/10/2016 19:57

At 3, I think 5 days a week is far too much - especially as it's not strictly necessary. How about a more balanced week? My 3 year old is massively confident and outgoing and goes three (non-consecutive) days a week and really likes it - but loves his days home with me even more.

MistresssIggi · 12/10/2016 20:03

Why three days of your time at home though, I think anyone would understand wanting her to go for a day so you can have one on one time with the 1 year old (or just for a bit of a break) but most people who work part time do it so the children don't have to be in full time childcare. Or am I missing something here?

Ohdearducks · 12/10/2016 20:06

What about a reward system, make a chart and get some favourite stickers, each day she goes to school without a fuss she can put a sticker on her chart, when she's done 5 days in a row she can choose a small treat. If she can manage this it will indicate that she can actually control herself in the mornings but is actually choosing to kick off in the hope of getting her own ear rather than being truly distressed at going in.

Ohdearducks · 12/10/2016 20:07

Way not ear 🙈

deathandtaxes123 · 12/10/2016 20:15

What's going to happen when she starts school and you're not able to take her out (unless you're home schooling) ?

She's going through a phase where she's related nursery to feeling unwell I presume.

Stick with it, she'll get over it and be fine. I'm not a big believer in "weeching weans oot" (good
Glasgow vocab there) unless there's a seriously good reason they can't stay and unfortunately I don't think a tantrum warrants this.

I can be pretty hardline though!

WordGetsAround · 12/10/2016 20:48

But she'll be 4, nearly 5 when she goes to school - much older than now. I've never understood the argument of doing something early because you'll have to do it eventually.

Marcipex · 12/10/2016 21:24

Glad to hear it's getting better manatee.

MistresssIggi · 12/10/2016 21:31

I think keeping a three year old with a cold and sore throat off nursery when you don't have to go to work is a complete no brainer.

manateeandcake · 13/10/2016 09:45

MistresssIggi That is all in the past now, but I should make it clear that said three year old was dancing around at home, at a good breakfast, and when she went to nursery had plenty of energy and only mentioned her sore throat once all day. She then insisted she was well enough to go to her favourite (physical) activity after school which she participated in happily. Not sending her would have sent the message that she can use (or create) a minor ailment to avoid going.

As for what I need to do during the day, I say that as irrelevant; if DH and I thought she was properly ill, we would not send her regardless of our own plans.

OP posts:
Zippidydoodah · 13/10/2016 09:54

I also agree it's madness to send a 3 year old to full time preschool. It won't be long before she has to go to full time school, so while she's little, why on earth not let her have some days off?

Zippidydoodah · 13/10/2016 09:55

My friend remembers hating preschool and being forced to stay. I really really wouldn't make her, unless I absolutely had to. 5 days a week, 9-3, is hard for my reception ds who is already 5, let alone a 3 year old.

manateeandcake · 13/10/2016 10:12

I am the OP.

For those who have the read the whole thread, I want to restate that DD is now walking to school happily. She continues to talk enthusiastically and proudly about her day there. Her teachers continue to assure us that she is very settled and happy once there.

Thanks to all those who have left supportive comments and suggestions.
To those who are using the thread to leave more judgemental comments about our decision to send DD to preschool: I'm sure you make the best possible childcare decisions for your families, just as we are doing.

OP posts:
MistresssIggi · 13/10/2016 12:44

OP you did post an aibu asking if you were unreasonable to force your dd to go to preschool. No surprise really that people post their opinions about her being sent to preschool. Confused

NickiFury · 13/10/2016 13:13

I'm always pleasantly surprised at how quickly problems get resolved after posters are initially at their "wits end". Usually it coincided with them getting loads of opinions they don't agree with. Anyway at least she's happy now OP but still think it's unnecessary for her to be there as long as she is.

Zippidydoodah · 13/10/2016 13:15

OP you did post an aibu asking if you were unreasonable to force your dd to go to preschool. No surprise really that people post their opinions about her being sent to preschool. confused

This!!

You asked AIBU?

Yes, YABU!

But it's none of my business.

Except for the fact that you asked if you were bu to "force" your dd to go to preschool, and I, as well as others, think you are.

justgivemeamo · 13/10/2016 13:16

oP My 3/4 year old digs in - I back off and after a while she comes to it in her own time I wonder if you are able to forget it for a week - then try again?

manateeandcake · 13/10/2016 14:19

The thread title was a mistake, I realise. I was emotional and being a bit masochistic as a result. Oh well -- live and learn!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread